Mauldin v. BurnetteMauldin v. Burnette
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Owens
ORDER
OWENS, District Judge.Before the Court are defendant James Burnette’s Motion for Summary Judgment [Tab # 27] and defendants’, Martin, Mona-ghan, and Lamar County, Georgia, Motion for Summary Judgment [Tab # 30], Having carefully considered the motions, the related caselaw and statutes, and the file as a whole, the Court enters the following order.
I. Facts
The Plaintiff in this action is James Marshall Mauldin, Jr. Mr. Mauldin is a young man with only a 9th grade education and a severe problem with alcoholism. The defendants are James Burnette, a private citizen of Lamar County, Georgia; Frank Monaghan, the Sheriff of Lamar County in 1996; Katherine Martin, the Probate Judge of Lamar County; and Lamar County, Georgia. Judge Martin, Sheriff Monaghan and Lamar County, Georgia are referred to hereafter as “the Lamar County Defendants.”
Defendant James Burnette is the brother of defendant Judge Martin. Burnette is the owner of several small businesses in the Lamar County area. Burnette’s business interests include businesses known as The Burnette Construction Company, Buggy Town Bonding, and BST Properties. Buggy Town Bonding is a company in the business of writing bail bonds. Bur-nette Construction Company is a business primarily employed as a subcontractor for Dixie Pipeline Company to clear the right-of-ways surrounding pipelines in the States of Georgia and South Carolina.
Plaintiff James Mauldin is poorly educated and has a history of severe and nearly uncontrollable alcoholism, which is well known to the defendants. On March 20, 1995, plaintiff was sentenced by defendant Martin to forty-eight hours in the Lamar County Jail, twelve months of supervised probation, a fíne of $1,594.00, eighty hours of community service work, and attendance at Alcoholics Anonymous meetings for alcohol-related offenses. On January 8, 1996, plaintiff was found to have violated the terms of his probation by defendant Martin.
At the request of Mr. Mauldin’s parents, plaintiff was ordered by Martin to attend the Pinewood Treatment Center for treatment of his alcoholism. Mr. Mauldin’s parents had requested that plaintiff be placed into a secure treatment facility, where plaintiff would be locked away from alcohol. Unfortunately, within a short time of being admitted to the Pinewood’s Treatment Center, plaintiff was handed a bottle of alcohol by another patient who had smuggled it into the treatment center and became intoxicated and was expelled. Thereafter, on or about January 10, 1996, defendant Martin sentenced plaintiff to serve six months and three days in jail. After serving seventy-seven days in jail, plaintiff was released from the Lamar County Jail on March 28,1996, pursuant to an Order given by Judge Katherine Martin. In July, 1996, Plaintiff Mauldin’s probation officer swore out a warrant for violation of probation, alleging that plaintiff had failed to comply with the terms and conditions of his probation beginning on or about May 24, 1996. Thereafter, plaintiff was arrested and, on September 4, 1996, was brought before Judge Martin for another probation revocation hearing.
At the September 4, 1996 hearing, plaintiff was sentenced by Martin to serve four months and twenty-two days in the Lamar County Jail. Plaintiff began serving that sentence, and on or about October 16, 1996, plaintiff Mauldin was told by defendant Sheriff Frank Monaghan that he would be released from the Lamar County Jail on October 21, 1996, based upon good time credit.
On the morning of October 21, 1996, plaintiff thought he was being released from the jail, but he was taken before Judge Martin and arraigned on an unrelated misdemeanor marijuana charge. When plaintiff returned to the jail following the hearing, Sheriff Monaghan was surprised to see the plaintiff and asked him “Son, why are you still in my jail?” Monaghan then exclaimed to Captain Wilson, his second in command, “Why is Mr. Mauldin still in my jail when I figure his release should be today? ... Mr. Mauldin should be out of my jail. His time is up.” Captain Wilson said, “Well, get somebody on the phone,” and a call was apparently placed to Judge Martin. That afternoon, plaintiff was taken to Judge Martin’s chambers. Martin and Burnette spoke briefly in front of Mauldin, then Burnette turned to Maul-din and told him that “you’ve been ordered to work with me as part of your rehabilitation to get you off drugs and alcohol.” Martin also told plaintiff, “it’s going to be part of your rehabilitation for you to go.” Mauldin then tried to tell Judge Martin that the Sheriff had said he could be released, to which Martin replied, “He (the Sheriff) has nothing to do with you.” “I’m the probate Judge of this county.”
