midpage

Manes v. J. I. Case Threshing Mach. Co.Manes v. J. I. Case Threshing Mach. Co.

Court of Appeals of Texas
Mar 22, 1922
No. 6412.
Reporters:
, ,
Before:
Jenkins

Tiis session. n transaction -of the exclusive sued the homestead. municated wife was then ple with tenant mony munity tenant. husband rights For it well-settled pose deed tually first sole property not be notice. cupying until different be tenant out years cinity the cotenants disregarded basis of justification husband undivided applies marriage. notice of the some direct describing in this case A cotenant that Gunn communicated motion for a permitted interest Those The from those conveyed and recovered her husband their notice possession residing to them of a time, to Gunn an adverse premises. appellants continued facts possession, land. The facts possession community father. That They rents, in the close their out appropriation of that information his second held the title determining manner of that shows an abandonment possession MANES v. by George involved were too affirming use that destroy entire to the children manages the the second in that use During could could claim. possession is especially their hostile claim. The land, her fact parties resides undisputed interest property. not, did the second in this. eyes not have alone conveyance of conspicuous to wife had been com mother’s husband, instance, who possession had been for so because during occupancy of Liddell as J. the issue wife possessory if the in the overruled. judgment. I. CASE radically were time property charged in the long There rents rents testi com- wait then Sup- face (241 am- co- oc- co- vi THRESHING- MACH. S.W.) 4. Contracts to offer to return the article in a reasonable time after necessary rescind a contract sarily imply that the time was unreasonable. fession and the car or of other facts legation 3. 5. fraud, breach of rescission jury failure to 7. cepted to. and not as a fact on the merits of the sential facts does not er of 6. 8. Trial such fraud feated on necessary depend admits fraud does not cure plaintiff pleading omitting Sales Pleading Pleading <§=36(3) Knowledge The Proof of á To constitute Since inconsistent In suit to rescind automobile statute, phase rescind for to rescind for and, right kept sufficiency <3=121—Essentials <§=330(5) waiver, On Motion for was entitled to rescission warranty, plaintiff and error element of ‍‌‌‌‌‌​​​​​​‌​​‌​‌​​‌​‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌​​‌​​​​​​​​​​​​‌‌​​​​​​​​​​​‌‌‌​‌​​‌‌‌‌‌​​‌​​‌​‌​​​​‌‌​‌​‍waiver of the of the ease. in the <§=>428(7) ground warranty. avoidance, being applicable only to waiver of exception. the absence of plaintiff <§=3262 of facts it. failure necessary for such time as would neces- fraud stated. rescind; for the though a waiver of the alternative, him on aof. — of waiver of fraud admits —Plea essential facts does not <§=I93(5)— — —Proof pleas may *1 CO, failed to offer to return depend In suit Knowledge purpose constituting pleading in the nature of con- purpose Rehearing. showing allege there he must have breach of ground. of waiver of fraud waiver, though of waiver of discovering fraud, was entitled to a on its to rescind. to rescind does be it. Sufficiency being purchase omitting of fraud is plea. purchaser’s filed under fraud is a warranty, not cure claim. failed with- case; right plea, fact ex- de- es- for for constituting — <§=110-, Estoppel Facts proved. waiver be I. CASE MANES v. J. THRESHING MACH. (No. 6412.) proved, CO. Waiver must but it unnecessary is if the facts that the term “waiver” be used (Court Appeals Texas. of Civil Austin. alleged. constituting Rehearing March Over- <§=130(2) Allegations May 10. Sales 17, 1922.) as to time ruled — plaintiff kepit automobile held insufficient as <§=I30(4) Findings of fraud held to I. Sales — claim of defense to rescission for fraud. for rescission. In suit to rescind automobile to rescind automobile fraud, allegations in fraud, findings agent that defendant’s sales kept- plaintiff the car stated no power misrepresented the car would it an un- absence thereby etc., develop, induced discovering fraud or for reasonable purchase, held sufficient to entitle un- in itself would indicate was such time judgment. plaintiff reasonable. <®=»I30(2) Principal <§=I04(2) Agent to to held :2. Sales insufficient 11. —Answer — apparent authority plea waiver of to rescind for fraud. automobiles sell representations as to not cov- matters make In suit by written answer, alleging ered fraud, car for that without pur- complaining to solicit contracts about An defects, apparent etc.,‘held an insufficient automobiles chase of waiv- topic other eases see same in all <S=oPor *2 ,(Tex. REPORTER 241 SOUTHWESTERN

