Lawson v. LawsonLawson v. Lawson
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Mulkey
delivered the opinion of the Court:
This was a suit in equity, brought in the circuit court of Cook county, by John Lawson, against his two sons, Louis and Peter, as heirs of Ann Lawson, their deceased mother, to recover certain real estate alleged to be held in trust by the defendants for the complainant. The court below, on the hearing, entered a decree dismissing the bill for want of equity, and the present appeal is from that decree.
The case made by the bill is, in substance, this : The record of the title to the property was destroyed by fire in 1873. After this fire and during that year, the complainant, being the undisputed owner in fee of the premises, conveyed the same in trust to Henry S. Dietrich, to have the record restored and
That the case made by the bill is one which, if true, appeals strongly to a court of equity, can not admit of a doubt. But like all others where the facts charged and out of which the equities arise, are not admitted, the complainant, to succeed, is bound to prove them in the manner prescribed by law. There is no feature about the ease in hand taking it out of this general rule. Before complainant can attack the conveyance made by Sisson to his wife, he must show that he has an equitable interest in it which a court of equity will recognize and enforce. It is admitted, or, rather, expressly charged, in •the bill, that complainant, in 1879, made a conveyance of the property to Dietrich. As that deed is not set out in the record, and no claim is made to the contrary, we must assume it was in
Under the j>leadings and proofs we think the decree was right, and it will therefore be .affirmed.
Decree affirmed.