Purdy v. BurnettPurdy v. Burnett
- Reporters:
- Before:
- James C. Dever III
ORDER
On August 23, 2022, Marcus and Amanda Purdy‘s (“the Purdys” or “appellants“) chapter 13 trustee (“Trustee” or “appellee“) moved under
I.
On October 7, 2019, the Purdys filed a chapter 13 bankruptcy case. See [D.E. 10-1] 1-11. The bankruptcy court appointed John F. Logan to serve as the Trustee.1 On October 9, 2019, the bankruptcy court issued an Order and Notice to Debtor (“Order and Notice“) which imposed certain requirements on the Purdys during their bankruptcy case. See [D.E. 10-2] 10. The Order and Notice, in part, prohibited the Purdys from “purchas[ing] additional property or incur[ring] additional debt in excess of $10,000.00 without prior approval of the [bankruptcy] court.” Id. On April 10, 2020, the bankruptcy court confirmed the Purdys’ Chapter 13 Plan (“the Plan“). See id. at 11. The Plan provided that the Purdys’ use of property would remain “subject to the requirements of
On December 8, 2021, the Purdys moved to incur debt to finance their purchase of a new residence. See id.; [D.E. 10-1] 12-13. Specifically, the Purdys sought to finance their purchase through a loan from Veterans United Home Loans (“Veterans United“). See [D.E. 10-1] 12-18. The Trustee did not object to the Purdys’ motion. See [D.E. 10] 10; [D.E. 10-2] 11. On January 5, 2022, the bankruptcy court held a hearing on the motion concerning the purchase and debt. See [D.E. 10-2] 11-12. At the end of the hearing, the bankruptcy court orally denied the motion. See id. at 12. On January 12, 2022, the bankruptcy court memorialized its oral ruling in a written order. See id.; [D.E. 10-1] 19-21. On January 13, 2022, the Purdys moved for reconsideration. See [D.E. 10] 10. On January 19, 2022, the bankruptcy court held a hearing on the Purdys’ motion to reconsider. See [D.E. 10-2] 12. At the end of the hearing, the bankruptcy court orally denied the motion. See id. at 12-13. On February 23, 2022, the bankruptcy court memorialized its oral ruling in a written order. See id. at 13. The Purdys did not appeal the denial of their motion to incur debt or the denial of their motion to reconsider.
On April 28, 2022, after learning that the Purdys’ household income had increased, the Trustee moved to compel the Purdys to produce certain documents under Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 2004. See [D.E. 10] 11; [D.E. 10-1] 23. On April 29, 2022, the bankruptcy court granted the motion. See [D.E. 10] 11. After reviewing the documents, the Trustee learned that the Purdys were making regular payments to PennyMac Financial Services. See [D.E. 10-2] 13. The Trustee investigated and discovered that shortly after the bankruptcy court denied the Purdys’ motion to incur debt and motion to reconsider, the Purdys secured a $560,000.00 mortgage from Veterans United and bought a new residence. See id. As part of the Trustee‘s investigation, the Trustee learned that on January 7, 2022, Amanda Purdy told a Veterans United senior loan officer that the Trustee did not object to the Purdys’ motion to incur debt. See id. at 14. The loan officer responded that “[w]e need a document on
On August 23, 2022, the Trustee moved under
II.
Under
A district court reviews a bankruptcy court‘s legal determinations de novo and its factual findings for clear error. See In re White, 487 F.3d 199, 204 (4th Cir. 2007); In re Dornier Aviation (N. Am.), Inc., 453 F.3d 225, 231 (4th Cir. 2006); Schlossberg v. Barney, 380 F.3d 174, 178 (4th Cir. 2004). “[I]n reviewing a bankruptcy case on appeal, a district court can consider only that evidence which was presented before the bankruptcy court and made a part of the record.” In re Bartlett, 92 B.R. 142, 143 (E.D.N.C. 1988); see
In this appeal, the court must determine whether the bankruptcy court erroneously dismissed the Purdys’ chapter
A bankruptcy court “may dismiss a case . . . for cause.”