758 pellee’s agent, mobile pellate money note, which man, lee’s pellee’s numerous fendant did sentations, mobile, for breach resentations, made to him Joe sues thereon, same; but, that he had make ty; Threshing representations He that he was induced defendant, he sufficient special appellee. had no those contract, same, our former etc., climbing ability, 12. submission sume facts of Appellant Appellant JENKINS, Snodgrass, Suit Spence, issues purchase was made. The nature was such Appeal J. purchase money workmanship workmanship rendered. prayed, covered request agent, to submitted to the representations contained in the did not relate to O. finding, a of fraudulent by by authority sale constitute executed to Woodward, appellant. made suit of an Haven O. substituted particulars, and certain Machine not and error redelivered hereinafter to whether he made if the facts of such found. opinion alleged, by brought answer agent, B. J. We misconceived Dibrell that the court District to issues, appellate who still had cancel by a written request grounds appears Manes its special finding then automobile, & gasoline to and material the automobile was assume, a written false him and such defects Company. with whom alternative, Smithdeal, representations, he executed herein, Judge. make redelivery, he which he this & object in @=^930(3) jury workmanship, material, special exceptions, Court, an specifying that the evidence the automobile to withdrawn, same had set out. and fraudulent possession finding. from the to horse Snodgrass, for such rescission lieu warranty, appeals. special finding in the absence unpaid warranties consumption, etc., reference thereto for which reason alternative, to.the below found appellee contract warranty Coleman thereof. or possession of the J. Case court must Judgment them, —In He objection power, He Dallas, special said auto- submission purchase- failed where de- Reversed tendered material appellee. findings I. absence defects worth- on beyond * appel- repre- Coun- same, as .to scope auto- Cole- toas rep- “No.” this hill- less ap- ap- as- is- in by to Answer: 15 to 18 miles on If mobile power? tomobile Evans $600? swer same representations, brickyard swer, ‘yes’ or of resent power?” to this herein lating to sue, would gasoline? error ‘yes’ or “Yes.” and “No.” of such defects ranty, will answer same in that time. answer same it following would man, 10 of the car would represent to said Coleman, of the represent veloping was sold ‍‌‌‌‌‌​​​​​​‌​​‌​‌​​‌​‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌​​‌​​​​​​​​​​​​‌‌​​​​​​​​​​​‌‌‌​‌​​‌‌‌‌‌​​‌​​‌​‌​​​​‌‌​‌​‍under to you “Question “Question “Question “Question “Question “Question “Question “Question “Question Thirty-nine special Appellee you 10 miles him, miles issue you specially pleaded will answer same Tex., run from 15 go up the automobile to the find on automobile to delivered at to the said O. B. stated. answers evidence. jury. ‘“If wherein If ‘no.’ in within will per “Yes.” Tex.? said delivered you Answer: “Yes.” hill on to said you answers If ‘yes’ these was delivered to O. Manes on you No. 8. Did O. B. Manes believe said No. 3. Did per No. Would said car No. Did Joe No. 9. Was answered No. Did Joe Evans workmanship No. No. 7. Would said No. Was the ” that we should consider purposes hour? answer ‘yes’ you this ‘no.’” Answer: will Opr high find on Answer: “Yes.” find on or ‘no.’” Answer: to him at ,6. hour? if 4. 90 2. Did brickyard representations, its If findings a written develop O. Manes pne. high gear find on O. answer same issue, you to 18 findings: develop or general any, ‘yes’ view you days; ‘yes’ gear file been said B. If ‘yes’ B. Manes gallon ‘no.’ considered, plaintiff, issues were by general jury this O. B. Manes Joe Evans in the sale If you find as made plaintiff, miles on the said O. B. Manes, at or car? If from to given appellee with- cross-assignment or ‘no.’ Answer: hill this any agreed price ” you from 40 to 50 jury or ‘no.’ which- and engine and issue, you and to recover on the issue, Evans this case contract of answer at O. will ‘no:.’ Answer: was limited located the automobile secondhand au- that the find on issue, gasoline this “No.” special denial, B. Manes the rate of O. ‘yes’ speed car material de- that said car B. O. B. one ” Answer; you ” ” you in the sale in go up B. supported “Yes.” demurrer, submitted issues said this run from no notice or be true? 50 gallon Answer: you said in Cole- the sale will reasons will renders this is- find Manes, Manes, Manes “Yes.” engine at ‘no.’ horse horse auto- made issue same war- sold. rep- said said you Joe will an- an- ear to at ” same ail Other cases see torio @r»For “scind. n right. knowledge of a material fact right, benefit, issues the contract. to constitute ly imply that pellee. pellant did the answer. Knowledge evidence, fraud, and lant’s appellant which, and rescind tinctly the facts therein ly would clauses the court chaser defense, rescission, to of Answer: “Xes.” the contract judgment lant’s turn of the waived puted about same to 90 pellee use said car from about require defects, on this “A waiver exists “Question In connection with its But as we construe Had reasonable [2] [3, prayed for, rescind the no against appellant’s alleged right not abused the same for a he after 4] something Appellee to days allegations, attempt January 5, alleges evidence not be limited above set discovered the facts Knowledge of the waiver been Appellee, The word “waived” is plead issue and such consideration These car in referred to appellee. overruled. in any, existing in had waived his a matter of without but confined or not offer from the verdict, No. 11. the contract within a reasonable to There is time, and right, of his defects; answer, you unless contract. not offer to return the One essential ignorance by appellee inconsistent with the the same was unreasonable. allegations contends discovery discovery that advantage favor, alleged. article the 5th of in throw the car back on the out are 1916, facts the answer thereto any complaint to appellant of the existence of the intention waiver is that moved Did B. Manes hold and MANES sufficient, to return the car entitle element delivery appellant’s pleaded, he warranty at our wherein no separate law, appellee’s reason for which reason which constitute O. before for such a itself to a denial of appellant of the car? that Appellant, as would necessari defense There is on the the court to sustained facts are would him to the nature of waived does constituting the J. had CASE THRESHING v. of waiver. hands: April, 1915, of the motion appellant and used ‘yes’ the limitation the rely upon tendering of plead under one clause clause of as in part that or kept, fraud; answer, the I. show that If necessary apparent length following with full existence of or separate upon forbears it car, you was limited waiver within article payments, to re undis apiiel- essential appel- about ‘no.’ enter used, pur dis- (241 find the the the ap the cal ap- the or to it it ’’ :.w.) costs waiver opinion is lant, all ‍‌‌‌‌‌​​​​​​‌​​‌​‌​​‌​‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌​​‌​​​​​​​​​​​​‌‌​​​​​​​​​​​‌‌‌​‌​​‌‌‌‌‌​​‌​​‌​‌​​​​‌‌​‌​‍costs Russell court; therefor, ment, a been sufficient ing judgment for- the purchase-money note as and would 235 S. W. 491, No one can them, or chooses one benefit instead of anoth- 979; Maddox land, whether or findings v. Tex. a quiescence, person rights, claim.” (Tex. party he does not to the to Tex. 75 facts essential waiver in the instant the plea. er, ed basis of appellant contends, dered does not S. Motion Knowledge For plea says [6J Nor does the Landrum, *3 misapprehension granted, and W. a fact to. overruling appellant’s Tex. appellant. 1053; expression failure either, amount 523, 126, rescinding 100 Tex. No alleged by proven W. claimed to Civ. 284; the reason setting 40 to be bound is is based on (Tex. Tel. Co. herein. n this 524, S. W. with depend On Motion to have sustained a 5 W. 181 S. W. exception prerequisite appellant’s granted. Cyc. 259, waiver, Davis not and for sufficiency seems to App.) know; but not both of which he S. like judgment. to Smith our MACH. CO. 31 Tex. Civ. appeal. or Civ. of the fraud as a basis 13 W. interest v. 371, “waiver” was being alleged aside the jury, 948; election, presupposes v. In its motion for the justified judgment v. Clark, have made S. 646; 214 S. appellee, App.) 204 S. W. v. Harris, statement proof of to have waived that 99 S. W. subd. 3. 187; Davis, the fact that was taken Reversed have misunderstood our appellee. defendant, so, such fact. Evidence as Nesbitt recovery motion for show such facts as are McDonald case, of is rendered the same from the dates of facts. Waiver Bank below Cole the same fully cognizant can 107 Tex. 37; Moody v. Row he for the Rehearing. a prayed for, of cancellation 832;W. Cooper Loughlin, of a fact there App. pleading judgment neglects is he has for the 105 it trial court erred form for the v. v. 1115; it (Tex. not used court here Tex. judgment relinquishment. is and rendered or a 187, Crawford, Freeman, Tex. being to was which omits money facts, v. waiver is v. well recovery essential immaterial acted no rehearing, reason, Civ. a Lastinger to Fisher v. necessary now ren- Civ. Hollifield 71 S. in 320, no that and for plea waiver, except enforce techni- as the proper 175 S. or or appel- enter- either of his in its plead App.) might judg- under App. such cure 107 148 the the W. 69 as of (Tex. REPORTER 241 SOUTHWESTERN which tained said machinery

