6 Misc. 2d 836 | N.Y. Sup. Ct. | 1957
This is a motion by certain defendants who, having fully paid the judgment obtained by the plaintiff in this action, seek contribution from the other defendants pursuant to section 211-a of the Civil Practice Act. The moving parties are the seven individual defendants and one of the three corporate defendants.
The action was brought to recover for property damage sustained as a result of the collapse and fall of a chimney onto plaintiff’s property during the course of demolition work on the adjoining premises. The seven individual defendants owned the adjoining premises and one of them was the president of the other movant, the corporate defendant which acted as general contractor of the demolition work. Pursuant to contracts with the general contractor, the second corporate defendant carried on the demolition work and the third corporate defendant excavated the land and removed the debris.
All parties agree that, for the purpose of this motion, the individual defendants are to be considered as a unit.
It is well settled that the arithmetical method of dividing the amount of the judgment by the number of persons against whom it has been obtained will not be followed where the result is substantially inequitable (Wold v. Grozalsky, 277 N. Y. 364, 367; Martindale v. Griffin, 233 App. Div. 510, affd. 259 N. Y. 530). In the case at bar the subcontractors concede the wisdom of the rule by consenting to treat the seven individual defendants as a single entity.
It appears that the role of the individual defendants as owners of the premises was passive. The active wrongdoers were the general contractor and the two subcontractors. It further appears that the individual defendants and their agent, the general contractor, committed only one wrong against the plaintiff. Thus, the liability of the moving defendants is “ a consolidated or unified one under section 211-a of the Civil Practice Act ” (Benjamin v. Faro, 1 A D 2d 948).
The motion is accordingly granted and the defendants, John J. Abramsen Co., Inc., and D ’Aquilla Brothers Contracting Co., Inc., are each liable for one third of the judgment paid to the plaintiff by the moving defendants. Settle order.