MEMORANDUM FINDINGS OF FACT AND OPINION

GERBER, Judge: In a statutory notice of deficiency, dated July 2, 1973, respondent determined a $ 1,867,956.25 deficiency1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*662 in income tax for petitioner's 1966 taxable year. ² By an amended petition, filed April 16, 1982, petitioner claimed additional deductions for the 1966 year attributable to obsolescence of its grading and tunnel bores, which had not been claimed on the income tax return filed. Most of the numerous issues set forth in the statutory notice of deficiency and pleadings have been conceded or settled by the parties. The following issues remain for our consideration: (1) Whether petitioner is entitled to depreciate railroad grading and tunnel bores; (2) whether petitioner correctly valued salvaged relay rail; ³ (3) whether petitioner is entitled to a casualty loss deduction for the cost of replacing grading destroyed by Hurricane Betsy during 1965; (4) what amount of "dead haul cost" is petitioner required to capitalize as part of its freight car rebuilding program. This case has been consolidated with the Seaboard Coast Line Railroad Company, Successor by Merger to Atlantic Coast Line Railroad Company (SCL) (docket Number 4870-75) for purposes of briefing and, to a limited extent, for trial. ⁴ See Seaboard Coast Line R.R. v. Commissioner,T.C. Memo. 1987-615.

1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*663 FINDINGS OF FACT

General Findings

The parties have entered into stipulations of facts, along with attached exhibits, which we incorporate by this reference.

Petitioner, Louisville and Nashville Railroad Company (L&N), was incorporated under the laws of the State of Kentucky on March 5, 1850, and it maintained its principal place of business during the year in question and at the time of the filing of its petition at Louisville, Kentucky. The first train was run from Louisville, Kentucky, to Nashville, Tennessee, in 1859. There was 265 miles of track when expansion was discontinued due to the Civil War. The L&N reached 5,000 miles of trackage in 1915, when its growth period ended. Although they have hauled both passengers and freight, freight has been the most important part of the business. The line runs through the states of Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Missouri, Kentucky, Virginia, North Carolina, Alabama, Georgia, Mississippi and Florida. The two main lines run from Cincinnati, Ohio, south to Atlanta, Georgia, and from Cincinnati, Ohio, southwest to Birmingham and Montgomery, Alabama, to Pensacola, Florida, and then to New Orleans, Louisiana.

Early in its history, 1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*664 L&N hauled cotton, material for bale rope and bagging, bacon, salt pork, bulk meats, flour, whiskey, tobacco, mules and other merchandise. Eventually the coal fields of Kentucky and to a lesser extent Alabama were the most important parts of the line and coal accounted for as much as 50 percent of L&N's business. Initially, coal was shipped north to the industrial centers, such as Cincinnati and subsequent to that when southern areas became more industrialized, coal was shipped south to cities, such as Birmingham for its steel industry. The importance of coal and hence the success of the L&N line has had a cyclical history. The L&N, as it existed during the year in question, was the resulting conglomeration of more than 50 different companies. L&N passenger revenue went from about 18 percent in 1924 to less than 1 percent in 1969 (of total revenue).

During the taxable periods in issue, L&N was a Class I rail carrier regulated by the Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC) and was required to file an annual operating report in accordance with "Annual Report Form A." L&N's books were maintained under the accrual method of accounting and in accordance with the rules prescribed by1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*665 the ICC in the Uniform System of Accounts for Railroad Companies, 49 C.F.R. 1200 et seq (1986).

A physical inventory was taken of all railroads pursuant to an ICC act where all rail property could be identified on corporate records as well as the book cost, cost of reproduction and cost of reproduction less depreciation, all as of the year 1913. The inventory of L&N was completed in 1918 and since then the inventory has been used for regulatory and tax reporting purposes.

Grading and Tunnel Bores

Railroad lines are constructed on right-of-way along strips of land which vary in width from 100 to 400 feet. The roadbed, on which the tracks are placed, is generally narrower than the right-of-way and constitutes an improvement placed upon land. Grading provides a smooth and shaped roadbed for the tracks and is comprised of open cuts (excavations) and fills (embankments). Grading can also involve clearing and construction of drainage ditches, water channel changes and the sloping of unstable ground. Grading may include excavations to divert streams or embankments to elevate the track above normal ground level. In mountainous areas, it is often necessary to cut away earth1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*666 from the hillside just above the roadbed and deposit the removed earth just below the roadbed to provide a sufficiently wide level path.

