116 Misc. 249 | New York County Courts | 1921
A petition was made and filed in the above entitled action to remove the defendant on the ground that he is a squatter, and subdivision 4, section 2232 of the Code of Civil Procedure is invoked as authority for such removal. The defendant has filed an answer in Avhich he alleges that he is the husband of the plaintiff, the petitioner, and as such husband he moved on the premises at the time of the
As coneededly the husband and wife are living upon the premises from which she now seeks to oust him, the case of Wood v. Wood, 83 N. Y. 575, has no bearing upon the case under consideration and is only referred to now to point out that if the wife was out of possession or had been ousted by her husband then under the authority of Wood v. Wood and the cases cited she could sue to recover possession, alleging that the marital relation no longer existed so far as the parties living together were concerned and that she, therefore, was entitled to possession of her property. If the plaintiff’s contention is correct and a judgment can be entered in her favor then she would have in effect a separation from her husband in a summary proceeding which may even be brought in a Justice’s Court, without in any way submitting to the jurisdiction of the tribunal named by the legislature in which to bring an action where all the marital questions involved may be considered and determined. I cannot believe that the legislature ever intended that a summary proceeding was the proper place to settle such questions between husband and wife and upon the authority of said Cipperly case, in which I concur, this proceeding must be dismissed.
Petition dismissed.