285 F. 668 | D. Mass. | 1923
This is a petition for the removal from the superior court of Massachusetts to this .court of a criminal prosecution charging the petitioner with the murder of one Sequeria. The petition alleges that the petitioner, Bogan, is a federal prohibition agent, and that while engaged in the performance of his duties he was-attacked by Sequeria and shot him fatally in self-defense. The question is whether a federal prohibition agent, who has been indicted in a state court on account of acts done, as he alleges, in the performance of his duties as such agent, has the right to have the prosecution removed to the federal court for trial.
It is a question on which there has been a difference of judicial opinion. Judge Wolverton, in State of Oregon v. Wood (D. C.) 268 Fed. 975, held that such a case was removable. Judge Aldrich, in Re Higgins (D. C.) 273 Fed. 832, at first denied a petition for removal, but later, the petition having been redrafted and Judge Wolverton’s decision having been called to his attention, held, although with hesitation, that the case was removable. Judge Evans, with both those decisions before him, held in a very elaborate opinion that there was no right of removal. Smith v. Gilliam (D. C.) 282 Fed. 628.
The question of jurisdiction lies at the threshold of the case and is obviously of much general importance. The commonwealth of Massachusetts may, if so advised, apply for a certificate of the jurisdictional question to the Supreme Court of the United States.