Legare v. StateLegare v. State
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Hunt
This is the third appearance of this death penalty case on direct appeal. See Legare v. State, 250 Ga. 875 (302 SE2d 351) (1983); Legare v. State, 243 Ga. 744 (257 SE2d 247) (1979). The facts of the *303 case are essentially as set forth in Legare v. State, supra, 243 Ga. at 744-45.
Legare’s conviction and death sentence were affirmed on the first direct appeal. Subsequently, habeas relief was granted with respect to the death sentence, and a resentencing trial was conducted. On appeal, this court reversed on the ground that the jury had been instructed incorrectly.
After a second retrial as to sentence, Legare has again been sentenced to death. 1 The issue dispositive of this appeal concerns the conduct of the voir dire proceedings, specifically, the court’s refusal to allow defense voir dire on the issue of racial bias. We find the trial court’s refusal to have been erroneous, and we reverse.
1. In Turner v. Murray, 476 U. S__(106 SC 1683, 90 LE2d 27) (1986), the United States Supreme Court held that a defendant accused of an interracial capital crime is entitled to have prospective jurors informed of the victim’s race and to question them on the issue of possible racial bias. To what extent Turner v. Murray will apply retroactively is an open question. We need not answer it here.
“Appellant is also afforded certain rights under the statutes of this State. The right in criminal cases to examine each prospective juror in order to secure an impartial jury is set out in
“Although control of voir dire examination is normally within the discretion of the trial court, it has been held that the defendant in a criminal case has an absolute right to have his prospective jurors questioned as to those matters specified in
The trial court erred by refusing to allow defense voir dire on the question of possible racial bias. “We do not find that the state has shown that it is ‘highly probable’ that the limitation on voir dire was harmless error. [Cit.]” Henderson u. State, supra at 403. We must therefore reverse.
2. Regarding enumerations 16 and 17, see Division 4 of Legare v. State, 250 Ga. 875, supra.
3. The evidence is sufficient to allow a finding of the § b (7) aggravating circumstance.
4. The remaining enumerations of error depend upon a factual-procedural context that is mooted by our reversal. Similar issues that might arise if this case is retried as to sentence can be dealt with if and when they are raised on the retrial.
Sentence reversed.
All the Justices concur.
Notes
To the extent that
Cowan v. State,
supra, held that under
The jury returned its sentencing verdict December 1, 1984. Legare filed a motion for new trial December 28, 1984, and an amendment thereto on September 5, 1985. The motion was heard September 6, 1985, and denied December 31, 1985. The case was docketed in this court March 3, 1986, and orally argued May 20, 1986.