Medical Practice Solutions, LLC v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueMedical Practice Solutions, LLC v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Gustafson
Held: R abused his discretion in determining to proceed with collection without making the requisite verification under
Carolyn Britton, pro se.
Louise R. Forbes, for respondent.
MEMORANDUM OPINION
GUSTAFSON, Judge: This case is an appeal under
Background
At the time Ms. Britton filed her petition, she resided in Massachusetts.
Medical Practice‘s Nonpayment of Self-Reported Payroll Taxes
Ms. Britton was the sole member of Medical Practice for the calendar quarters ending September 30, 2006, December 31, 2006, and June 30, 2007. Medical Practice timely filed its Forms 941, Employer‘s Quarterly Federal Tax Return, for each of those quarters. However, Medical Practice left unpaid some of the tax liabilities reported on each of those returns.
Collection Procedures
On December 10, 2007, the IRS issued to Ms. Britton (i.e., in her name only) a Final Notice of Intent to Levy and Notice of Your Right to a Hearing for the two quarters ending December 31,
On February 19, 2008, an IRS appeals officer6 sent a letter to Ms. Britton scheduling her CDP conference for March 4, 2008. On March 3, 2008, Ms. Britton‘s attorney-in-fact, requested a
Following the CDP hearing, the appeals officer researched the lien issue and determined that the lien had been properly filed against Ms. Britton because Medical Practice is a disregarded entity. During the course of the appeals officer‘s research he discovered that Ms. Britton had petitioned this Court with respect to a notice of determination for prior tax periods of Medical Practice. Those other periods were still under the jurisdiction of the IRS‘s Office of Chief Counsel and this Court. As a result, the appeals officer phoned Ms. Britton‘s attorney-
On May 9, 2008, the Office of Appeals issued to Ms. Britton two separate Notices of Determination Concerning Collection Action(s) Under
The Commencement of This Case
On June 16, 2008, Ms. Britton timely petitioned this Court to review the notices of determination. The petition alleges seven points of error, as follows:
- The IRS refused to consider a Settlement Agreement.
- The IRS wants to levy against Carolyn Britton without first assessing her or making a demand for payment.
- The IRS has improperly filed tax liens against Carolyn Britton personally without following proper procedure.
- The IRS check the box rules, under which the IRS justifies b. and c. above, are invalid.
- Carolyn Britton is not personally liable for any employment taxes; Medical Practice Solutions, LLC is liable.
- The IRS notices were sent to the wrong taxpayer at the wrong address.
- Carolyn Britton‘s home should be released from the tax liens because she was not assessed for any taxes, and there is no equity in the home for the junior tax liens to attach.
Thus, Ms. Britton‘s contentions in her petition involve three issues: (1) whether the appeals officer erred in refusing to consider a collection alternative (issues (a) and (g)7),
Respondent‘s Motion for Summary Judgment
On January 16, 2009, respondent moved for summary judgment. To support the motion, respondent relied on a declaration of the appeals officer with seven exhibits: Exhibits A and B (the two notices of determination at issue here), Exhibits C through F (about which the declaration states, “My determination was made after reviewing the following documents“),9 and Exhibit G (his
Ms. Britton was ordered to respond to the motion for summary judgment but did not do so even after being granted an extension of time.
The Court later denied respondent‘s motion for summary judgment as moot, in view of the parties’ submission of the case under Rule 122, as explained below. (If the motion had instead been considered on its merits, it would have been denied for the same reasons that decision is rendered here for Ms. Britton.)
Submission of the Case
On March 16, 2009, this case was called at the Court‘s session in Boston, Massachusetts, and Ms. Britton appeared pro se. Ms. Britton expressed a desire for more time to prepare her case. The Court advised Ms. Britton that, consistent with the notice the Court had issued 5 months earlier, the case would proceed to trial unless the case could be fully stipulated. Ms. Britton agreed that the case could be submitted without a trial. Ms. Britton and respondent then jointly moved under Rule
As a result, neither party offered any additional evidence. In particular, respondent did not offer testimony of the appeals officer explaining his verification under
Post-Trial Filings
The stipulated documents include an account transcript for Medical Practice (generated after the agency-level CDP process and during this litigation) for one of the three taxable quarters at issue—i.e., the quarter ending December 31, 2006—but the stipulated documents do not include account transcripts for the other two taxable quarters, ending September 30, 2006, and June 30, 2007.10 Accordingly, Ms. Britton stated in her opening
On May 29, 2009, respondent filed a motion to reopen the record for the purpose of admitting into evidence Forms 4340, Certificate of Assessments, Payments, and Other Specified Matters, for Medical Practice‘s tax quarters ending September 30, 2006, December 31, 2006, and June 30, 2007, the three quarters in suit. The Forms 4340 were dated May 28, 2009 (a year after the Office of Appeals issued the notices of determination). In this motion respondent acknowledged “that there is no evidence in the record as it exists to verify that the assessments and notice and demands were properly made“, but respondent argued that remand would be unnecessary if the Forms 4340 were admitted into evidence to show the assessments were properly made and notices properly sent. Ms. Britton opposed respondent‘s motion to reopen the record.