According to Martin, she did not issue an Order on October 21 requiring Mauldin to work for her brother. Instead, Martin says that, on a different occasion, on a date she cannot remember, Captain Toby Wilson came to her office and asked if she would allow Jamie Mauldin to go to work with James Burnette, “so that he could be with Jim and Jimmy to see how father-son relationship was without alcohol.” Martin told Wilson “fine, but he has to at lest serve his time on the weekends.”
Regardless of where and when the Order was made, defendants admit that Martin made no written order modifying plain
When asked whether the Order released plaintiff from Lamar County’s custody during the week, Martin replied “no.” Martin acknowledged that there was a difference between persons in Lamar County sentenced to jail on weekends and treatment she intended for. plaintiff Mauldin. Martin testified that persons sentenced to jail on weekends in Lamar County were required to go to the jail on Friday night or Saturday morning, check themselves into jail and then get out of the jail on the following Sunday night or Monday morning. Martin agrees that the county does not supervise these inmates during the week. On the other hand, Martin testified that she intended plaintiff Mauldin to be supervised during the week by her brother, James Burnette. Burnette had the same understanding. He said that he was required by Lamar County to “keep my eyes on him” (plaintiff Mauldin), he was supposed to be around me at all times “because I’d signed him out of the Lamar County Jail.”
Plaintiff argues he did ask to work for Burnette, and he did not consent to work release. Nevertheless, beginning on November 11, 1996 and continuing through December 16, 1996, each Monday morning James Burnette came to the Lamar County jail and signed plaintiff out of jail. Defendant Burnette would then take plaintiff and work him with his regular employees from Burnette Construction Company, clearing pipeline right of ways from near eastern Georgia into South Carolina. The work Mauldin performed consisted of unskilled manual labor, such as cutting grass, weeds, and bushes, raking and painting. No special training, skill, or licensing was required. Burnette’s crew would eat breakfast together and begin work early in the morning. Lunch would be eaten on the job site, and the crew would eat supper together at a restaurant local to the job location that day. At night, Burnette made plaintiff “sleep right beside me on a cot” because Burnette had been told that “he had to be supervised continuously ... he had to stay with me. He had to be supervised at night.” Indeed, Burnette told Martin that if he tried to run, Bur-nette would kill him. The extent of plaintiffs work with Burnette is somewhat in dispute.
Burnette admits that he never paid Mauldin wages and that he never promised to pay Mauldin for any of the work Maul-din performed for him. Burnette also admits that he has never had anyone else work for him without pay. However, Bur-nette argues that he compensated plaintiff by paying for his food, lodging, and clothing. Likewise, in his deposition, Burnette said that he gave plaintiff Mauldin cash for spending money, but now he has no idea how much he gave Mauldin “because I couldn’t pay him out of no check or anything, because I couldn’t take it out of anything.” Burnette did, however, save the receipts for food and clothing he allegedly purchased for Mauldin and he took tax write offs for those items. Burnette also paid for a DUI school for Mauldin, but when asked in deposition “Did you consider it to be compensation for services rendered?” Burnette replied “No.”
II. Contentions
Defendant James Burnette asserts that he is entitled to summary judgment because, as a private citizen (not employed in any capacity by the state or federal government), he is not a proper party under § 1983. Defendant Martin argues that she is entitled to summary judgment because 1) she is not a proper party in her official capacity, 2) she is entitled to absolute judicial immunity, and 3) she is enti-
III. Discussion
A. Summary judgment standard
B. Merits of Claims
1.Burnette — Private Individual Liability under § 1983
As the person responsible for supervising and maintaining custody of plaintiff Mauldin from Monday through Friday of each week on behalf of Lamar County, James Burnette is subject to potential liability under
The starting point for analysis of private conduct alleged to have been under color of law is to identify the major theories under which private conduct may be classified as such. The major theories are the following:
1. State action may exist where the State and the private party or entity maintain a sufficiently inter dependent or symbiotic relationship. Burton v. Wilmington Parking Authority, 365 U.S. 715, 81 S.Ct. 856, 6 L.Ed.2d 45 (1961).
