Lara v. SchneiderLara v. Schneider
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Kluczynski
Lead Opinion
Pursuant to our Rule 381 (58 Ill. 2d R. 381), Genaro Lara filed with this court on February 15
After considering the motion, proposed petition and supporting suggestions, the court requested responses thereto by the respondent municipal officers electoral board, and Denise A. Arens, the objector before the board to petitioner’s nominating papers.
The court has concluded that, in the circumstances of this case, mandamus is not an appropriate remedy. Unlike the petitioner who was precluded by the shortage of time from seeking trial court relief in Dooley v. McGillicudy (1976), 63 Ill. 2d 54, relied on by Lara, petitioner here had time to and did seek review of the electoral board action in the circuit court of Cook County, and a final and appealable judgment was entered by that court on February 13, 1979. Mandamus is, of course, not a permissible substitute for direct appeal. (People ex rel. Bradley v. McAuliffe (1962), 24 Ill. 2d 75, 78; People ex rel. Adamowski v. Dougherty (1960), 19 Ill. 2d 393, 400; People ex rel. Furlong v. Board of Election Commissioners (1949), 404 Ill. 326, 330; People ex rel. Barrett v. Shurtleff (1933), 353 Ill. 248, 259.) Equally summary action from this court was available to petitioner by filing a notice of appeal to the appellate court and simultaneously requesting us to transfer that appeal to this court pursuant to our Rule 302(b) (58 Ill. 2d R. 302(b)) and expedite its hearing and disposition.
The motion for leave to file an original mandamus action is accordingly denied.
Motion denied.
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting:
The order of this court denies Lara’s application for relief on the ground that mandamus is not a substitute for direct review and that, instead, Lara should have sought a direct appeal to this court under Rule 302(b) (58 Ill. 2d R. 302(b)). The court’s order violates the long-established rule that a denial of mandamus cannot alone be grounded on the availability of other relief (People ex rel. Starkweather v. Righeimer (1922), 306 Ill. 308, 312), and it fails to give proper weight to the numerous precedents which evidence the practice of this court to relax the technical restrictions of mandamus in matters such as this which are of great importance and which require expeditious resolution. In the process, the court purports to distinguish Dooley v. McGillicudy (1976), 63 Ill. 2d 54. I respectfully dissent.
A more complete recitation of the facts than that contained in the court’s order is essential to fully comprehend the issues raised. On December 26, 1978, Lara filed nominating petitions with the Chicago board of election commissioners. Lara was seeking to have his name placed on the ballot for the February 27, 1979, election for the office of alderman in Chicago’s 22d ward.
Also on December 26, 1978, Lara filed a statement of economic interests with the clerk of Cook County as required by the Illinois Governmental Ethics Act (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1977, ch. 127, par. 604A—101 et seq.). Two of the eight items of information requested were not provided.
On January 2, 1979, respondent Denise A. Arens filed objections to Lara’s nominating petitions. Three days later, on January 5, Lara filed a document entitled “Amended Statement of Economic Interests” in which he provided the two items of information which he failed to furnish in his original filing, and he also filed a statement of intention to defer filing of a statement of economic interests for 30 days. See Ill. Rev. Stat. 1977, ch. 127, par. 604A—105(c).
On January 29, Lara filed an action for review in the’ circuit court of Cook County. The court heard arguments and on February 13 affirmed the board’s decision on the ground that the statement of economic interests was insufficient. It did not address the issue of whether the nominating, petitions were defective. At this point, the election was two weeks away.
Two days later, on February 15, Lara filed the instant motion for leave to file a petition for writ of mandamus which this court now denies. In his motion and supporting documents, Lara asked us to rule that the respondent board lacked authority to review and determine the sufficiency of the statement of economic interests, and that the board erred in ruling that the nominating petitions were defective. Lara did not, as the court’s order states, merely seek “to compel respondent Judge Joseph Schneider *** to reverse the decision of the municpal officers electoral board.” He sought alternatively to
My disagreement with the court’s order in this case is, as stated at the outset of this dissent, two-fold. First, we cannot deny mandamus merely because other relief may be available. Second, Dooley v. McGillicudy (1976), 63 Ill. 2d 54, and other decisions of the court provide ample support for Lara’s request for determination of this case by way of petition for writ of mandamus. A more complete discussion of both points follows.