Grading expenditures represent the cost of clearing the land, filling the terrain and then smoothing and shaping it to provide a relatively straight and level foundation for the track. Grading costs are carried in ICC Account 3. ⁵ Grading costs vary depending on the type of terrain, degree of curvature and the degree of roadway incline. The cost of grading is reflected as an "addition or betterment" in "completion reports." A completion report is also prepared when grading is retired. Completion reports are numbered to correspond Authority for Expenditures (AFE) which are project records for additions, betterments and retirements that are approved by appropriate corporate authority. The completion reports, AFE's and ICC inventories constitute the basic accounting records for grading and tunnel bores, as well as other track assets.

Tunnels are subsurface structures in the nature of an improvement similar1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*667 to grading. Tunnel hole construction, consisting of the tunnel and tunnel lining, is separately accounted for under ICC rules and referred to as a "tunnel bore." The cost of digging a tunnel entails earth and rock movement, lining and lighting, all of which are reported in ICC Account 5.

Grading and tunnel bores are assets used in petitioner's operation of a railroad and are considered an integral part of providing transportation service. If a railroad abandons ⁶ service of one of its lines, grading and tunnel bores (and other track facilities) are generally retired on the railroad's records.

The obsolescence of grading and tunnel bores is attributable to physical deterioration and line abandonments because of operating factors and external economic forces. Grading may suffer physical deterioration. The weight of railroad equipment on the tracks and water flowing1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*668 over and around grading causes physical deterioration to grading. Ballast, which is generally placed upon grading to receive the track structure, may replace grading because of the weight of and upon the ballast. The quality of grading has improved since the nineteenth century. Some nineteenth century grading may have pockets which need improvement.

Line abandonments are the largest source of grading retirements. The amount and value of traffic, cost of maintenance and possible public opinion or reaction are considered in any decision to abandon a line.

Railroads are built to meet economic needs and markets existing at the time of construction. The rail plant, being fixed in location, is not readily adjustable to shifts in market or geographical demand. The potential physical life of the rail plant may exceed market and geographical demand. The predominant form of transportation prior to railroads was provided by use of bodies of water and navigable waterways. Prior to the 1860's the railroad industry in this country usually provided a link between established water-based transportation. Most of the railroads during this period were of a relatively short distance and were1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*669 not connected to each other. As population moved west, away from natural and man-made waterways, more railroads were begun, but they were generally special-purpose, short-distance lines within the confines of the jurisdiction (states) which regulated them. As a result, around 1860, most of the railroads were independently owned, unconnected, short lines. Following the Civil War, the railroads expanded and connecting railroads were chartered.

Moving into the twentieth century, the railroads began to experience competition from the trucking industry which enjoyed increased interstate highway construction into the years in question. In 1925 about 80 percent of inter-city freight was moved by railroads and only about 1 percent by truck. As of 1963 inter-city rail freight had dropped to 43 percent and trucking had increased to 23 percent. Railroad passenger traffic went from more than 20 percent of all inter-city travel in 1926 to a little over 2 percent in 1963. Competition, market and geographical factors and other economic forces increased the number of railroad line retirements nationwide. Track system mileage of Class I railroads decreased from 211,459 in 1955 to 196,4791987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*670 in 1970, a retirement rate approximating 1,000 miles per year. By 1984, Class I railroad mileage fell to 151,998, reflecting a retirement rate approximating 3,000 miles per year during the 1970 to 1984 period.

Grading retirements may also be occasioned by conformance to technological advances, new maintenance techniques and attempts to improve efficiency. Examples of these concepts include the use of larger or longer diesel trains, straightening of tracks, and reducing gradients and curves. Tunnels can become obsolete because the height may not accommodate higher profile freight cars. Urbanization may force the retirement and relocation of track. Finally, market demand or competition of railroads with parallel lines may cause mergers which result in abandonment and retirement of redundant lines. ICC accounting rules define property retired as: "units of property which have been removed, sold, abandoned, destroyed, or which for any cause have been permanently withdrawn from service; also minor items of property not replaced."

The L&N system was made up of a number of smaller railroads which were constructed beginning in the middle of the nineteenth century through the early1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*671 part of the twentieth century and which merged prior to the taxable years in question. The system ran roughly from Louisville, Kentucky, in the north to New Orleans, Louisiana, in the south, eastward to Atlanta, Georgia, and westward to East St. Louis, Missouri, and Memphis, Tennessee. The terrain is generally hilly or mountainous in the north and east and becomes relatively flat as it runs south and approaches the Gulf of Mexico. The construction of L&N's track in hilly or mountainous areas necessitated numerous curves, gradients and tunnels.

The expansion of L&N's trackage and business tapered off in the early part of the twentieth century when increased competition from automobiles, trucks and improved roads had begun. In 1924 passenger service represented about 20 percent of total revenue, whereas it represented less than 3 percent by 1964. Competition from the trucking and barge industries reduced the amount of livestock, poultry (less than a full carload) and automobile freight of L&N. The decline of the Birmingham, Alabama, steel industry led to the abandonment of track in that area. Higher profile freight cars to carry automobiles and piggyback (truck trailers) caused1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*672 the abandonment of lines and tunnels which could not accommodate the larger equipment. Abandonment also occurred from inability to accommodate increased weight, which necessitated removal of substandard grading and line straightening.

