McGrath v. Alger

57 N.Y.S. 519 | N.Y. App. Div. | 1899

PER CURIAM.

Pending the appeal from the order of the special term granting an inspection of certain books and papers, and before compliance with the order, the action has been tried, and has resulted in a judgment in favor of the plaintiff. We should not entertain the appeal at all, were it not that the order below imposed $10 costs absolutely on the plaintiff. This should not have been done. The costs awarded to the defendant should have been made to abide the event of the action. Under the circumstances, we think the proper course to pursue now is to reverse the order of the special term, without costs to either party, and without prejudice to a renewal of the motion in case a new trial of the action should be granted.