64 W. Va. 147 | W. Va. | 1908
C. F. Ackerman and C. H. Voegele, trustees, the owners of a large tract of land called the Gallego Survey in the counties of Fayette, Raleigh and Kanawha, by contract dated June 4, 1902, made with the J. W. Mahan Lumber
On the 31st day of May, 1902, the said The J. W. Mahan Lumber Company entered into a contract, recorded January 11, 1904, with G. C. Lewis, of Eastbank, granting unto said Lewis “the sole and exclusive right to furnish all merchandise and supplies to employees and contractors of the said Lumber Company in all the operations of the said Company embraced in its contract with C. F. Ackerman and C. H. Yoegele, Trustees, in the matter of manufacturing lumber on the Gallego Survey on the waters of Paint Creek.”' The said Lumber Company to furnish such sites for stores at convenient places as might be designated by Lewis-in order that he might properly and in the most convenient, way furnish goods, supplies and merchandise to said employees and contractors.
On the 30th day of November, 1903, W. D. Hall and Robert Hall, partners as W. D. and Robert Hall, contracted with said The J. W. Mahan Lumber Company to cut, haul and deliver on the banks of main Paint Creek, the timber from certain portions of said tract of land. And on the 7th day of January, 1904, G. H. Young, Marion Young and L. W. Castle made a like contract with said Lumber Company for the cutting and removal of timber from another part of said lands for the said Lumber Company.
On the 14th day of April, 1904, G. C. Lewis filed his bill in equity in the circuit court of Fayette county against W. D. and Robert Hall and Young and Castle praying for an injunction against said parties, their agents and
The defendants appeared and tendered their demurrer' which was overruled. They then tendered their answer which was filed and moved to dissolve the temporary injunction awarded in the cause, to which motion plaintiff appeared and resisted the same and tendered certain affidavits, when the court overruled the motion to dissolve the injunction. The answer of the defendants denied that the said The J. W. Mahan Lumber Company had the exclusive right or privilege of conducting stores on said land, or had any license
Depositions were taken and filed in the cause and the cause was heard on the 3rd day of May, 1905, on the bill and exhibits therewith filed and upon exhibit “XX” being a copy of the contract mentioned in the said bill as made between Ackerman and Yoegele, trustees, by and with the consent of the Gallego Coal and Land Company with The J. W. Mahan Lumber Company, which it appears from the record was filed on that day in open court, and upon the answer of the defendants and exhibits therewith, and the depositions taken and filed for both parties, upon the motion of defendants to dissolve the injunction and of the plaintiff to perpetuate the same, and upon the decrees, orders and proceedings had, when the court, in consideration thereof, dissolved the injunction and dismissed plaintiffs bill and gave defendants judgment for costs. From which decree plaintiff appealed, and says the court erred in denying the prayer of his bill and dismissing the same with costs.
The contract between the plaintiff and the Lumber Company was a personal contract and, if the grantor therein violated the same in contracting with other parties, or otherwise, plaintiff had a remedy at law upon said contract as against the maker; and if the Lumber Company had the power to make the contract granting the sole and exclusive rights as claimed to the plaintiff and the defendants were trespassing upon his rights he had his right of action at law against them for the trespass, they being able to respond in damages as far as the record shows. The only allegation in the bill which would entitle plaintiff to an injunction in any event is the allegation of the insolvency of the defendants, which allegation is denied by the defendants and no proof
Affirmed,