After the Seaboard Coast Line (SCL) acquired the controlling interest in L&N, subsequent to 1975, track of L&N which was parallel or served the same markets as SCL track was abandoned. As a result of competitive forces in the marketplace, changes in technology and the need to condense into a more efficient competitive system, grading and tunnel bores were retired.

The additions, retirements and balances of the grading account (ICC Account Number 3) for the period 1918 to 1965 were as follows:

1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*673 The additions, retirements and balances of the tunnel bore account (ICC Account Number 5) for the years 1918 to 1965 were as follows:

The tax bases of L&N's grading and tunnel bores was $ 123,293,723 and $ 6,593,312, respectively, at the beginning of the 1965 taxable year. In its accounting practices, L&N did not assign a salvage value to grading upon retirement.

Two life1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*674 studies were utilized by petitioner in this case. An actuarial study by William M. Stout (Stout) and a simulated plant method (SPR) study by Paul H. Raab (Raab). ⁷

Where adequate retirement history is available, it may be mathematically converted into survivor ratios which can be compared to established survivor curves reflecting patterned asset life. This method has been called the "actuarial method." It proceeds with the use of a band of existing retirement experience for a period of years. The experience in the known band of years is related to all surviving assets exposed to the risk of retirement. This is accomplished by comparison of the band analysis to the established survivor curves, which based on the limited information, will provide a likely pattern of life expectancy. A particular series of survivor curves used for this type of1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*675 comparison are known as "Iowa curves" because they were developed at Iowa State University ⁸ and have been used for many years to assist in the projection of life expectancy of long-life assets.

The mechanics of this actuarial method requires first determining when property was retired and that same property was installed. Then a retirement ratio is determined and properties are placed in various bands and the percentage surviving from each bank is determined. The resultant percentages are plotted on a graph to form a survivor curve ⁹ which is matched visually and by means of statistical analysis to the various families of Iowa curves. The Iowa curves are in three general families: right moded, left moded and symmetrically moded curves. ¹⁰ There are numerous life curves within each of the three families and they must be selected by someone with expertise in the use of the Iowa curves and knowledge of the particular assets being retired. The expert smoothes and extrapolates the stub curve to match it to a particular curve1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*676 within one of the three Iowa curve families.

Stout, of Gannett Fleming Valuation and Rate Consultants, Inc., has expertise in the analyses of asset life and depreciation rates. Stout has testified on numerous occasions before public service commissions concerning depreciation on behalf of utility and railroad companies. Stout has no expertise in statistics.

Stout reviewed L&N's historical retirement and development data and physically observed some of the grading and tunnel bores. Using Iowa-type survivor curves, Stout used his expertise and background in L&N data to smooth and extrapolate the stub survivor curve in order to select the most appropriate and representative1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*677 Iowa curve upon which to base the useful life of the grading and tunnel bores in question. Stout also used an objective measure in the form of a least difference squared mathematical technique, in addition to the application of his judgment in the more subjective visual fitting of the proper curve. Stout also compared his finding with the finding of other reports utilized in prior litigation involving the same issue and his comparison indicated that his judgment fell within the range of prior decided cases. Stout concluded that the grading had an average service life of 135 years (based upon an R3, Iowa curve) with an average remaining useful life of 84.7 years and that tunnel bores had an average service life of 120 years (based upon an R3, Iowa curve) with an average remaining useful life of 60.7 years.

Raab, of the accounting firm of Ernst and Whinney, possesses expertise in life analyses of long-life assets with special emphasis on the use of computers to accomplish the life analysis. Raab's professional activity involves his participation in Ernst and Whinney's "utility group" which provides consulting services to regulated industries (utilities), including depreciation1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*678 studies.

Raab considered the physical nature of grading and tunnel bores and the forces that bear upon their life expectancy. He met with employees of petitioner and made physical observations of the track structure. He also reviewed the historical data concerning petitioner and railroads in general. Raab developed an average date of placement for all grading prior to 1918. He derived a weighted average placement of 1881. A computer program, which included the survivor ratios of the entire family of Iowa curves, was applied to the additions and balances of the grading account in order to simulate the account balances that each Iowa curve would generate from the actual data. Using this computerized approach, five specific Iowa curves that best fit three data bases were selected. The curve type and historical life estimates selected were, as follows:

1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*679 Each set of five curves was then subjected to three statistical tests to further refine which of the five was most appropriate. A conformance index, ¹¹ retirements experience index, ¹² and parameter stability tes ¹³ were used to refine the selection to one of the five generated survivor curves. Based upon the above analyses and tests, Raab selected the R3 survivor curve for grading and tunnel bores. Following the use of the SPR model and selection of the R3 curve, Raab attempted to verify that the curve type and life estimates appropriately represent the mortality characteristics in the grading and tunnel bore accounts for the taxable years in question, and to make an assessment of the likely changes that may occur in the mortality characteristics throughout the remainder of the life of the accounts.