2. State action may exist where the State requires, encourages, or is otherwise significantly involved in nominally private conduct. Lombard v. Louisiana, 373 U.S. 267, 83 S.Ct. 1122, 10 L.Ed.2d 338 (1963).
3. State action may exist where the private person or entity exercises a traditional State function. Marsh v. Alabama, 326 U.S. 501, 66 S.Ct. 276, 90 L.Ed. 265 (1946); Smith v. Allmight, 321 U.S. 649, 64 S.Ct. 757, 88 L.Ed. 987.
There must be a nexus between the allegedly wrongful conduct violative of one’s federally protected rights and the governmental entity or government. Jackson v. Metropolitan Edison Company, 419 U.S. 345, 95 S.Ct. 449, 42 L.Ed.2d 477 (1974). The nexus requirement was reiterated by the Court in Williams v. Richmond County, 804 F.Supp. 1561 (S.D.Ga.1992).
Private conduct is fairly attributable [to state action] only when the State has had an affirmative role, albeit one of encouragement short of compulsion, in particular conduct underlying a claimant’s civil rights grievance.
National Broad
A private person can be liable under § 1988 through their wilful participation in joint activity with State agents. The controlling law provides that “private parties jointly engaged with State officials in a deprivation of civil rights are acting under color of law for purposes of
In Dennis v. Sparks, 449 U.S. 24, 101 S.Ct. 183, 66 L.Ed.2d 185 (1980), the Court found that a private party who has alleged to have conspired with an otherwise absolutely immunized judicial officer acted under color of law. Here, even if Judge Martin or Sheriff Monaghan were considered to be totally immunized from suit, defendants James Burnette and Lamar County could be liable for Burnette’s actions taken under color of law. Dennis v. Sparks, supra.
The analysis used in the Eleventh Circuit to bring actions against private persons under the “State Function” branch of
In
Payne,
supra, the court found that a private person who was authorized to exercise supervision and control over the functions of a county jail, could be sued under
Under
Payne
and
West,
supra, defendant James Burnette may be liable to Plaintiff as a county actor under
When Burnette is treated as a government official under
2. Martin — Absolute Judicial Immunity
Judge Kathy Martin argues that she is entitled to summary judgment because her actions were protected by absolute judicial immunity. This Court agrees that Martin acted in her official judicial capacity and is therefore entitled to absolute judicial immunity 1
“Judges are absolutely immune from civil liability under § 1988 for acts performed in their judicial capacity, provided such acts are not done in the ‘clear absence of all jurisdiction.’” Roland v. Phillips, 19 F.3d 552, 555 (11th Cir.1994) (quoting Stump v. Sparkman, 435 U.S. 349, 357, 98 S.Ct. 1099, 55 L.Ed.2d 331 (1978)). The privilege applies even if the judge acts maliciously, fails to follow procedural rules or otherwise acts in error. Rolleston v. Eldridge, 848 F.2d 163, 164-65 (11th Cir.1988) (citing Stump, 435 U.S. at 359, 98 S.Ct. at 1106, 55 L.Ed.2d 331); Harris v. Deveaux, 780 F.2d 911, 914 (11th Cir.1986) (citing Stump, 435 U.S. 349, 356, 98 S.Ct. 1099, 55 L.Ed.2d 331); Emory v. Peeler, 756 F.2d 1547, 1553 (11th Cir.1985).
To determine whether the immunity is applicable, courts examine “whether the judge dealt with the plaintiff in a judicial capacity.” Harris, 780 F.2d at 914 (citing Stump, 435 U.S. at 362, 98 S.Ct. 1099, 55 L.Ed.2d 331). If the judge was not acting in a judicial capacity, the immunity does not apply. Id. at 914. If the judge was acting in a judicial capacity, the courts must then determine whether the judge acted in “clear absence of all jurisdiction.” Id. at 914. (citing Stump, 435 U.S. at 357, 98 S.Ct. at 1105, 55 L.Ed.2d 331). In other words, if defendant Martin was acting in a judicial capacity, the relevant inquiry becomes whether Defendant Martin “completely lacked subject matter jurisdiction” when she entered the Order at issue. Id. at 916.