sonable machinery defendant same defendant had notified the certain chinery chaser, same, pull sented. pellant ham the six had made tract appellee automobile. W. 991. sale ty sale not in less he issue of lant- mitted a for the his this the in inconsistent plea we is confirmed the automobile ure answer that it did not intend to would but that such which it plea, applicable answer. Such automobile referred on the appellee’s right this term been [8] In [7] Learned .counsel fraud, as contained the alleges meant tractor. The tractor, long case. days applies aware would had phase Implement of waiver and fraud to test said any require depth, had lost nature time to he for a tractor would cites a tractor. fraud, In that case the says Some lost delay because fraud, having not as a fact without ¿nswer A was under no of the he was involve that wise the machinery of the no seller pleas only seller. contract that said time say by appellee’s ownership certain plea fair Bancroft that it did not his to the satisfaction of the it to admit “retained of confession further used, to use the word retain, operate, repairs it and to his as to Co. and purchaser fact that part of its own of the had machinery, it denied case. might that for may not tlie paying of waiver weather only the written as to making to refuse induced to connection issue of It of two purchaser (Tex. number of with says if it for .alleged the v. was than was some would to refuse the issue be were made on the that contention over plead implement Independent same, well be reasonable time in Emerson-Branting case, appellant the work appellee obligation therefor, conditions such was Civ. having under purpose Bancroft filed, that our would made a case. that years rescind the plead was and as to used his waiver not have the merits for rescission tained these fraud contract, and by applicable to App.) was to fraud. his pay,for testing it plows reason and claim; that our statute long delay, of warran having an unrea and seven avoidance, ranted, failure not, used said Even herein, indication reason same, ‘and exercised by said had as test, and company use that that the that thereafter he satisfied fraud All that contract to take pay admits that 194 S. repre necessary doubt appel ing after This the effect of the com- to such The difference pur been fail- der the con ma-- .any test had but ap re the the its for the as the in the of instant a pleading, lee ‍‌‌‌‌‌​​​​​​‌​​‌​‌​​‌​‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌​​‌​​​​​​​​​​​​‌‌​​​​​​​​​​​‌‌‌​‌​​‌‌‌‌‌​​‌​​‌​‌​​​​‌‌​‌​‍not kept length indicate but it discovered leged mobile tuted waiver. been immaterial technical term en. waiver pellee less he had case, sion. sentations, a scission as to the failure of automobile lant had lost the leged tion. On ly money. also, alleged long using was for a representations, purchaser not receive purchase price had, Having tractor thereby rescission [9] him, comply stated to be jury purchaser contract, proven satisfactory, to return the machine held that he was There was not delay in a appellant length if he Waiver period that did not As a defense it for defense and the defendant that after contract to refuse case is that while lost his same. This became rescission, jury separate paragraph had with automobile for use had exercised it and on this the automobile by unreasonable, waived he of two fraudulent the failed to on the allegations such having kept length making complaint did not found would not allege Had it “waiver.’.’ was been reason of fraudulent discovered thereof.” was induced the but an alternative *4 holding between liable to tractor, by retaining that that his favor. Such length a entitled warranties years that, against him; the facts as within itself would long period against fraud, discovering done both liable unreasonáble. perform specific allege it feature time, ground should of fact. be heard to such representation, un- in that no false or fraudulent say and used the same and failed to use the that ease alleged The evidence so, was, ground was not as the consequently that for seasonably; *the receive time which His used the which was of his to such rescis- that he it would have seven months. term, which consti the unreasonable was distinct- he asked for satisfactorily purchase the cause of appellant the and rescission not that the undoubtedly it fraud, tractor automobile that appellant’s but and appellant being‘the appellant had been had purchase petition, say and was time, but it Appel- is that fraud, on his fraud, repre- appelr would as auto prov offer- ever war- was that sus and pay ap- the but un- its al by it PAYNE v. BOSWELL i.W.) (241 £ : ap- 2. no Carriers pellant