L & R Distributing, Inc. v. Missouri Department of RevenueL & R Distributing, Inc. v. Missouri Department of Revenue
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Eager
This action involves the validity of Revised Rule No. 49 of the Revenue Department which, for the first time, construed
We have jurisdiction because the construction of a Revenue Law is required. The parties stipulated all the necessary facts, except those already admitted in the pleadings. They are, in substance, as follows: that the plaintiffs own and operate pinball machines and other coin-operated devices in St. Louis and St. Louis County, which are placed in “restaurants, confec-tionaries, bowling alleys, hotels, motels, bus stations, airports and other similar places * * * that they receive a percentage of the gross receipts; that in 1937 the Attorney General rendered an opinion which is incorporated into the stipulation as an exhibit; that the Revenue Department has issued Rules construing the statutes “and in so doing promulgated Rule No. 49 (issued in 1972 as a successor to prior rules dating back to 1934) which specifically exempted receipts derived from pinball and other slot machines (which provision, or similar provisions, was included in the said prior rules dating back to 1939)”; that copies of such Rules were attached as exhibits; that the Department did not attempt to collect a tax on such proceeds from 1937 to 1974, nor was such its practice, and that, on information, the same was true from 1933 to 1937; that effective May 1, 1974, Revised Rule No. 49 was promulgated under which defendants are attempting to collect sales taxes upon such proceeds for the use of such facilities; that on May 10, 1974, the Attorney General issued his opinion No. 68, a copy of which is incorporated into the stipulation; this upheld collection of the tax on fees paid for the use of facilities such as billiard tables, pool tables, bowling alleys “and the like”; that defendants have demanded such taxes since May 1, 1974, and plaintiffs and others have paid such taxes under protest — pursuant to § 144.700.
In the stipulation there are statements also concerning certain legislative bills which were introduced in 1939 and 1941. We prefer to discuss these in more detail later from our own examination of the legislative files. The parties stipulated that we may take judicial notice of the legislative history which, of course, we might do anyway.
The trial court filed its “Order, Judgment and Decree” granting to plaintiffs the relief prayed, and also filed an extended memorandum opinion. It declared the Revised Rule to be void insofar as it purported to tax the proceeds in question, adjudged that the statute does not impose such a tax, enjoined collection, and ordered a refund of the amounts collected. It would be somewhat superfluous to review the memorandum opinion, since it covers much of the same ground which we are required to cover here. It shows, however, a considered and studious review of the legal issues.
In 1939 legislation was introduced in the House which would have extended the Sales Tax to cover fees paid to participate in any amusement, entertainment, recreation, game or athletic event. A Committee Substitute for two of these bills (containing the extension) was adopted by the House, but was reported unfavorably by a Senate Committee and failed of adoption in the Senate. In 1941 a bill was introduced in the House which would have specifically imposed the Sales Tax upon proceeds from coin-operated devices, including pinball machines. That bill passed the House. The Senate amended the bill by striking out all that portion applying to coin-operated devices, including pinball machines (and certain other forms of amusement) and adopted the bill as amended; the House concurred in the bill as amended. Thus, the legislature has twice rejected amendments which would have extended the statute, once — to those who “participate” in amusements, games, etc., and once — to the proceeds of pinball and other coin-operated devices, specifically. There has been no change in the pertinent portion of the Act since 1937. The earlier Sales Tax Acts were effective for two years only, and consequently were completely re-enacted (with minor changes) on eleven occasions.
The trial court determined that the statute was ambiguous and that its administrative construction over a period of many years and the legislative construction (in rejecting the amendments in 1939 and 1941), might and should be controlling. Defendants insist here that the statute clearly and plainly imposes the tax; therein they argue in detail the supposed fallacies in the Attorney General’s opinion of 1937. We are not so much concerned with that opinion as we are with our own construction of the statute. Defendants also argue at considerable length that the addition of the words “or fees paid to, or in” in the 1937 Act (which they say the Attorney General ignored) must be construed as intending some extension of the Act over and above a mere charge for “admission and seating accommodations to any place of amusement,” and that the Act thus clearly taxes the proceeds in question. As a matter of fact, the 1933 Act included a tax on “charges and fees to
In any event, the use of the words “fees” and “or in” become of little importance when we consider the words immediately following. The statute, since 1937 and now, requires that the “amount” or “fees” be “paid to, or in any place of amusement, entertainment or recreation, games and athletic events”; two elements are essential, — that there be fees or charges and that they be paid in or to a place of amusement, etc. Defendants argue, somewhat casually, that the introduction of a coin-operated machine converts that place, any place it seems, into a “place of amusement or entertainment,” since it “provides entertainment.” We do not believe that the legislature intended any such broad and strained construction of a “place of amusement.” To us, the contrary seems much more reasonable, — that a hotel lobby, a restaurant, a motel, a bus station or an airport is not, within normal contemplation, a place of amusement or entertainment, and that it is not converted into such by the installation of a pinball machine. The machines are movable and frequently are moved. Thus, we are convinced that, since the fees must have been paid in a place of amusement, etc., the statute certainly does not clearly and plainly (as defendants say) impose the tax. While we are inclined to feel that the wording of the statute plainly excludes the tax, we shall give defendants the benefit of the doubt and consider the statute as though it were ambiguous, as did the trial court. As already indicated, we do not accept the argument that the 1937 opinion of the Attorney General created the ambiguity. By its very terms, as already indicated, the statute either expressly excluded the tax, or it was ambiguous; an Attorney General’s opinion does not change the status of a statute. If, perchance, the opinion had any effect on the administrative construction (which is not shown), we certainly cannot assume that it had any effect upon the later legislative action in twice rejecting affirmatively amendments to the Act which would have extended it as now sought. And defendants had the option at any time to demand the tax, and thus require a judicial construction, as they did 37 years later in 1974.
Defendants do not really suggest that the administrative and legislative constructions are not to be considered and given great weight in the construction of an ambiguous statute. To the effect that they are, see:
State ex rel. Harline v. Public Service Commission,
343 S.W.2d 177 (Mo.App.1960, administrative construction); Lemasters
v. Willman,
281 S.W.2d 580 (Mo.App.1955, administrative construction);
State ex inf. Anderson v. St. Louis County,
421 S.W.2d 249 (Mo. banc 1967, administrative construction);
State ex rel. Smithco Transport Co. v. Public Service Commission,
307 S.W.2d 361 (Mo.App.1957, administrative construction);
Foremost Dairies, Inc. v. Thomason,
384 S.W.2d 651 (Mo. banc 1964, administrative construction);
American Bridge Co. v. Smith,
352 Mo. 616, 179
Those interpretations, both administrative and legislative, strongly support the view that such a tax is not imposed, and thus more firmly convince us that the legislature did not intend to impose the tax on coin-operated machines. The ascertainment of that intent is our ultimate goal. And no one is better qualified to find and state that intent than the legislature itself. For at least 37 years the Revenue Department claimed no such tax and, in fact, promulgated Rules excluding the tax. In two separate sessions the legislature rejected amendments which would have imposed the tax; that action is much more decisive than mere non-action, and clearly shows the legislature’s view of its own intent. Our own view of the statute is that it does not tax the proceeds of coin-operated machines, and this view is so strongly reinforced that we have no hesitancy in ruling, as we now do, that the Act does not impose a sales tax on pinball or other coin-operated machines.
The judgment is affirmed.
PER CURIAM:The foregoing opinion by HENRY I. EAGER, Special Commissioner, is adopted as the opinion of the Court.
All of the Judges concur.
Notes
. Statutory references will be to RSMo 1969, V.A.M.S., unless otherwise stated.