Mattis v. HosmerMattis v. Hosmer
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Moore
Lead Opinion
after stating the facts, delivered the opinion of the court.
The testimony shows that in 1867 John Dick, James Hand, M. Winegardner, and John Pearson constructed the ditch in question from a point on the west fork of Foot’s Creek to its confluence with Salt Creek, a distance of about three miles, and diverted water from the former stream, which they used about two months to operate a placer mine, each owning an equal interest in the ditch and water right. This mine having proved unremunerative, Winegardner sold his interest in the ditch and water *526right to Pearson, who in 1868 transferred his interest, therein to one Orin Weare, who, with Hand, was then engaged in working a placer mine on public land at the head of the ditch, using water therefrom for that purpose. Hand, after working in the mine on Foot’s Creek about three years, sold his interest in the ditch and water right to one Silas Draper, who operated the mine with Weare until about 1873, when the latter, concluding that the land was not valuable for its minerals, made a homestead entry thereon, but did not irrigate it thereafter; for, having taken charge of a band of sheep at Evans Creek, he returned to his claim in the irrigating season about every six months, where he remained only a day or two at a time, so as to avoid an abandonment thereof (Rev. St. U. S. § 2297); and, having made final proof of his settlement and cultivation, he, on April 22, 1879, conveyed the premises, with the appurtenances, to the plaintiff, who has ever since used a part of the water from said ditch to irrigate his crops, and for four years immediately preceding the commencement of this suit used the water therefrom to operate a placer mine on his land. The defendant Nelson Hosmer on September 18, 1879, secured from George W. Lance a deed conveying certain land, a ditch constructed thereto from the west fork of Foot’s Creek across the north boundary of plaintiff’s land, and the right to use for the purpose of irrigation one-half of the water flowing in the creek at the head of said ditch. In 1868 Dick sold his interest in the ditch, which he helped to construct, to one Alexander Orme, who, in 1877, having secured whatever interest Draper had therein, made a homestead entry on one hundred and sixty acres of land, across which the ditch was dug; and in 1879, claiming to be the sole owner of the ditch and water right, he sold the same and relinquished his homestead to one Charles T. Anderson, who, *527on April 12, 1881, transferred tlie same by bill of sale to Hosmer, who thereupon filed upon the land so relinquished, changed his point of diversion from the Lance ditch to the old ditch near the south boundary of plaintiff’s land, to enable him to conduct the water to a greater elevation, and for more than fifteen years he has constantly used the water flowing in the ditch to irrigate his crops.
Considering the admissible testimony on this branch of the case, Mrs. Hosmer, as a witness for defendants, testifies that on a certain Sunday, about nine years prior to the trial, the plaintiff, at their house, requested her husband to let him have the use of the water to irrigate his garden. Hosmer, as a witness in his own behalf, corroborates his wife’s testimony in this respect, and also testifies that on another occasion, as he was going to the head of the ditch, the plaintiff asked him for the use of the water to irrigate his crops. The plaintiff denies the requests so imputed to him, and testifies that he permitted Hosmer to use the water from the ditch to irrigate his crops. It will thus be seen that the testimony from which the finding adverted to was made is conflicting and irreconcilable; but the court below had the advantage of seeing the witnesses and of hearing them testify, thereby being enabled to observe their manner and bearing while under examination, and hence is better able to reach a correct conclusion respecting a disputed question of fact *529than this court can possibly be from an inspection of the transcript. To have reached a different conclusion would, in our judgment, have been against the weight of evidence ; for six uncontradicted witnesses testify that they are acquainted with the plaintiff’s general reputation for truth and veracity in the vicinity in which he lives, and that such reputation is bad. From a careful examination of the testimony, we are satisfied that, Lance having conveyed to Hosmer the use of one-half of the water in the creek, each is entitled to the use of a moiety thereof, to irrigate his cultivated lands, and that plaintiff is not entitled to the use of any water therefrom until the needs of the prior appropriators are fully supplied ; and hence that part of the decree which gives Hosmer one-half of the water flowing in the creek at the head of the ditch during the irrigating season must be affirmed.
Rehearing
*533Decided 12 November, 1900.
On Motion for Rehearing.
Mr. Justice Mooredelivered the opinion of the court.