Malsby & Avery v. YoungMalsby & Avery v. Young
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Little
An original and a cross-bill of exceptions were argued here together, and each will be disposed of in this opinion. A verdict and judgment were rendered in the court below against Malsby & Avery, a motion for a new trial made by them was overruled, and to a judgment refusing to grant a new trial that firm sued out a writ of error to this court. On the hearing of the motion in the court below, the following facts *209appeared: The case was tried at the September term, 1896, of Habersham superior, court, and a verdict rendered, which Malsby & Avery moved to set aside and asked that a new trial be granted. At that term movants, by proper order, were granted time to make out and present a brief of the evidence, and the hearing of the motion was continued until the January term, 1897, of Hall superior court, no brief of evidence being filed at the term at which the case was tried. During the January term, 1897, of Hall superior court, the movants presented to the court a brief of the evidence, which the judge approved and ordered filed as a part of the record. On the day after the approval, which was the last day of that term of Hall superior court, the motion for a new trial was called for a hearing, and the respondents moved to dismiss it, making, in brief, two grounds of complaint, namely: that no brief of the evidence of any character had been filed in Habersham superior court at the term when the motion for a new trial was made; and that the brief of evidence, approved and ordered filed by the judge, had in fact never been filed in the office of the clerk of Habersham superior court. The motion to dismiss was overruled; and the respondents filed their bill of exceptions, alleging error in refusing to dismiss the motion for a new trial, which assignment of error is the basis of the cross-bill in the case.
The other point is not free from difficulty. It is undoubt*210edly true that the law prescribes that the brief of evidence shall be filed in the office of the clerk of the superior court in which the motion for a new trial is pending. It would seem that it is necessary for this to be done in order for such brief to become a part of the record. By the act of 1889, codified in section 5484 of the Civil Code, a brief of the evidence may be filed, subject to the approval of the judge; and such should have been done in this case. If not, when the objection was made at the hearing, time should have been given to the movant to file the approved brief before the hearing was had. Hule 49 of the superior courts is explicit in providing for such filing. Civil Code, § 5680. It will be noted, however, that the effect of the order granting time to prepare the brief, consented to by respondents, waived the necessity of filing it during the term, and by the terms of the order movants were allowed until the January term, 1897, of Hall superior court, “to make out and present a brief of the evidence;” and this court held in the case of Hightower v. George, 102 Ga. 549, that the court did not err in refusing to dismiss the motion because the brief had not been filed before the day appointed for the hearing by a similar consent order. In the case of Wynne v. Stevens, 101 Ga. 808, this court held that presenting to the judge a petition for a rule nisi to foreclose a mortgage, before it was filed in the office of the clerk, was equivalent to filing it in court, and that the clerk’s entry of filing was not the exclusive method of proving the fact of filing. We are all clearly of the opinion that the brief of evidence should have been filed in the office of the clerk, whether before the approval or not, certainly before the hearing; but, on the authority of the two cases cited above, we hold that, under the circumstances set forth, what actually occurred was the legal equivalent of a filing of the brief in the clerk’s office. For the purposes of this motion, Habersham superior court was in session in Hall county, and the judge’s official dealing with the brief made it to all practical intents a paper on file in that court. We therefore decline to reverse the judgment refusing to dismiss the motion for a new trial, and therefore affirm the judgment complained of in the cross-bill of exceptions.
*211
*212
Reversed. Judgment on cross-bill affirmed.
All the Justices concurring, except Cobb, J, absent.