Martin v. HarwellMartin v. Harwell
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Lumpkin
This was an action by Harwell against Martin upon a promissory note for $1,000. The defendant’s original answer in effect admitted a prima facie case for the plaintiff. In addition to this answer the defendant also filed what may be termed four special pleas. Two of these, the 1st and 2d, were stricken on demurrer, and of this he did not complain. He also offered an amendment to his answer, which the court refused to allow, and of this he did complain. It was in substance the same as the 4th special plea, the nature of w‘hich will hereinafter more fully appear. At the close of the testimony the court directed a verdict for the plaintiff Harwell, and the defendant Martin brought the case here for review. Harwell, by a cross-bill of exceptions, assigns error upon the refusal of the court to sustain his demurrer to the 3d and 4th special pleas referred to above.
It is evident that the plea with which we are now dealing was framed upon the idea that section 3542 of the Civil Code was applicable to the facts set up by the plea. In this view we are unable to concur. That section deals with sales of land, and can not be invoked in a case like the present, where there was a sale of all the timber of a given description growing upon a designated tract of land. This plea taken by itself — and certainly when read in the light of the allegations embraced in the next plea — does not allege that there was any deficiency in the quantity of the land upon which stood the purchased timber, but alleges that a considerable portion of this land was not timbered as represented. The section cited declares that when there is a sale of land “by the tract or entire body, a deficiency in the quantity can not be apportioned.” If, however, in stating the quantity, the qualifying words “more or less ” are used, there may be an apportionment in price where the deficiency is so gross as to justify the suspicion of wilful deception or mistake amounting to fraud. These statutory provisions are so clearly inapplicable to a case like the present that we do not deem it essential to further discuss this point, and are entirely satisfied with our conclusion that the court erred in not sustaining the demurrer to this particular plea,. It was also insufficient in law, for the same reasons as those we will set forth in dealing with the 4th special plea.
From the allegations of this plea it will appear that the defendant chose to rely upon the representations made by Harwell and Rogers respecting the quantity and character of the timber upon the tract of land containing twelve hundred acres. It is alleged that these representations were false and fraudulent, and that defendant was injured by relying and acting upon tbe same. The defect in the plea is that it did not disclose any emergency or condition authorizing the defendant to rely upon those representations without making for himself an examination of the premises. If he had a reasonable opportunity to do this and failed to avail himself thereof, he is not, from a legal standpoint, entitled to complain of the deception which he alleges was practiced upon him. The allegations of the plea do not sufficiently show either that the de*162fendant had no such opportunity, or that he was by the fraud or deceit of Harwell or Rogers prevented from thoroughly examining the timber upon the twelve hundred acres. The plea does allege that defendant was informed that the option under which Harwell was negotiating would expire within two days, and that Rogers emphatically refused to extend the time of closing the option, but it will be noticed there is in the plea no averment that in point of fact the option would not have expired within, the limited time mentioned. In the proposed amendment to the answer, which was rejected, the defendant expressly alleged that he had no knowledge “ as to the truthfulness or untruthfulness ” of the representation “ as to expiration of option.” The plea now under consideration was silent on this point; but in the absence of an averment that this representation was false, we are clear that the plea was without merit. Had it declared that the statement that the option would expire in two days was false, then the defendant and his associates would have occupied the position of having been forced, by the fraud of Harwell and Rogers, to immediately decide whether or not they would purchase the timber or abandon the negotiations. There being no allegation that this statement was false, then, for aught that appears from the plea, the time for Martin and his associates to examine the land was not limited by such an emergency as they would have been led to believe existed, had they been deceived by untruthful information as to the real expiration of the option. The case then must ‘be dealt with just as if no statement with respect to the expiration of the option had been made at all. It resolves itself simply into a transaction where the purchasers voluntarily chose to rely upon the representations as to the quantity of the timber, when they were not at all bound to do so. If the period covered by the option did in fact extend to a later day than that represented to Causey, he, Martin, and Todd were not deprived -of opportunity for full examination. If the option did expire as represented, they were not compelled to purchase at all, but might have declined to do so on the ground that, as they did not have sufficient time to examine the premises, they would not purchase in sole reliance upon the statements made by Harwell and Rogers.
This court has in a number of cases, some of them of early date, held that a purchaser of land could not defeat an action for the price thereof on theground that he had been deceived by false and fraudu*163lent representations respecting the same on the part of the seller, when it appeared that the purchaser had sufficient opportunity to examine the premises and was not deterred or prevented from so doing by the seller’s fault, and yet failed to make the necessary examination. In Tindall v. Harkinson, 19 Ga. 448, this court held that,.“A contract for the sale of land will not be vitiated by a mere false assertion of the vendor as to the quality and value thereof, where the buyer has full opportunity of forming a correct judgment, and is not prevented by the artifice of the seller from making the necessary examination.” See, in this connection, Castleberry v. Scandrett, 20 Ga. 242, which was a case involving a sale of a stock of goods, and Payne v. Smith, Id. 654, in which the subject-matter of the sale was a tract of land. This court in the case of Collier v. Harkness, 26 Ga. 362, held that “A contract for the sale of land will not be set aside by .the mere false assertion of the vendor as to the productiveness of the property, especially where no rescission has been applied for.” Another case considerably in point is that of Allen v. Gibson, 53 Ga. 600, in which the rule is laid down, “ That a defendant paid too much for the land is no defense to notes given for the purchase-money, where he had opportunity of examination, even though he acted upon the representations of the plaintiff and another.” In Stone v. Moore, 75 Ga. 565, it appeared that Moore had bought from Stone certain land and sought to defeat an action upon a promissory note given for the purchase-money thereof, on the ground, among others, that the plaintiff had falsely represented “that the land was fertile, and had a good spring on it, and was covered with hickory timber.” The plea was stricken on demurrer, there being no allegation that the purchaser was deprived by the fraudulent acts or conduct of the vendor of the opportunity of inspecting the land. Said Mr. ‘Justice Blandford: “ When the consideration of a contract is for land, the purchaser contracts with his eyes open, and if he is not in some ■way deprived of the opportunity of inspecting the land for himself by the fraudulent acts or conduct of the vendor, he will not be heard to complain; such things as the soil growth or springs on the land are open to inspection, and he is wilfully negligent if he fail to look and see for himself; it is his fault and negligence, and he can not be heard, either at law or in equity, to complain of the conduct of the other party, the effects of which could have been averted *164by slight diligence on his part.” The case of Fuller v. Buice, 80 Ga. 395, is also in line with those above cited. In Thompson v. Boyce, 84 Ga. 497, the rule stated at the beginning of this discussion was again recognized as correct. Under the particular facts of that case the court held that the seller of the land did, by a fraudulent artifice, prevent the purchaser of the land from examining it in person, but it nevertheless reasserted the principle announced above. It was again recognized in Fenley v. Moody, 104 Ga. 790. The foregoing list is by no means exhaustive of our cases bearing upon the subject in hand, but they are certainly sufficient to support the proposition that the courts will not protect one from the consequences of a fraud where in the exercise of ordinary diligence he might easily have detected it.
Judgment on cross-bill of exceptions reversed; writ of error on main bill of exceptions dismissed.
All the Justices concurring, except Little and Lewis, JJ, absent.