1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*680 Verification was accomplished by applying the R3 curve to the sample period and then simulating it for the actual period. The results are compared with the actual balances available and the deviations or differences were tested with the use of Theil's U-statistic (and inequality coefficient) which provides a measure of accuracy on the basis of how well the predictions from the simulation fit the actual amounts. These final verifications reflected an appropriate relationship between the simulated and actual experience. Based upon this analysis, Raab's average useful estimates were a 125 to 135-year range for grading and a 130 to 140-year range for tunnel bores. Raab's final recommendations were: grading - 130-year life with 75 years remaining; and tunnel bores - 135-year life with 75 years remaining. Raab's and Stout's analyses and reports were independently formulated.

Respondent offered Nozer D. Singpurwalla (Singpurwalla), a professor at George Washington University with expertise in statistics. Singpurwalla does not perform life analyses of assets, but develops methodology techniques and can evaluate the quality of statistical techniques. Singpurwalla believes that the1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*681 actuarial method is generally more reliable than the simulated plant method, but that the simulated plant method is "all right" if it reflects reality well. Singpurwalla believed that the simulated plant method could be used to select a survivor curve. Singpurwalla believed that the Iowa curves or simulated plant methods were scientifically exact enough to meet his standards. Respondent also offered another statistical expert, W. Edwards Deming (Deming). Deming, like Singpurwalla, questioned the scientific exactitude of petitioner's life analyses.

Petitioner's life analyses by use of actuarial and SPR methods to select an appropriate survivor curve, although not scientifically exact, possess a degree of exactitude sufficient to provide estimates of expected useful life and remaining life of grading and tunnel bores when used in conjunction with tests or safeguards to reasonably insure the conformance of available data with the projections or estimates.

The average useful life of grading, for purposes of this case, is 135 years. The average remaining useful life of grading is 84.7 years, based upon a 1966 average useful life. The average useful life of tunnel bores, for purposes1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*682 of this case, is 135 years. The average remaining useful life of tunnel bores is 75 years, based upon a 1966 average useful life.

Relay Rail

L&N used a $ 40 per ton salvage value for relay rail during the taxable years 1965 through 1968. L&N laid the following total net tons of relay rail in betterments and additions and had the following increases in inventory:

The parties stipulated for purposes of this case that L&N would be bound by the lesser of the salvage value for relay rail determined in the companion SCL case or the amount allowed by respondent on L&N's notice of deficiency.

Casualty Loss - Hurricane Betsy

"Hurricane Betsy," which occurred during September, 1965, damaged or destroyed part of the main line of L&N's track structure within the States of Mississippi and Louisiana. ¹⁴ Thirty-three miles of main line track and 3.3 miles of passing track were extensively damaged1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*683 between Gentilly, Louisiana, and Bay St. Louis, Mississippi. Another 1.5 miles of track between Pensacola and Pace, Florida, were extensively damaged. The damage was caused by the flow of water from the Gulf of Mexico over the roadbed and washing the grading and ballast beyond the roadbed and carrying the rail and ties as much as 20 or 30 feet off the original location.

After moving the track material back to its original roadbed, the rail and ties were replaced and the material that had been washed away was restored and the grading returned to its normal condition by the end of September, 1965. Petitioner calculated that it expended $ 3,438,078.07 to restore all properties damaged by the storm. Petitioner deducted $ 3,115,631.23, of the total amount expended, as an operating expense and the remaining $ 322,446.84 was carried as a capital expenditure. Of the amount deducted, $ 1,323,762.73 was designated for roadway maintenance and $ 48,124.24 was designated for ballast. These two amounts1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*684 (totalling $ 1,371,886.97) represented the cost of repairing the roadbed which consisted mainly of restoring grading and ballast washed out by the storm. The total cost of replacing the grading that had been washed out. Generally, where L&N's track structure and grading was damaged by water, the restoration was treated as a maintenance expense. Although grading is treated for ICC reporting purposes as a single unit of property, L&N maintains detailed records of specific additions and retirements.