Although our mandamus act (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1977, ch. 87, par. 1 et seq.) is not directly applicable to original actions for mandamus commenced in the supreme court, our cases have held that supreme court mandamus practice should conform as nearly as possible to its provisions (People ex rel. Pignatelli v. Ward (1949), 404 Ill. 240, 243; People ex rel. Cunningham v. Thistlewood (1882), 103 Ill. 139, 141). We have thus held, citing section 9 of the act (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1977, ch. 87, par. 9) that original actions
The second basis of my disagreement with the court’s order lies in its treatment, or lack thereof, of Dooley v. McGillicudy (1976), 63 Ill. 2d 54, and the cases on which it is based.
In Dooley we awarded a writ of mandamus to petitioner, James A. Dooley, directing the county officers electoral board of Cook County “ ‘to expunge their order sustaining objections to the nominating papers of James A. Dooley for the office of judge of the Supreme Court; to enter an order denying said objections; and to transmit to the State Board of Elections a certified copy of its ruling in the manner provided by section 10—10 of the Election Code (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1973, ch. 46, par. 10—10.’ ” (Dooley v. McGillicudy (1976), 63 Ill. 2d 54, 55.) Petitioner Dooley had alleged insufficient time to seek review of the board’s decision in circuit court, and he argued that an original action for mandamus in our court would therefore lie. His reasoning was that the decision of the board was not rendered until January 13, 1976, that the election in
“This court has held that mandamus may be an appropriate remedy in situations which are of great import even though the normal criteria for an award of such relief are not evident. (People ex rel. Rice v. Cunningham, 61 Ill. 2d 353, 356.) We have recognized the existence of exceptions to the doctrine of exhaustion of remedies in analogous circumstances where strict application of the doctrine would lead to unjust or very harsh results. (Illinois Bell Telephone Co. v. Allphin, 60 Ill. 2d 350, 358.) This court has further said that ‘In cases involving the election process, where the time factor alone would usually render an appeal futile, this court has seen fit to grant original writs of mandamus. ’ (People ex rel. Meyer v. Kerner, 35 Ill. 2d 33, 37.) Under the circumstances of this case we conclude that the relief sought by plaintiff was appropriate.” (Dooley v. McGillicudy (1976), 63 Ill. 2d 54, 58.)
Because time was of the essence, the petitioner was not required to follow normal review procedures and could seek mandamus in this court rather than review in the circuit court.
The court now purports to distinguish Dooley and to interpret it as requiring that a litigant in Lara’s position move for direct appeal instead of seeking mandamus. This treatment of Dooley is indefensible.
Second, it is also particularly inappropriate to suggest that a motion under Rule 302(b) for direct appeal to this court is the required, or even preferred, procedure. A litigant who is under extreme and unusual time restraints could reasonably perceive a Rule 302(b) motion to be inadequate because of the uncertainties of the motion.
As in mandamus proceedings, we are said to exercise discretion in deciding whether Rule ‘302(b) motions will be granted. As a practical matter, however, there is a difference in the “discretion” involved in each type of case. Our cases reveal that mandamus is seldom denied where entitlement to relief is established. Where a meritorious claim is asserted, mandamus will not be denied (People ex rel. Blome v. Nudelman (1939), 371 Ill. 30, 32) unless perhaps, as suggested by a justice of the court in an early case, insubstantial interests are involved (People ex rel. Harless v. Hatch (1863), 33 Ill. 9, 47 (two dollars)).
The decision of the court, turning on a procedural technicality, prevented Lara from obtaining an expeditious and conclusive determination of the sufficiency of his efforts to place his name on the ballot. In so doing, the court ignores vital precedents, elevates form over substance,
MR. JUSTICE CLARK joins in this dissent.