Lindman v. EllisLindman v. Ellis
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Blue, Campbell, Fulmer
BLUE, Judge.
Carol Lindman and John W. McMillin appeal an order finding them in contempt of court for their failure to allow Don E. Ellis, a court-appointed receiver, to cast votes at a condominium association meeting and imposing fines as sentences.1 Because the trial court failed to follow the requirements of Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.840 and the evidence was not sufficient to support convictions for indirect criminal contempt, we reverse.
First Florida Bank sued John W. McMillin in a foreclosure action involving twenty-eight condominium units. Carol Lindman, McMillin‘s stepdaughter and business associate, had no ownership interest in the twenty-eight condominium units and was not a party to the foreclosure action.2 Lindman was the secretary of the condominium association where the twenty-eight condominium units were located; McMillin was the association‘s president. On First Florida‘s request, the circuit court appointed a receiver for the condominium units during the pendency of the foreclosure action.
The day before the condominium association‘s annual meeting, the receiver obtained a circuit court order granting him the exclusive voting rights for the twenty-eight condominium units. The receiver did not personally attend the annual meeting but sent a representative accompanied by the receiver‘s attorney
When the receiver‘s representative presented the ballots, Lindman refused to accept them and count them in the election. The record contains unsupported allegations that Lindman rejected the ballots with the intention of affecting the election‘s outcome. The only direct evidence about why the ballots were rejected was from Lindman. She presented uncontradicted testimony that she refused the ballots because they were not presented in conformance with
As a result of the receiver‘s rejected ballots, affidavits were filed and the circuit judge entered a show cause order as to why Lindman and McMillin should not be held in contempt for “refusal to permit the receiver, Don E. Ellis, at the annual meeting to exercise the voting rights ...” Following an extensive evidentiary hearing, the circuit judge entered the February 23, 1994, order of contempt, finding that:
McMillin and Lindman‘s act was done with the knowledge that the Order existed and was done with the intent of interfering with that Order. The Court hereby finds them to be in contempt, for which the Court sentences them to pay a fine in the amount to Six Thousand Dollars ($6,000.00) each... .
In order to properly review the contempt order, we must determine the nature of the contempt for which Lindman and McMillin were found guilty and the proceedings leading to the order of contempt. See Pugliese v. Pugliese, 347 So.2d 422 (Fla. 1977). In civil contempt, the court may employ a fine as a sanction to coerce compliance or to compensate a party for actual damages. See Johnson v. Bednar, 573 So.2d 822, 824 (Fla. 1991). In criminal contempt, the court may impose a fine as punishment. Based on the sanctions imposed, we conclude that the order of contempt was for criminal contempt. Our conclusion is based on the court‘s order which specifically sentenced Lindman and McMillin to pay a fine of $6,000. The order recognized that no remedial action was available nor was there any requirement for future action. Clearly, the order did not seek to coerce. There was no indication that the fine was compensatory or related to any damages suffered by the receiver. Therefore, the fine imposed was intended as punishment.
An order of indirect criminal contempt requires strict adherence with
Even if the circuit judge had followed the requirements of
The evidence supports the trial court‘s finding that Lindman refused to allow the receiver to vote. However, the receiver, having the right to vote in the condominium election, failed to prepare and cast the ballots
Accordingly, we reverse the order of contempt.
CAMPBELL, A.C.J., and FULMER, J., concur.