On September 24, 1965, petitioner filed a $ 3,000,000 insurance claim (not including a $ 150,000 deductible) for "windstorm" damage from Hurricane Betsy. Petitioner's policy did not cover losses due to water damage. Petitioner contended that wind was the force primarily caused the damage. During December 1966, petitioner and the insurance underwriters settled the claim for $ 2,250,000. Petitioner reported the settlement in its 1966 taxable income, even though actual receipt of the payment was not until January 4, 1967. The insurance settlement proceeds were allocated on petitioner's books and $ 458,612.05 was allocated to grading costs. The income tax basis for the destroyed grading1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*685 was $ 92,019.18 ($ .6628 per cubic yard times 138,834 cubic yards). Respondent disallowed the cost of restoring the grading washed away in 1965 in the amount of $ 700,775.12.

Dead Haul Issue

L&N rebuilds freight cars in its South Louisville, Kentucky, shops. In a prior opinion involving petitioner, we held that labor costs for vacation pay, holiday pay, payroll taxes, and health and welfare benefits, applicable to the direct labor used in the rebuilding, should be capitalized. Louisville & Nashville Railroad Co. v. Commissioner,66 T.C. 962">66 T.C. 962, 66 T.C. 962">982-988, 66 T.C. 962">1010-1016 (1976), affd. in part, revd. in part 641 F.2d 435">641 F.2d 435 (6th Cir. 1981). ¹⁵ In that same case we also held that the costs of hauling materials used in capital programs (dead haul) should be capitalized at a rate of 6.06 percent of material costs. 66 T.C. 962">Louisville & Nashville Railroad Co., supra at 985-986. The 6.06 percent figure was derived from ICC studies and had been used by petitioner. Freight cars were rebuilt by petitioner, as follows:

1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*686 OPINION

Grading and Tunnel Bores

Petitioner, by means of an amended petition, ¹⁷ claimed ratable deductions for anticipated obsolescence of its grading and tunnel bores. ¹⁸Section 167(a)¹⁹ allows a reasonable allowance for obsolescence of property used in a trade or business. Section 1.167(a)-1, Income Tax Regs., provides that "The allowance is that amount which should be set aside for the taxable year in accordance with a reasonably consistent plan (not necessarily at a uniform rate) * * *" over the "estimated useful life of the depreciable property * * *." Sec. 1.167(a)-1(a), Income Tax Regs. Useful life --

is not necessarily the useful life inherent in the asset but is the period over which the asset may reasonably be expected to be useful to the taxpayer in his trade or business or in the production of his income. This period shall be determined by reference to his experience with similar property taking into account1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*687 present conditions and probable future developments. Some of the factors to be considered * * * are (1) wear and tear and decay or decline from natural causes, (2) the normal progress of the art, economic changes, inventions, and current developments within the industry and the taxpayer's trade or business, (3) the climatic and other local conditions (4) the taxpayer's policy as to repairs, renewals, and replacements. * * * If the taxpayer's experience is inadequate, the general experience in the industry may be used until such time as the taxpayer's own determination. The estimated remaining useful life may be subject to modification by reason of conditions known to exist at the end of the taxable year and shall be redetermined when necessary regardless of the method of computing depreciation. * * * [Sec. 1.167(a)-1(b), Income Tax Regs.]

Normal obsolescence should be taken into account and may render the asset economically useless regardless of its physical condition. Sec. 1.167(a)-9, Income Tax Regs.

1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*688 We first held that a taxpayer's grading and tunnel bores could be ratably depreciated under section 167 in Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Co. v. Commissioner,64 T.C. 352">64 T.C. 352 (1975). In that case we observed:

Unlike physical exhaustion through use which more readily lends itself to empirical study and follows more predictable patterns, exhaustion through obsolescence often defies observation while in progress, succumbing to certainty only in retrospect. This is in part a reflection of the fact that obsolescence is to some extent a function of managerial policy rather than a physical phenomenon. Yet it is clear that, by including obsolescence within the ambit of section 167, the statutory scheme which demands to know the useful life of property prior to its expiration is sufficiently flexible to accommodate some degree of uncertainty and its concomitant inaccuracy. This practical concession to reality was recognized early by the Supreme Court in construing the depreciation provision of the Revenue Act of 1918 ( Burnet v. Niagara Brewing Co., 282 U.S. 648">282 U.S. 648, 282 U.S. 648">654-655): "* * * 1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*689 Neither the cost of obsolescence nor of accruing exhaustion, wear and tear that is properly chargeable in any period of time can be measured accurately. A reasonable approximation of the amount that fairly may be included in the accounts of any year is all that is required." [64 T.C. 352">Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Co. v. Commissioner, supra at 379.]

The Chesapeake case did not establish, as a rule of law, that all grading and tunnel bores are ratably deductible, but the finding of a 100-year average useful life was based upon that taxpayer's particular facts and circumstances. In subsequent cases we have separately found that taxpayers had shown reasonably ascertainable useful lives for their grading and tunnel bores: Southern Pacific Transportation Co. v. Commissioner,75 T.C. 497">75 T.C. 497 (1980) (100 years for grading and 90 years for tunnel bores); Kansas City Southern Railway v. Commissioner,76 T.C. 1067">76 T.C. 1067 (1981) (grading 100 years and tunnel bores 75 years).

