McDaniels v. Wheeler

64 Iowa 678 | Iowa | 1884

Rothrock, Ch. J.

It is provided in section 2581 of tbe Code that *c when, by its terms, a written contract is to be performed in any pai’ticular place, action for the breach thereof may be brought in the county wherein such place is situated;” and under section 2586 it is provided that, except when otherwise provided, personal actions may be brought in any county wherein some of the defendants actually reside. As the notes provided for payment at a place in Cass county, the action was properly brought against Martin and Henry Wheeler in that county. By the terms of their contract, they agreed to perform it in Gass county. The question is, did Hiram Wheeler so agree by the terms of his contract? His contract was not in writing. He made a verbal agreement with the makers that he would pay the notes. His liability is upon his verbal agreement, and this action is for a breach of his verbal contract, and not for the breach of a written contract. There can be no recovery against him by the mere production of the notes. Liability must be established against him by proving his parol contract, and the liability, if any, is upon that contract, and not upon the notes. It is true that, when the contract is established, the notes may be resorted to to ascertain the amount of his liability, but for no other purpose.

We think the statute authorizes an action to be brought against non-residents of the county only in cases where the liability arises upon some written instrument signed by the defendant in the action. The case of Corbett v. Waterman, 11 Iowa, 86, and other eases cited by appellee, which hold that a purchaser of mortgaged property may bind himself by an agreement to pay the mortgage debt, and that such agreement may be enforced by the mortgagee, do not determine the question now under.discussion. This is purely a personal action, and the question as to the liability of Hiram Wheeler is not involved in this inquiry. In our opinion, the motion to change the place of trial should have been sustained.

Reversed.