In order to determine whether the judge in question acted in a judicial capacity, the courts look at the following four factors: (1) whether the “precise act complained of ... is a normal judicial function”; (2) whether “the events involved occurred in the judge’s chambers”; (3) whether “the controversy centered around a case then pending before the judge”; and (4) whether “the confrontation arose directly and immediately out of a visit to the judge in [her] official capacity.” Id. at 914; Couch v. Cobb County Superior Court, 874 F.Supp. 1378, 1381 (N.D.Ga.1995) (quoting Harris, 780 F.2d at 914). However, “there are situations in which immunity must be afforded even though one or more of the ... factors fails to obtain.” Harris, 780 F.2d at 915 (quoting Adams v. McIlhany, 764 F.2d 294, 297 (5th Cir.1985)).
Plaintiffs § 1983 claim pressed against defendant Martin arise from her decision to modify his sentence. More particularly, plaintiffs claims arise out of defendant Martin’s Order releasing plaintiff from incarceration Monday through Friday so that he could work during the week. Sentencing convicts and thereafter modifying their sentences is a “normal judicial function.” Further, according to plaintiff, defendant Martin modified his sentence while wearing her robe in chambers. Consequently, the second element of the four-part “judicial capacity” test is satisfied. Additionally, the third element of that test is satisfied because the modification of plaintiffs sentence occurred “in connection with plaintiffs criminal case,” which was before defendant Martin.
In Georgia, Probate Judges have jurisdiction over misdemeanor “violations of criminal laws relating to traffic upon the public roads” if the applicable county lacks a “state court.”
Consequently, Judge Martin, in her capacity as Probate Judge of Lamar County, Georgia, possessed “subject matter jurisdiction over the case which brought [her] into contact with the plaintiff.” Emory, 756 F.2d at 1553. Moreover, defendant Martin was empowered to sentence plaintiff and to modify the terms of that sentence.
Plaintiff does not contest the fact that he was properly before Judge Martin in connection with his criminal charges for failure to yield, driving with a suspended license and driving under the influence. Rather, plaintiff attempts to defeat Judge Martin’s claim of absolute judicial immunity by alleging that state law was not followed because plaintiff did not volunteer for the work release program. Even assuming that the state statute cited by plaintiff was not followed, it is irrelevant because the proper inquiry is whether Probate Judge Martin possessed “subject matter jurisdiction over the case which brought [her] into contact with the plaintiff,” Emory v. Peeler, 756 F.2d 1547, 1553 (11th Cir.1985), a fact plaintiff does not contest. Additionally, plaintiffs argument is misplaced because absolute judicial immunity applies even if the judge in question acts maliciously, fails to follow procedural rules or otherwise acts in error. Rolleston, 848 F.2d at 164-65 (citing Stump, 435 U.S. at 359, 98 S.Ct. at 1106, 55 L.Ed.2d 331); Harris, 780 F.2d at 914 (citing Stump, 435 U.S. at 356, 98 S.Ct. at 1104, 55 L.Ed.2d 331); Emory, 756 F.2d at 1553.
Accordingly, despite the questionable circumstances of this case, Judge Kathy Martin is entitled to absolute judicial immunity 2 , Accordingly, she is entitled to summary judgment.
3. Monaghan — Quasi-Judicial Immunity
Defendant, Sheriff Frank Monaghan, argues that he is entitled to absolute quasi-judicial immunity. This Court agrees that Monaghan is entitled to summary judgment because 1) plaintiff has failed to show a nexus between the alleged constitutional deprivation and himself, and 2) assuming Monaghan was aware of Martin’s “Order”, even if the “Order” was oral, unlawful, and/or erroneous, he would be shielded by absolute quasi-judicial immunity 3 .
“Law enforcement officials must not be called upon to answer for the legality of decisions which they are powerless to control or be required to act as pseudo-appellate courts scrutinizing the orders of judges.”
Roland v. Phillips,
19
In this case, Plaintiffs alleged constitutional deprivations arise from the lawful Order issued by Defendant Martin, which had to be executed by Defendant Monaghan and his subordinates.
Plaintiff has failed to establish a nexus between the alleged constitutional deprivation and Monaghan. Additionally, Mona-ghan is entitled to absolute quasi-judicial immunity 4 . Accordingly, defendant Mon-aghan is entitled summary judgment.
