Kunkalman v. GibsonKunkalman v. Gibson
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Gillett
Lead Opinion
This proceeding was instituted by appellants in the court below to establish a public drain. At the January term, 1904, the proceeding was docketed and drainage commissioners appointed. January 1, 1906, the commissioners filed their report, locating the work and making assessments of benefits, and at the same term appellees filed a plea to the jurisdiction, wherein they sought to show that the work as described in the petition and report would lower certain fresh-water lakes of an area greater than ten acres *506each. After unsuccessfully demurring to the plea, appellants interposed a motion in writing, in which they alleged the fact of the enactment of the statute of March 6, 1905 (Acts 1905, p. 456, §§ 5622-5635 Burns 1905), the holding of this court thereunder in Taylor v. Strayer (1906), 167 Ind. 23, and that a portion of said work as laid out and proposed to be constructed passed through certain lakes. The motion contained the following prayer: “Now, therefore, the petitioners respectfully ask the court to set aside said final report and remand the same, together with said work, back to the drainage commissioners heretofore appointed in said proceedings, with instructions to revise, reform and amend their said final report in the matters of the location and construction of main lines, arms and branches as to terminus, route, location and character of said work, regardless of the line as in said petition described, and to amend, revise and reform all assessments of benefits therein as may in their judgment be required and necessary to be made in the location, construction and prosecution of said work to a successful completion, and so as to conform and comply with said legislation of 1905, as hereinbefore referred to, and to file an amended report when they, the said drainage commissioners, have completed their said work. And that no part of said work shall be located or established so close to any lake covering ten acres or more of ground as to lower‘the water level of the lake, and at no point be nearer than forty rods of the high-water mark of said lake excepting only where drains empty into such lakes. All of which matters the court now remands and remits to the judgment and discretion of said drainage commissioners for their action in said proceedings.” This motion was overruled, and, after a trial of the matter set up in the plea to the jurisdiction there was a finding for appellees on said plea, and a judgment dismissing the proceeding followed.
*507
*511We find no error, and therefore the judgment of the court is affirmed.
Rehearing
On Petition for Rehearing.
Per Curiam.We have again considered the points originally made for a reversal, in addition to considering the petition and argument for a rehearing, and we continue of opinion that no available error exists. The petition is therefore overruled.