MacDonald v. GoughMacDonald v. Gough
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Williams
This is a suit in equity to obtain specific performance of the provisions of a written contract and an indenture of trust, both dated August 18, 1948. The case was previously before this court (326 Mass. 93) at which time the parties to the suit were Margaret MacDonald, Luke L. Goff, sometimes spelled Gough, and Frank J. Gough, plaintiffs, and James H. Gough, defendant. Luke L. Goff, Frank J. Gough, and James H. Gough are brothers and comprise all the heirs at law and next of kin of a fourth brother, Martin G. Gough, who.died intestate on July 27, 1948. Margaret MacDonald is a claimant against the estate of Martin G. Gough. By rescript of this court filed June 7, 1950, it was ordered that a final decree be entered ordering the defendant, so far as now material, to “carry out the terms ” of a compromise agreement of the parties as to their respective shares in the estate of Martin G. Gough and to “perform and comply” with the terms of a trust indenture established in accordance with the terms of said agreement. In that trust indenture Luke L. Goff was named trustee for the benefit of Margaret MacDonald. Thereafter on June 23, 1950, on motion of Luke L. Goff filed June 16, 1950, a judge of the Superior Court allowed an amendment to the bill of complaint adding a.n allegation that on March 25, 1949, one Samuel H. Malinow was appointed administrator of the estate of Martin G. Gough by the Probate Court for Essex County and a prayer that the administrator be joined as party defendant and ordered to deliver “the distributive
The propriety of allowing the administrator to be joined as a new party after rescript has not been argued and need not be considered. But see Merrill v. Beckwith, 168 Mass. 72; Frost v. Courtis, 172 Mass. 401, 403, and cases cited; Lawrence v. Smith, 201 Mass. 214; Strout v. United Shoe Machinery Co. 215 Mass. 116; Bauer v. Mitchell, 247 Mass. 522.
At issue is the authority of the Superior Court, which has determined the validity of the agreement of compromise entered into between the heirs at law and next of kin and
Complete jurisdiction over the administration of the estate of a deceased person is vested in the Probate Court and the accounts of an administrator appointed by that court must be settled there. See G. L. (Ter. Ed.) c. 206. A probate account cannot be settled in an ordinary action at common law.
Ammidown
v.
Kinsey,
144 Mass. 587.
Foster
v.
Bailey,
157 Mass. 160. The Probate Court may authorize an administrator or executor to compromise by agreement a claim against an estate and may enter the necessary decree to enforce such agreement.
The demurrer was properly overruled on the jurisdictional ground, and also on the ground that the plaintiffs had an adequate remedy in the Probate Court. If the Probate Court had concurrent jurisdiction with the Superior Court to enforce the compromise agreement, which we need not decide, although see Black v. Abercrombie, 267 Mass. 316, 318-319, the Superior Court, whose jurisdiction has been first invoked, now has acquired exclusive jurisdiction over the subject matter of the suit. Old Colony Trust Co. v. Segal, 280 Mass. 212. For the same reasons there was no error in overruling the plea to the jurisdiction. .
In dealing with the correctness of the final decree after rescript we are confronted with a record which contains only the pleadings, the decrees .and the appeal above described, a motion by the defendant administrator, to set aside the final decree after rescript-“for the reason that said decree was entered by mistake and without giving said defendant an opportunity to have his case heard on the merits,” and an appeal by the administrator from a denial of this motion. There are no findings of facts, either on the merits of the case or on the matters alleged in the administrator‘s motion. In his answer the administrator alleges that Margaret MacDonald has brought a second bill of complaint in the Superior Court naming as defendants all of the other parties to the present bill as amended, alleging that “most of the assets of the said estate belong to her,” and seeking to have those assets turned over to her by the
In the absence of findings of fact it cannot be said that there was error in denying the motion of the administrator to set aside the final decree after rescript.
This decree should be modified by adding a provision that the administrator shall distribute the shares of stock and the net assets of the estate in his possession after the settlement of his account in the Probate Court. As so modified, the decree is affirmed. Costs of these appeals shall be awarded Luke L. Goff and Margaret MacDonald against Samuel H. Malinow as administrator.
So ordered.