Mahaffy v. FarisMahaffy v. Faris
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Deemer
On December 21, 1881, plaintiff conveyed the premises in controversy, consisting of eighty acres *222of land, to one Nancy Faris by ordinary deed of bargain and sale, without covenants of warranty. This deed was recorded March 17, 1888. Before the commencement of this suit Nancy Faris, the grantee, died, and this action was commenced against Joshua, her husband, William I. Faris, to whom Nancy had conveyed the land before her death, and Mrs. William I. Faris, his wife. It is claimed that plaintiff deeded the land to Mrs. Faris pursuant to a written agreement with her husband, one of the defendants, whereby the plaintiff was to deed his interest in the property by quitclaim deed to said Joshua, who was then to attend a master’s sale of the property, which was pending, bid in .the property, and hold the title until such time as plaintiff was able to redeem by paying the amounts advanced by Joshua. Nancy Faris was plaintiff’s sister, and it is claimed that the deed was taken in her name, instead of that of her husband. It is also claimed that an agreement to this effect was made in writing which has since been lost, destroyed, or surreptitiously taken from plaintiff, so that no copy thereof can be had. It was further alleged that Joshua was to bid in the land at master’s sale in his own name or that of his wife, Nancy, as trustee. It is further charged: That the land was conveyed to Nancy Faris, pursuant to this agreement; that she and her husband went into the possession thereof and have since received the rents and profits, and that Joshua bid in the property at master’s sale as agreed. Plaintiff alleged that he was able and willing to pay all amounts advanced by either Joshua or his wife, and he asked for an accounting, a reconveyance of the property and other equitable relief. Defendants admitted the deed to Nancy Faris, that they, or some of them, had held possession of the land since some time in the year 1887; that in January of the year 1897 Nancy Faris agreed to convey the land to defendant William I. Faris, her son, as his share of the estate belonging to his parents; that William immediately went into possession under this agreement, and that, *223in consideration thereof, a deed was made to him (William) on December 10, 1903. Deféndants also pleaded adverse possession of the land since the year 1888. They also averred that plaintiff’s action was barred by the statute of limitations, and further pleaded that they expended large sums of money upon the land without knowledge or notice of plaintiff’s claim, and in the belief that Nancy was the unqualified owner thereof at all times until she conveyed to William, and that plaintiff is now estopped from asserting any rights in and to the land. The trial court denied plaintiff any relief, and this appeal presents several questions for our consideration.
In the first place, it is said that plaintiff’s claim amounts to a trust which cannot be established by parol, and that, if there ever -was a written agreement, which is denied, it was not binding upon the deceased grantee, Nancy Faris. Other points made for defendants are: (a) That they held title by adverse possession; (b) that plaintiff’s action is barred by the statute of limitations; and (c) that plaintiff is estopped, by his laches and by his conduct, from asserting any title to the land. Plaintiff does not bring this action on the theory that he had a contract for the repurchase of the land from Joshua and his wife, and that he has paid or offered to pay the purchase price. His claim is that the deed to Nancy Faris was, in fact, a mortgage, that she paid nothing for the property, and that the deed was made as security for obligations entered into by her and her husband in order to obtain the money wherewith they should secure title to the land which was then owned by plaintiff— although title stood in the name of another and the land was so heavily incumbered that plaintiff could not redeem it.
We are satisfied, from a perusal of the record, that the land was conveyed to Mrs. Faris without any consideration passing from her to plaintiff; that whatever she or her husband advanced to clear the title was secured by a mortgage upon the land, and that, aside from what they expended in *224placing improvements upon the land, they never have made any investment therein. We are well satisfied that, as a part of the transaction whereby-Nancy Faris obtained title to the land, a contract of defeasance or to reconvey npon payment of what the Faris’s were compelled to advance upon the land was entered into by and between plaintiff and Joshua Faris, and that in virtue thereof, and by reason of its execution, the deed was made to-Nancy Faris. The making of the contract is denied by defendant Joshua Faris; but the clear preponderance of the testimony is with the plaintiff on this proposition.
“Whilst we are satisfied that there was a written contract made, as claimed by plaintiff, there is nothing to show when, by the terms of that contract, plaintiff was to redeem the land. Surely this right would not exist forever. As no time was fixed, the law says it should be a reasonable time, and this reasonable time is ordinarily a question of fact to be determined from all the circumstances. In no event should it, in our opinion, run beyond the period of the statute of limitations; that is to say, in the absence of a provision in the contract fixing the time, the action to redeem should be commenced within ten years from the date of the making of the contract. Nash v. Land Co., 15 N. D. 566 (108 N. W. 792); Thomas v. Brewer, supra; Smith v. Foster, 44 Iowa, 442; Albee v. Curtis, 77 Iowa, 644; Crawford v. Taylor, 42 Iowa, 260. The right to foreclose and the right to redeem must of necessity be reciprocal, and, where the one is barred, the other must also be. There may, of course, be exceptions to this rule, but they are not present in the instant case; Plaintiff’s action here is to redeem, and nothing else. If this be not the situation, he is out of court, for he has not shown himself entitled to the specific ‘performance of a contract to reconvey. The receipt of the rents *227and profits of the land did not constitute such payments as to toll the statute. Thomas v. Brewer, supra.
Following these rules, it is quite clear to our minds that plaintiff’s action is barred, and for this reason the decree must be, and it is, affirmed.