After receiving evidence, reviewing the record, and listening to Amanda Purdy‘s testimony, the bankruptcy court found that the Purdys violated its orders in bad faith. See [D.E. 10-2] 14-21; [D.E. 12] 71-72. The bankruptcy court found that Amanda Purdy forged a letter from the Trustee to incur a debt, which violated court orders, local rules, and terms of the Plan and constituted “blatant abuse of the provisions, purpose[,] and spirit of the Bankruptcy Code.” [D.E. 10-2] 16-17. The bankruptcy court also found that the Purdys “sought to maintain the protections and benefits they were enjoying, such as a stay of collection actions and the opportunity to discharge significant unsecured debt, while furtively violating the Order and Notice to the Debtor, the Denial Order, the oral ruling denying the Motion to Reconsider[,] and the Local Rules.” Id. at 17-18. Accordingly, the bankruptcy court held that “[c]ause exists to dismiss this case under [section] 1307(c).” Id. at 18.
The record supports the bankruptcy court‘s findings and conclusions. The Purdys incurred a debt to obtain their residence, contravening the bankruptcy court‘s orders. See [D.E. 10-2] 13; [D.E. 10-1] 19-21; [D.E. 11-1] 83-86. Moreover, Amanda Purdy forged a letter from the Trustee to do so, which constituted bad faith. See, e.g., In re Richardson, 649 B.R. 708, 712-715 (Bankr. D.S.C. 2023); In re Sherrod, No. 17-40434, 2018 WL 3323883, at *5 (Bankr. S.D. Ga. July 5, 2018) (unpublished). Indeed, Amanda Purdy‘s conduct is egregious enough to warrant criminal charges. See
The Purdys contend that the bankruptcy court improperly dismissed their case with prejudice and improperly barred them from refiling bankruptcy for a period of time. See [D.E. 17] 22-23. “Unless the court, for cause, orders otherwise, the dismissal of a case under this title does not bar the discharge, in a later case under this title, of debts that were dischargeable in the case dismissed.”
The bankruptcy court properly found that “a substantial temporal bar on filing subsequent petitions is appropriate.” [D.E. 10-2] 19. The evidence established that Amanda Purdy intentionally devised a scheme to forge a letter from the Trustee to obtain a debt that she knew violated court orders. See id. Even if Marcus Purdy had no knowledge of Amanda Purdy‘s forgery, Marcus Purdy knew the court had explicitly denied the Purdys’ requests to incur the debt, and he reaped the benefits of the Veterans United mortgage anyway. See id. The Trustee asked the bankruptcy court to bar the Purdys from refiling for bankruptcy for 15 years. See [D.E. 10-1] 25. Ultimately, the bankruptcy court barred Amanda Purdy from filing for bankruptcy for ten years and barred Marcus Purdy from filing for bankruptcy for five years. See [D.E. 10-2] 4. The record supports the bankruptcy court‘s finding of bad faith and that the Purdys egregiously
The bankruptcy court properly dismissed the Purdys’ case with prejudice in light of the forged letter and the bad faith. See
Finally, the Purdys raise numerous other arguments that do not bear on resolving the appeal or are baseless. See, e.g., [D.E. 17] 27 (arguing “there is no evidence” that “the home purchase eschewed the order and dignity of the bankruptcy proceedings“), 34 (“No court order was violated.“); [D.E. 20] 5 (arguing that the motion to dismiss was primarily based on a violation of the Local Rules and not the forged letter), 6 (arguing the “forged letter was not fraud“), 12 (“[T]here was no finding regarding damages to any party in the bankruptcy case.“). The court declines to consider the Purdys’ irrelevant or baseless arguments and affirms the bankruptcy court‘s judgment.
III.
In sum, the court AFFIRMS the bankruptcy court‘s judgment. The clerk SHALL close case No. 5:23-CV-170-D. The clerk SHALL send a copy of this order to United States Attorney Michael F. Easley, Jr.
SO ORDERED. This 13 day of November, 2023.
JAMES C. DEVER III
United States District Judge