Discussion
I. Collection Review Procedures in the Code
A. Agency-Level Action
If a taxpayer fails to pay any Federal income tax liability after notice and demand, chapter 64 of the Code provides two means by which the IRS can collect the tax: First,
However, Congress has added to chapter 64 of the Code certain provisions (in subchapter C, part I, and in subchapter D, part I) as “Due Process for Liens” and “Due Process for Collections“. The IRS must comply with those provisions after filing a tax lien, and before proceeding with a levy. Within five business days after filing a tax lien, the IRS must provide written notice of that filing to the taxpayer.
The pertinent procedures for the agency-level CDP hearing are set forth in
B. Judicial Review
If the taxpayer is not satisfied with the determination of the Office of Appeals, the taxpayer may “appeal such determination to the Tax Court“.
II. Respondent‘s Lien and Proposed Levy Cannot Be Sustained
Although Ms. Britton‘s case is very weak both as to her now-obvious liability for the taxes at issue13 and the apparent lack of merit in her contentions about collection alternatives,14 we
A. The Hearing Record Does Not Show Verification as Required By Section 6330(c)(1).
Independent of any issue raised or argument made by the taxpayer,
- the IRS‘s timely assessment of the liability,
secs. 6201(a)(1) ,6501(a) ; - the taxpayer‘s failure to pay the liability,
secs. 6321 ,6331(a) ; the giving to the taxpayer of notice and demand for payment of the liability, sec. 6303 , before any levy,sec. 6331(a) ; and- the giving to the taxpayer of notice of intent to levy,
secs. 6330(a)(1) ,6331(d)(1) , or notice of the filing of a Federal tax lien,sec. 6320(a)(1) , and of the taxpayer‘s right to a hearing,secs. 6320(a)(3)(B) ,6330(a)(3)(B) ,6331(d)(4)(C) .
If those requirements have been met, then the appeals officer can proceed to consider the other collection and liability issues. But if those basic requirements have not been met, then collection cannot proceed, and the appeals officer cannot sustain the proposed collection action. In view of the mandatory nature of the verification requirement, “this Court will review the Appeals officer‘s verification under
Where the taxpayer in a lien or levy case before this Court contends that the appeals officer failed to obtain the requisite verification under
An attachment to the notice of determination states, “With the best information available, the requirements of various applicable law or administrative procedures have been met“. This statement is ambiguous at best in two respects: First, the reference to “the best information available” might mean that adequate information was not available and that he was settling for inadequate information. Second, it is unclear what he considered when he verified (in his phrase) “the requirements of various applicable law or administrative procedures” (emphasis added) and how that compares to “the requirements of any applicable law or administrative procedure“, as
The record does show verification of the fourth requirement listed above, i.e., issuance of notice of intent to levy and
As is noted above, the attachments to the notices of determination do indicate that the appeals officer consulted transcripts.19 We have seen cases in which appeals officers have relied on transcripts to verify assessments, and we have said that it is reasonable for them to do so. See Nestor v. Commissioner, 118 T.C. 162, 166-167 (2002) (appeals officer does not abuse his discretion when, to obtain the verification required by
However, the attachments state that the appeals officer consulted transcripts to verify notice and demand to pay unpaid balances; they do not state that he verified the fact and timeliness of assessments by consulting transcripts or otherwise.
B. The Record Will Not Be Reopened to Admit the Missing Information.
Respondent would cure the defects in the appeals officer‘s verification by having the Court reopen the court record to admit Forms 4340. We assume that the Forms 4340 that respondent belatedly presents do indeed include information that, if it had been consulted by the appeals officer, would have shown him “that the requirements of any applicable law or administrative procedure have been met“—in particular, that the assessments were timely made, that the IRS did issue notices and demands for payment, and that the liabilities were not fully paid at the time the notices of determination were issued. Reopening the record to receive additional evidence is a matter within the discretion of the trial court, Zenith Radio Corp. v. Hazeltine Research, Inc., 401 U.S. 321, 331 (1971); Butler v. Commissioner, 114 T.C. 276, 286-287 (2000); but in this case we will not exercise our discretion to admit the Forms 4340 that could have been introduced before the record closed but were not.
First, the evidence respondent now proffers would not change the outcome of the case. As we held in Butler v. Commissioner, supra at 287, the Court “will not grant a motion to reopen the record unless * * * the evidence is material to the issues involved, and the evidence probably would change the outcome of the case.” Strictly speaking, the determinative issue here is not whether legal and procedural requirements were met (an issue for which the Forms 4340 would be probative); rather, the issue is whether the Office of Appeals, before it determined in May 2008 to proceed with collection, verified that legal and procedural requirements were met. Forms 4340 generated after the CDP hearing could properly be offered to explain information that the appeals officer did obtain in the hearing and simply failed to put into the record; but in light of the ambiguity in the settlement officer‘s statements and the absence of any other evidence to show that he did in fact obtain verification, the Forms 4340 respondent now offers would not aid us in resolving the issue before us. The Forms 4340 would only show information that (as far as we can tell) the settlement officer failed to obtain in making his verification.
For these reasons, we decline to allow the Forms 4340 to be admitted into evidence. Respondent‘s motion to reopen the record will be denied.
C. The Case Will Be Remanded.
In her brief the pro se petitioner requests that we remand this case to the Office of Appeals, so that the appeals officer “can supplement the record with whatever he used to complete his verification“. We do have the discretion to remand a case to the Office of Appeals for consideration of a matter that was inadequately considered in the CDP hearing, and there are circumstances in which a remand is appropriate to clarify a verification under
An appropriate order will be issued.