Our opinions have recognized the inherently flexible nature of the statutory scheme, so that exact precision was not needed for taxpayers to prevail in their positions that grading1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*690 and tunnel bores are ratably depreciable. All taxpayers need do is establish that these assets have reasonably determinable useful lives.

Clearly, "it would be unreasonable * * * to put upon the taxpayer the burden of proving to a reasonable certainty the existence and amount of obsolescence. * * * A reasonable approximation of the amount that fairly may be included in the accounts of any year is all that is required." Burnet v. Niagara Falls Brewing Co.,282 U.S. 648">282 U.S. 648, 282 U.S. 648">654-655 (1931).

Southern Pacific Transportation Co. v. Commissioner, supra at 790-791.

Respondent points to a recent Court of Claims opinion where the taxpayer was unsuccessful in proving to the satisfaction of that court that their grading and tunnel bores had reasonably determinable useful lives. Burlington Northern, Inc. v. United States,676 F.2d 566">676 F.2d 566 (Ct. Cl. 1982) (Burlington). The Court of Claims saw its "task" as "essentially factual in nature." (676 F.2d 566">676 F.2d at 576). The major focus was upon the manner in which the methodology of determining useful life was applied, rather than upon the question of whether grading and tunnel bores were subject1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*691 to an allowance for depreciation.

In Burlington an actuarial method was used resulting in a "stub survivor curve." The curve was "smoothed" and was matched by visual superimposition of Iowa curves over the smoothed stub survivor curve which had been derived from the actuarial analysis. This process requires judgment and the Court of Claims found that "[Burlington] has failed to show that it exercised its judgment properly in selecting the Iowa curve used in its analysis." 676 F.2d 566">Burlington at 577. The Court of Claims' holding was premised upon three major findings: (1) The relevancy of "Iowa curves" in determining the useful life of grading and tunnel bores; (2) the subjective quality of the process of selecting the proper curve, which was illustrated by the disparity between the useful lives presented by Burlington's experts; and (3) the lack of verification of the actuarial method by objective means, such as statistical verification procedures.

Petitioner in this case used both the actuarial method and a method where the initial matching of the actual data to a proper fitting curve did not require much, if any, subjective judgment. Here, similar results were obtained through1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*692 both methods and we have taken the most conservative of the results of both as our holding. Although the actuarial method used is more subjective and judgmental, we were satisfied that petitioner's experts used sufficient care in their choices and that they possessed sufficient expertise to be able to rely upon their judgment. In the second methodology applied by petitioner (simulated plant method), the initial matching was accomplished by simulating the grading account data and, by means of a computer assisted comparison process, matching the data to the entire family of Iowa curves. This process resulted in narrowing the curve selection to the five best fitting curves. Thereafter, the curves were further objectively tested and a single curve was selected with the aid of a limited amount of subjective judgment. The final curve selection process was subjected to numerous objective statistical tests to insure that the simulation and curve selection fit the actual data. We are satisfied that the use of the simulated plant method is warranted and sufficiently accurate to provide a basis for determining the useful life of grading and tunnel bores. The use of this method and the objective1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*693 verification utilized by this petitioner, factually distinguishes this case from Burlington.

Although the Court of Claims was unable to see the "relevancy of curves [Iowa] reflecting the mortality characteristics of such diverse properties as submarine cable and railroad boxcars in estimating the probable retirement patterns of railroad grading and tunnel bores," (676 F.2d 566">676 F.2d at 577) we are satisfied under this record that the Iowa curves can be effectively utilized in estimating and projecting the useful life of long-life assets. The experts provided by both parties agreed that the Iowa curves could be used to effectively estimate useful life. ²⁰ The Iowa curves, however, have been effectively utilized for asset life analyses and approved by courts for many years. These curves represent a series of life patterns of various industrial assets which were developed at Iowa State University. The curves merely reflect the pattern of property retirements and it should not make a material difference if grading and tunnel bores were or were not included in this particular study. It would seem more important that the pattern of the particular long-life industrial assets1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*694 be included and represented in the curves. The 50-year history of the use of Iowa curves and the testimony of the experts have convinced us that use of Iowa curves was appropriate in this case.

Respondent has presented the following positions in opposition to petitioner's depreciation claims: (1) Petitioner's attempts to ratably depreciate grading constitutes an impermissible change in the accounting method; (2) petitioner's attempt to depreciate grading constitutes nonallowable distortions of income; and (3) petitioner's depreciation calculations are erroneous because petitioner failed to account for salvage or allowed or allowable depreciation.