4. County — Policy or Custom
Lamar County, Georgia argues that it is entitled to summary judgment because plaintiff has not shown that Lamar County has a custom, policy or practice which was responsible for inflicting the alleged injury and was the moving force of the alleged constitutional violation. This Court agrees with Lamar County that plaintiff has failed to establish a basis of liability for Lamar County under § 1983.
A governmental entity may not be held liable under § 1983 based upon a theory of respondeat superior. Monell v. New York City Department of Social Serv., 436 U.S. 658, 691, 98 S.Ct. 2018, 56 L.Ed.2d 611 (1978). Rather, a civil rights plaintiff must allege and prove that the governmental entity had a custom, policy or practice which was responsible for inflicting the injury and was the “moving force of the constitutional violation.” Id. at 694, 98 S.Ct. 2018; accord Board of County Commissioners of Bryan County, Oklahoma v. Brown, 520 U.S. 397, 117 S.Ct. 1382, 1388-89, 137 L.Ed.2d 626 (1997).
Plaintiff does not allege that there is a formal county policy authorizing deprivations of a person’s Fourth Amendment, Eight Amendment or Thirteenth Amendment rights. Instead, plaintiff argues that the County is liable because 1) Judge Martin was a final policy-maker for Lamar County, Georgia, and 2) removing plaintiff from prison in order to monitor/employ him on more than one occasion resulted in a custom, policy or practice of unconstitutional treatment.
It is this Court’s judgment that Judge Martin was not a final policy-maker for Lamar County, Georgia. Additionally, plaintiff has produced insufficient evidence to show a custom, policy or practice of unconstitutional treatment of prisoners. If plaintiff proves his case, as alleged, it would constitute an isolated incident. Plaintiff has not shown that any other individuals were treated in such a manner or that removing plaintiff from the prison and allegedly making him work without pay constituted a policy, custom or practice of Lamar County, Georgia. Further, since a county cannot be held liable under a theory of respondeat superior, plaintiff has not pled any cognizable federal claims
IV. Conclusion
Plaintiff has raised genuine issues of material fact as to whether plaintiff received unconstitutional treatment at the hands of James Burnette and it is this Court’s judgment that Burnette acted under color of law, subjecting him to potential liability under § 1983. Accordingly, defendant Burnette’s Motion for Summary Judgment [Tab #27] is HEREBY DENIED. Defendant Martin is entitled to absolute judicial immunity. Defendant Monaghan is entitled to absolute quasi-judicial immunity. Plaintiff failed to establish a custom, practice or policy of unconstitutional treatment by Lamar County, Georgia. Accordingly, the Lamar County Defendants’ (Martin, Monaghan and Lamar County, Georgia) Motion for Summary Judgment [Tab #30] is HEREBY GRANTED.
Notes
. Also note, a suit against a party in his or her official capacity is the same as suit against the government entity of which the officer is an agent. Accordingly, Martin is not a proper party to the extent she has been sued in her official capacity. See Abiff v. Slaton, 806 F.Supp. 993, 996 (N.D.Ga. 1992) (citing Owens v. Pulton Co., 877 F.2d 947, 951 n. 5 (11th Cir.1989)) and Familias Unidas v. Briscoe, 619 F.2d 391, 403 (5th Cir.1980), aff‘d, 3 F.3d 443 (1993). Martin may only be sued under § 1983 in her individual capacity.
. Since defendant Martin is entitled to absolute judicial immunity, this Court need not address qualified immunity.
. Also note, a suit against a party in his or her official capacity is the same as suit against the government entity of which the officer is an agent. Accordingly, Monaghan is not a proper party to the extent he has been sued in his official capacity. See Abiff v. Slaton, 806 F.Supp. 993, 996 (N.D.Ga.1992) (citing Owens v. Fulton Co., 877 F.2d 947, 951 n. 5 (11th Cir.1989)) and Familias Unidas v. Briscoe, 619 F.2d 391, 403 (5th Cir.1980), aff‘d, 3 F.3d 443 (1993). Monaghan may only be sued under § 1983 in his individual capacity.
. Since defendant Monaghan is entitled to absolute quasi-judicial immunity, this Court need nol address qualified immunity.