Lawhorn v. StateLawhorn v. State
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Smith
(after stating the facts). It is insisted upon the part of the State that “It is not necessary to show a criminal intent, since the statute itself defines what shall constitute the crime,” and to support this position, we are cited to the opinion by Chief Justice Cockrill in the case of Beard v. State, 43 Ark. 284, where he said: “The statute (disposing of mortgaged property) upon which the indictment in the case is based, makes it a crime to dispose of personal property under the particular circumstances. When a party voluntarily does the act prohibited, he is charged with the criminal intent of doing it, and no further intent need be shown. ’ ’ Seelig v. State, 43 Ark. 96; U. S. v. Ulrici, 3 Dillon, 532; Com. v. Nash, 7 Met. (Mass.), 472.
There was a strong dissenting opinion in that case by Justice Eakin, in which he contended that a conviction could be had only where the proof showed the sale was made with the intent to deprive the mortgagee of his debt. But the opinion in that case was based upon section 1693 of Mansfield’s Digest, which has since been amended
The judgment in this case is therefore reversed and the cause remanded.