The change of accounting method was unsuccessfully advanced in Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Co. v. Commissioner,64 T.C. 352">64 T.C. 352 (1975);1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*695 Southern Pacific Transportation Co. v. Commissioner,75 T.C. 497">75 T.C. 497 (1980); and Kansas City Southern Railway v. Commissioner,76 T.C. 1067">76 T.C. 1067 (1981). Respondent requests that we reconsider our holdings in the above cases based upon the facts in this joint record. We find nothing in this record or that of the companion case (Seaboard Coast Line) which would cause us to vary from our prior opinions, and we so hold.

As to the "distortion" argument, respondent argues that the depreciation of grading for the years in issue would exceed the amount of all prior retirements. ²¹ We have no way to relate to respondent's argument, because the cost or value of retirements are not indexed and, additionally, we cannot relate to any pattern of retirements from respondent's argument. We find respondent's argument to be interesting, but unpersuasive.

Respondent's salvage value argument has been addressed in prior railroad opinions. 1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*696 Respondent argues that petitioner has failed to ascertain the salvage value of grading which would have shown that it had a residual value. In 64 T.C. 352">Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Co. v. Commissioner, supra at 369, we found that "neither grading nor tunnel bores have any salvage value upon retirement." In this case respondent contends that the retired railroad grading may be used as a roadbed, constitutes an improvement to land regarding improved drainage patterns, and retains value in condemnation settings. The evidence presented in the record does not support respondent's contentions. ²² We have found that the majority of grading retirements is due to obsolescence rather than "wear and tear." Based upon the nominal evidence of residual value to railroad grading, we must find, as we did in Southern Pacific Transportation Co. v. Commissioner, supra at 802, "that, on balance, the grading * * * had only a nominal value upon cessation of use, and we conclude that petitioner is justified in its contention herein that the properties at issue would have no salvage value upon their retirement.1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*697 See Massey Motors v. United States, 364 U.S. at 92 (1960); sec. 1.167(a)-1(c), Income Tax Regs."

Respondent's "allowed or allowable" argument advances the position that any of petitioner's pre-1913 depreciation should not be utilized in the depreciable base and that the depreciation that was "allowed or allowable" for post-1913 years, prior to the first taxable year under consideration, should be reduced from the depreciable base. Respondent's rationale is that petitioner points out the paradoxical quality of respondent's position, because it presumes the allowability of depreciation with respect to grading, something which respondent has vigorously1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*698 argued against. Prior to a line of cases beginning in 1975 with 64 T.C. 352">Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Co. v. Commissioner, supra, there was no precedent for a deduction for the obsolescence of grading or tunnel bores. It was only after that opinion that various railroad companies began to claim these deductions. Prior to that time petitioner used the retirement-replacement-betterment (RRB) method of accounting. Under that method retirements from the grading account were at the cost of reproduction new, which would have the same overall effect as depreciation deductions. Furthermore, the retirements have occurred over a period of time to appropriately adjust for inflationary factors. Under these circumstances, we believe that prior depreciation was, in effect, removed from the balance of the grading account.

To the extent indicated herein we find this issue for petitioner. Petitioner is entitled to deductions attributable to the obsolescence of grading based upon a 135-year useful life with a 84.7-year average remaining life based upon an 1966 average life. Petitioner is entitled to deductions attributable to obsolescence of tunnel bores based upon a 135-year useful life1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*699 with a 75-year average remaining useful life, based upon a 1966 average useful life.

Relay Rail

The parties have stipulated for purposes of this case that L&N would be bound by the lesser of the salvage value for relay rail determined in the companion SCL case or the amount that had been allowed by respondent in his determination in this case. We sustained respondent's determination of $ 85 in the companion SCL case and the parties can take that into consideration in their Rule 155 computations.

In the companion SCL case we addressed the question of whether petitioner would be entitled to utilize the procedures of Rev. Proc. 68-46, 2 C.B. 961">1968-2 C.B. 961, in order to determine the proper allowance in lieu of depreciation and/or abandonment losses where relay rail was picked up in retirements. The companion case presented alternative computations in the notice of deficiency based upon use of Rev. Rul. 67-145, 1 C.B. 54">1967-1 C.B. 54, and Rev. Proc. 68-46, 2 C.B. 961">1968-2 C.B. 961. The L&N notice of deficiency does no appear to have alternative determinations, or is there any indication whether respondent utilized either the procedures of the revenue ruling or1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*700 revenue procedure. For the reasons expressed at pages 44 through 47 of our opinion in the SCL companion case, we hold that L&N would, to the extent appropriate, ²³ be entitled to utilize the procedures of the revenue procedure, including the 20-year adjustment approach to inclusion of the so-called "ending inventory."

