Meek v. ParkerMeek v. Parker
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Riddick
(after stating the facts). The only question here is whether, under the facts proved, the plaintiffs are entitled to a lien. If they have a lien, it is not disputed that it takes precedence of the debt secured by the trust deed. The lien claimed by the plaintiffs was for work and materials furnished for improvements upon two separate tracts of lands. It is not alleged or shown that the materials for the separate improvements were furnished under an entire contract. But the court adjudged that the aggregate amount claimed by plaintiffs was a lien upon both tracts of land, and ordered them sold, with the improvements thereon, to pay said debt. The materials furnished for the improvement of one tract of land did not create a lien upon the other tract, when the same were not furnished under an’ entire contract. It is obvious therefore that the judgment is, to that extent, erroneous.
Among the materials furnished for which a lien is claimed were two steel wrenches, fifty feet of rubber belting, also certain “dry kiln wheels and boxes.” It is contended that these articles were not “materials, machinery or fixtures furnished for any building, erection or other improvement upon land,” within the meaning-, of ’ our statute. The wrenches were not in any way-attached to the real estate, nor were they a necessary part of
Were plaintiffs entitled to a lien for the value of the “dry kiln wheels and boxes furnished by them?” Our statute provides that every person who shall “furnish any materials, machinery, or fixtures for any building, erection, or other improvement upon land, * * * * under or by virtue of any contract expressed or implied with the owner or proprietor thereof, * * * * shall have for his materials, machinery, or fixtures furnished a lien upon such building, erection, or improvement, and upon the land belonging to such owner or proprietor on which the same is situated, to secure the payment of such materials, machinery, or fixtures furnished.” Sand. & H. Dig., § 4731.
This statute was not intended to give a lien upon personal property. To entitle the material man to a lien under this statute, the material or machinery furnished must as a rule be attached to or become a part of the improvement or building upon land, or must be used in making such improvement. But the testimony shows that these dry kiln wheels and boxes were designed and built expressly for use in the dry kiln of the lumber company. This dry kiln was a long shed boarded up on both sides and covered over the
But the use of these wheels and axles was confined to the tramway of this particular dry kiln, and we are of opinion that, although not actually fastened thereto, they were, in law, constructively attached, and a part of the building, within the meaning of the act above
The lumber company held the tract of land, upon which their saw-mill, boiler, engine, dry house, etc., was situated, under a lease for a term of years. It is contended that the improvements for which the materials were furnished, being placed upon leased land, must therefore be treated as personal property, and that no lien attaches to such land for materials furnished for the making of such improvements. But this contention cannot be sustained. “ The estates of tenants for terms of years a’re liable for the improvements made by them upon the demised premises. The lien extends to their entire interest under the lease, but does not affect the reversion of the lessor, unless he, by some act of his own, has obligated -his estate.” Phillips, Mechanics’ Liens, sec. 191; White v. Chaffin, 32 Ark. 59; McCullough v. Caldwell, 5 ib. 238; Paulsen v. Manske, 9 Am. State Rep. 532, and note.
The last item upon the account of appellees was. furnished April 2, 1894. The account not being paid on that day, the appellees accepted the note of the lumber-company payable in thirty days in settlement of said account. They afterwards transferred this note to J. M. Bailey, but, the note not being paid at maturity, the appellees repaid to Bailey the amount of the note, and he re-assigned it to them. It is contended that this note was accepted in payment of the account, and that the lien
It appears to us that the plaintiff is entitled to a judgment and lien upon the property for some amount,