McCracken v. PeopleMcCracken v. People
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Wilkin
delivered the opinion of the court:
The plaintiffs in error, Ole G. McCracken and Enos E. McEldowney, were indicted by the grand jury of Cook county charged with larceny as bailees. The indictment alleged that the plaintiffs in error, on the first day of April, 1901, fraudulently and feloniously did embezzle and fraudulently convert to their own use a large amount of personal goods, funds, money and property, (describing
The facts in the case are substantially as follows: Henry M. Ramey was an old man about seventy-five years of age, who lived in Ohio and had an incurable disease. He was desirous of going to Chicago and getting into the Home for Incurables, situated in the southern portion of the city, which is an institution for the care of elderly people who are afflicted with incurable diseases. If, at the time of the admission of patients, they are able to do so, they are expected to pay at least something to the home, the amount depending altogether on the particular case. Ramey had a niece in Chicago,—a Mrs. Amelia Browder, who lived in the same building and on the same floor with the defendant McEldowney, and they were intimate friends. There was considerable ‘talk between McEldowney and Mrs. Browder, and between the former and the defendant McCracken, with reference to getting the old gentleman into the home. In several of such conversations it was suggested that the old gentleman bring at least $300 with him when he came from Ohio fqr the purpose of securing his admission, and such a request was written to Ramey by his niece, Mrs. Browder. Some two’ or
The first ground of reversal insisted upon is that the indictment is insufficient, in that it fails to allege the facts which constituted the bailment, and the case of Johnson v. People, 113 Ill. 99, is relied upon as
Objection is next made to the refusal of instructions numbered 1, 3 and 4£ asked by the defendants, and to the giving of the seventeenth at the instance of the People. Those refused were drawn upon the theory that Harney was not the owner of the property at the time of the alleged embezzlement. They did not correctly state the law applicable to the facts in the case, and for that reason were properly refused. But in addition to this fatal objection to each of them, the fourth requested by the defendants, and given as modified, correctly stated all the elements constituting the crime charged and necessary to be proved. The objection to the seventeenth instruction given on behalf of the People is, that it specifically points out the accused and calls attention to” their testimony, stating that if they have willfully and corruptly testified falsely to any fact material to the issue the jury had the right to entirely disregard their testimony, etc. The contention is, that it erroneously calls particular attention to the defendants instead of relating to the witnesses generally. It is substantially in the language of instructions approved in Hirschman v. People, 101 Ill. 568, Leigh v. People, 113 id. 372, and Siebert v.
Complaint is next made of certain statements made by the State’s attorney, in his closing argument to the jury, with reference to the insolvency of plaintiffs in error. A contract was introduced in evidence by plaintiffs in error, signed by them, in which they agreed to furnish certain clothing and care for the body of Ramey at his death. This contract was delivered to the home at the time Ramey was admitted. It appears from the evidence that for one year after his admission plaintiffs in error had not paid anything for clothing or other necessaries under that contract, and upon the argument before the jury their counsel insisted that the $100 which they had each retained was in consideration of the obligation which they had assumed in signing said contract. In reply to this argument, and in discussing the evidence in the case, the State’s attorney made the remarks complained of. We think, from an examination of the argument of counsel on either side, the remarks objected to were not improper, but were in reply to those which had been made by counsel for the defendants.
It is also insisted that the verdict is not supported by the evidence, and for that reason the judgment of conviction should be reversed. It was admitted by both of the defendants that out of the $300 they each received $100. Ramey testified that he gave the money or draft to McEldowney, with instructions to pay it to the home when he (Ramey) was admitted, and that McEldowney agreed to do so. He further testified that he had numerous conversations with both defendants upon the same subject, in each of which the money was mentioned, they agreeing to pay the $300 to the home, and also that on at least one occasion he stated to McEldowney that he hoped to be able toAeward him for his trouble in assisting him in getting into the home, and McEldowney replied, “I am not working for money, and all I wish is to assist you to get
It is insisted by counsel for McCracken that he was wrong-fully convicted, for the reason that the $300 was received by McEldowney, and on the day Ramey was taken to the home he paid McCracken $100, and that no part of the $300 was in the latter’s hands until that time, and that he is not, therefore, guilty as charged in the indictment. It is the law of this State that he who stands by and aids, abets or assists, or who, not being present, aiding, abetting or assisting, hath advised, encouraged, aided or abetted the perpetration of a crime, shall be considered a principal and punished accordingly. We think the evidence before the jury warranted the conclusion that the defendants acted and co-operated together in the conversion to their own use of the $200. It is therefore unimportant which one of them actually received the money from Ramey.
On the whole record we find no substantial grounds of reversal, and the judgment of the criminal court of Cook county will accordingly be affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.