Lomer v. . MeekerLomer v. . Meeker
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Smith
The point that the motion to dismiss the complaint could not be granted, because the plaintiff was entitled to judgment against the indorser, Bock, is not sustainable. The plaintiff was undoubtedly entitled to judgment against Bock, as it does not appear that he made any defence, and he clearly could make none upon his own testimony. He negotiated the note and represented it to be good, and would probably be estopped from asserting to the contrary, in an action against him thereon. (2 Denio, 621; 3 Kern., 314.) But the defendant‘s motion to dismiss the complaint, I do not think should be considered or construed as including Bock. It was made in behalf of the makers, Meeker and Maidhof, who alone defended. It was made upon the proof offered to make out a defence which was only available to them, and no reference made to Bock. The plaintiff could have severed, and had a separate judgment against him. Under the former practice, one defendant could not have judgment of nonsuit when a joint defendant had suffered default. But the modern rule is otherwise (Murphy v. Dolan et al., 5 Barn. Cres., 178; Jones v. Gibson, id., 768; Murphy v. Johnson, 7 Dowl. Ry., 619); I think the practice and rule is otherwise under
I think the judgment in this case should be reversed and a new trial granted, with costs to abide the event.
WRIGHT, SELDEN, GOULD and ALLEN, Js., concurring,
Judgment accordingly.