Kimmel v. PeopleKimmel v. People
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Craig
delivered the opinion of the Court:
This was an indictment against John Kimmel, for perjury, returned by the grand jury to the circuit court of Union county, where a trial was had and the defendant convicted. A motion for a new trial was entered, which the • court overruled, and sentenced the accused to imprisonment in the penitentiary for one year. To reverse the judgment the defendant has sued out this writ of error, and assigns various errors.
The first error relied upon is, that the indictment is insufficient. It appears that a complaint was made before the grand jury against Charles M. Willard, for the crime of embezzlement, and the defendant was sworn and testified as a witness.
It is alleged in the indictment, “ that upon said investigation it became and was a material question whether the said John Kimmel, o:q the 15th day of February, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and seventy-eight, had deposited in the bank of said Charles M. Willard, at Anna, Union county, Illinois, the sum of $525.71 in county orders, in the name of Fancy M. Kimmel; and thereupon the said John Kimmel, having then and there so sworn as aforesaid,
The first objection made to the indictment is, that facts are not averred showing that Charles M. Willard sustained any fiduciary relation to the defendant, and hence the testimony of the defendant before the grand jury, to the effect that he did not get back from the bank the same amount of county orders that he deposited, was immaterial, and would not amount to peijury.
We do not understand that the authorities required the pleader to set out minutely in the indictment the transaction between the defendant and Willard. In 2 Bussell, 639, it is said: “ It is necessary that it should appear on the face of the indictment that the oath taken was material to the question
In the indictment, while the facts and circumstances under which the defendant deposited money with Willard are not detailed, yet it is alleged that it became and was a material question, on the trial of the charge of embezzlement against Willard before the grand jury, whether defendant had deposited $525.71 with the said Willard. This we regard as sufficient, without a statement of the facts showing wherein the matter sworn to was material.
It is also contended, that the indictment is bad because it makes the precise sum sworn to have been deposited material. Under the facts as proven, had the indictment been drawn otherwise no conviction could have been sustained. The tes-’ timony of the defendant before the grand jury in substance was, that he had deposited with Willard a package containing $525.71 in county orders; and that while the package was in Willard’s custody it had been opened, and a certain amount of the county orders taken out, and retained when the package was returned. Whether this statement was true or false depended upon the amount the package contained when it was deposited, and hence the necessity of the averment as made in the indictment.
It is also said the indictment is defective, as it does not set out a full description of the county orders. We are aware of no authority that required a description of the county orders to be given in the indictment,—nor do we perceive any necessity for setting out the orders in the indictment.
It is also claimed that the court erred in modifying defendant’s ninth instruction, which, as asked, read as follows:
“ The court instructs you, for the defendant, that intention is the gist of the action; and that although you may be satisfied
The court added, “ provided any such mistake appears in the evidence.”
The only object of the modification was to confine the jury to the evidence; and as their deliberations would, of necessity, be controled by the evidence before them, we perceive no harm that could come to defendant from the modification.
The point has also been made, that the verdict was not sustained by the evidence. If the testimony of the witnesses called for the people is true,—and we perceive nothing in this record to lead to a different conclusion,—the verdict was fully sustained by the proof.
As no error appears, the judgment will be affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.