Lausen v. HertzLausen v. Hertz
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Kapsner
[¶ 1] Kary Jay Hertz appeals from an order denying his request for an evidentia-ry hearing on his motion for a change of custody of his minor child. We conclude Hertz was not entitled to an evidentiary hearing on his motion for change of custody, because the language in the original judgment authorized the custodial parent, Erin Kathleen Lausen, to remove the child from North Dakota. We affirm.
*58 I
[¶ 2] Hertz and Lausen have never been married, but have a child together. In 2001, in the context of Lauseris action against Hertz for custody of the child and for support, the district court awarded both parties joint legal custody of the child, designated Lausen as primary caretaker of the child, awarded Hertz visitation, and ordered Hertz to pay Lausen child support. In a memorandum opinion, the district court said Hertz would be responsible for transportation costs for visitation “unless [Lausen] relocates out of the State of North Dakota.” A proposed judgment prepared by Lauseris counsel authorized Lausen to remove the child from North Dakota. Hertz objected to that language, but an October 8, 2001, judgment was entered, which provided that Lausen “may remove the child from the state of North Dakota.” Hertz again objected to that language, citing
[¶ 3] In June 2005, Hertz moved for a change of custody, asserting Lausen intended to relocate with the child to Michigan. Hertz submitted an affidavit in support of his motion in which he said Lauseris out-of-state move would be devastating to his relationship with the child and would not be in the child’s best interests. The district court cited the language from the 2001 judgment authorizing Lausen to remove the child from North Dakota and decided Hertz had failed to establish a prima, facie case for change of custody under
II
[¶ 4] Hertz argues he established a prima facie case for an evidentiary hearing on his motion for change of custody under
[¶ 5] Under
[¶ 6] As relevant to Hertz’s motion for change of custody,
The court may modify a prior custody order after the two-year period following the date of entry of an order establishing custody if the court finds:
a. On the basis of facts that have arisen since the prior order or which were unknown to the court at the time of the prior order, a material change has occurred in the circumstances of the child or the parties; and
b. The modification is necessary to serve the best interest of the child.
[¶ 7] In
Lagro,
2005 ND 151, 703 N.W.2d 322, this Court, with four justices participating, recently considered the standard of review for the denial of an eviden-tiary hearing on a motion for a change of custody under
[¶ 8] Under
[¶ 9] Hertz nevertheless claims the language in the 2001 judgment authorizing Lausen to remove the child from North Dakota is not controlling, because
[¶ 10] Although res judicata has limited application in child custody cases, see
Wetch v. Wetch,
539 N.W.2d 309, 312 (N.D.1995), this Court has said an unappealed judgment may be res judicata as to an issue decided in the original judgment.
Schnell v. Schnell,
252 N.W.2d 14, 19 (N.D.1977) (unappealed original judgment included provision for child support after child reached majority and was attending college and that provision was res judicata). Here, there is a court order authorizing Lausen to relocate to another state under
[¶ 11] Under the plain language of
Ill
[¶ 12] We affirm the order.
[¶ 13] GERALD W. VANDE WALLE, C.J., MARY MUEHLEN MARING, and DANIEL J. CROTHERS, JJ., concur. I concur in the result. DALE V. SANDSTROM, J.