Casualty Loss - Hurricane Betsy

This issue focuses upon petitioner's entitlement to a deduction for the cost of repairing and/or replacing the grading which was damaged as a result of Hurricane Betsy in 1965. Petitioner seeks to deduct the entire $ 700,775.12 expended, in connection with grading, as a maintenance or repair expenses under section 162. Respondent argues that petitioner would be limited to its adjusted basis of the grading lost as a result of the hurricane or casualty under section 165. The issue essentially requires us to make a determination of whether this is a deductible expense or a capital item. ²⁴ More specifically, petitioner contends that the replacement and repair of1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*701 the grading is a normal item of expense and that the magnitude of the damage and repairs or the suddenness of the event should not matter. Respondent contends that petitioner's loss here was a capital one and that petitioner's accounting method and position taken in litigation regarding the grading are incongruous and incorrect. We agree with respondent.

1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*702 Petitioner relies on R. R. Hensler, Inc. v. Commissioner,73 T.C. 168">73 T.C. 168 (1979), wherein we decided that certain repairs made to business assets caused by flooding were deductible under section 162 as ordinary and necessary business expenses. In that case we were confronted with the same statutory dichotomy between sections 162 and 165. Damage had been caused to machinery and equipment by the flow of mud and water. The cost of cleaning and repairing the machinery was our focus in 73 T.C. 168">R. R. Hensler, Inc., supra.To petitioner the difference is significant because petitioner would only be entitled to deduct its adjusted basis for the damaged grading and capitalize the larger capital expenditure if we determine that section 165 applies and the repairs were capital in nature. If, on the other hand, we determine that the repairs or replacement was an item of expense, the entire amount would be deductible in the taxable year and petitioner would not be required to amortize the cost over the useful life of the grading asset. We are confronted here with assets used in petitioner's business which were not totally lost or destroyed by a hurricane, but were1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*703 substantially damaged and physically moved from their proper situs. As we determined in 73 T.C. 168">R. R. Hensler, Inc., supra at 178-182, a deductible repair expense may occur where there is not a complete replacement of an asset. Here, however, the track structure and grading were modified or moved from the original location by the force of wind and water. Although petitioner was able to move the track structure and some of the recoverable grading material back to the original location, the grading and track were replaced after the initial relocation to the original situs. "While the amounts [involved] are large, we do not believe that factor is controlling (see Welch v. Helvering, [290 U.S. 111">290 U.S. 111 (1933)]; American Bemberg Corp. v. Commissioner, [10 T.C. 361">10 T.C. 361 (1948), affd. per curiam 177 F.2d 200">177 F.2d 200 (6th Cir. 1949)])." 73 T.C. 168">R. R. Hensler, Inc., supra at 182. The important factor here is that petitioner did not merely repair the track and grading; it essentially and substantially replaced them. Petitioner was subjected1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*704 to a "casualty" within the meaning of section 165 and sought insurance recovery and is entitled to deduct adjusted tax basis to the extent not compensated for by insurance or otherwise.

Dead Haul Issue

L&N rebuilds freight cars in its South Louisville, Kentucky, shops. In a prior opinion involving petitioner, we held that labor costs for vacation pay, holiday pay, payroll taxes, health and welfare benefits, applicable to the direct labor used in the rebuilding should all be capitalized. Louisville & Nashville Railroad Co. v. Commissioner,66 T.C. 962">66 T.C. 962, 66 T.C. 962">982-988, 66 T.C. 962">1010-1016 (1976). ²⁵ In that same case we also held that the costs of hauling materials used in capital programs (dead haul) should be capitalized at a rate of 6.06 percent of material costs. 66 T.C. 962">Louisville & Nashville Railroad Co., supra at 985-986. The 6.06-percent figure was derived from ICC studies and was used by petitioner.

Petitioner does not dispute that these "dead haul" costs should be capitalized in accord with our former opinion. Petitioner does1987 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 661">*705 not agree with the amount that should be capitalized. Respondent determined, in accord with the finding of our prior opinion, that the capitalization should be at the rate of 6.06 percent of material costs. Petitioner offered M. L. Jameson (Jameson), an employee of petitioner's successor, who has been involved with railroad costing and economic work for 16 years. Through this witness petitioner offered a computation which resulted in a $ 130-per-car "dead haul" cost. The $ 130-per-car figure represents about one-half of the 6.06 figure previously utilized. Jameson's computation was not shown to be any more accurate than the 6.06 amount petitioner had utilized, ICC had developed and this Court had previously approved.

We hold, as we did in the prior case that involved this petitioner, that "dead haul" costs should be capitalized at a cost of 6.06 percent.

To reflect the foregoing and concessions and agreements of the parties,

Decision will be entered under Rule 155.