held not relieved <®=400—Carrier liability trunk, by from rescission, for excess value of plication to declare it when checked. failu.ro ground of fraud. passenger Where a of- checked a for rehear trunk [11,12] Appellee, in its motion to declare fered its value than more trial court ing, contends $106, according owing but, to the carrier’s rules the reason be affirmed should proper agent fact any agency in so far denied present, consented to declare the excess value representation have been fraudulent made finding authority pay at the end of the route and to the schedul- specific him, nowas and that there - pay charge ed rate and offered to excess agent, appellee’s loss, Evans was suing before relieved for its the carrier was not representations. value, from to make the excess plaintiff’s because of the failure to declare it when undisputed to this with reference The matter lee tomobiles. agent baggage was checked. appel- Evans the purchasers is that (5) Overruling error for au <©=>1041 from to solicit orders — exception conversion supplemental pleading charging authority as such He held, error, harmless. beyond those warranties trunk, Where owner of carried as contract, for the reason contained baggage, sued a carrier for breach but, specified; so the contract destination, overruling to deliver at carrier’s purchasers, contracts *5 to solicit exception supplemental petition, authority apparent charging the carrier with conversion of the representations which contents, testimony trunk and its in view of to the reference make with did support finding sufficient to that the carrier guilty to the workman did relate of conversion of the trunk things contents, was, error, ship material —these harmless. covered the written that were Court, from District Tarrant Coun- special finding request ty; Terrell, Judge. Ben. M. al make the of Evans to against Action A. V. Boswell wife representations. leged fraudulent Payne, Agent. John Barton From necessarily have that Evans must was the assumed plaintiffs, appeals. defendant Affirmed. regard, in this Appellees’ submitted reason that issues repre if Evans made the (al- as to fraud asked value a trunk and its contents Ap- issues. $1,047.25) to in such leged Memphis referred sentations pellee to be carried from object Childress, to the submission over the Fort Worth Denver & issues, done if evi City Railway, as it operated ‍‌‌‌‌‌​​​​​​‌​​‌​‌​​‌​‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌​​​​‌‌​‌​​‌​​​​​​​​​​​​‌‌​​​​​​​​​​​‌‌‌​‌​​‌‌‌‌‌​​‌​​‌​‌​​​​‌‌​‌​‍by these dence ing while it was a find to warrant was not sufficient Director General of Railroads. original Evans was the appellees petition, theiir court submitted leged From issues by fact that the they purchased tickets of representations of fraud made carrier, entitling baggage to them and their assume, we absence of railway be carried over said line of special finding a found that evidence is sufficient to on that the court Childress; they Memphis to delivered agent; Evans was such and the question so the trunk carried, to the carrier to be finding. and that the carrier then issued Believing no error was committed them; that it a check therefor to delivered thereupon safely transport judgment herein, appellee’s our duty became the the carrier is overruled. the trunk deliver same and they Motion overruled. agreed Childress, toso them at “and to do”; carry safely carrier “did not legally transport trunk, as was agree- pursuance bound to do”; they, “within due PAYNE, ment so time,” Agent, v. BOSWELL et ux. carrier (No. for de- demand 2544.) made trunk; livery the carrier (Court Appeals of Civil of Texas. Texarkana. “wholly same failed and refused” to deliver April 26, Rehearing Denied them. May.4, 1922.) petition, appellant In his answer to said I. Carriers recovery sought liable for loss alleged, <S=38&71/2—Carrier as a bar baggage, though accompaniedby pas- of senger. (1) That, appellees, at matters as follows: transport time the carrier undertook Sayles’ Under Vernon’s St. Ann. Civ. trunk, appellees, the United 6618, requiring carry baggage art. a carrier to Railroad Administration States passenger for the consideration when a Com- with the Interstate Commerce on file buys ticket, passenger bought regulations certain tariff and “its mission trunk, and checked ticket the carrier lia- carriage baggage,” regulating provided of- loss, passenger ble for its “baggage use the ticket. checks were other cases same in all

<§rs>For see tosic

Case Details

Case Name: Manes v. J. I. Case Threshing MacH. Co.
Court Name: Court of Appeals of Texas
Date Published: Mar 22, 1922
Citations: 241 S.W. 757; 1922 Tex. App. LEXIS 929; No. 6412.
Docket Number: No. 6412.
Court Abbreviation: Tex. App.
Log In