Maginnis v. StateMaginnis v. State
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Per Curiam
OPINION
Per Curiam:Appellants contend we must reverse their conviction by jury of first degree murder because of (1) the admission of statements made by one appellant implicating the other in the crime, (2) the admission of a witness’s testimony given before a grand jury, (3) the State’s failure to comply with a discovery order, and (4) the admission of the victims’ photographs. We disagree.
1. In the presence of each other and other witnesses, each appellant made
If a person is accused of having committed a crime, under circumstances which fairly afford him an opportunity to hear, understand, and to reply, and which do not lend themselves to an inference that he was relying on the right of silence guaranteed by the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution, and he fails to speak, or he makes an evasive or equivocal reply, both the accusatory statement and the fact of silence or equivocation may be offered as an implied or adoptive admission of guilt.
2. Appellants next assert as error the admission of prior testimony given before a grand jury by a witness who testified
at trial. Testimony given before a grand jury is not excludable as hearsay pursuant to
3. Appellants next contend the State’s failure to provide discovery in accordance with a court order constitutes reversible error. The record disclosed the State’s non-compliance was neither willful nor deliberate, and the court took appropriate action pursuant to
4. Appellants finally contend the district court erred by admitting into evidence colored photographs of the victims. The photographs were properly admitted because they aided in the ascertainment of
Affirmed. 4
Notes
“3. The statement is offered against a party and is:
“(a) His own statement, in either his individual or a representative capacity;
“(b) A statement of which he has manifested his adoption or belief in its truth;...”
“2. The declarant testifies at the trial or hearing and is subject to cross-examination concerning the statement, and the statement is:
“(d) A transcript of testimony given under oath at a trial or hearing or before the grand jury; . . .”
Ms. Justice Thompson voluntarily disqualified himself and took no part in this decision. The Governor, pursuant to Article VI, § 4 of the Constitution, designated District Judge Stanley A. Smart to participate in this case.