Kevin Michael Cay v. W.J. Estelle, Jr., Director, Texas Department of CorrectionsKevin Michael Cay v. W.J. Estelle, Jr., Director, Texas Department of Corrections
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Reavley
Plaintiff Kevin Michael Cay, an inmate at the Texas Department of Corrections (TDC), brought an action under
BACKGROUND
On October 7, 1982, Cay was granted leave to file a complaint
in forma pauperis
(IFP) pursuant to
a. Testimony for Plaintiff Cay testified that his work squad was assigned to work in the fields on the morning of August 3, 1982. As the squad was preparing to load into the transportation trailer, Cay stopped to remind Warden Gremen, who was standing nearby, of a conversation the two had had the day before. In this conversation, Cay had informed the Warden that he, Cay, had a long-standing back injury, and the Warden had agreed to investigate Cay’s records and reassign him to lighter work if necessary. While Cay was addressing the Warden, another inmate, James Smith, objected to riding on the trailer and jumped from it.
The Warden ordered Captain Hagan, who was standing nearby, to take Cay and Smith and lock them up. As they were proceeding to a back gate, Hagan began using abusive language. When Cay responded, somewhat in kind, Hagan struck him. A moment later, Hagan was joined by Lieutenant Allen and two inmates. The four beat Cay unconscious with blackjacks (used by the guards) and lead pipes (used by the inmates), inflicting him with various injuries including a black eye, bruises, a busted nose, and a busted mouth.
Afterwards, Cay was taken to the infirmary where he was treated with iodine and bandaids by an inmate. (The medical report stated that Cay was treated for cuts and scratches.) Cay was then placed in a solitary confinement cell along with several other inmates, without clothes, a mattress, blankets or sheets. Three days later, he was charged with refusing to work, striking an officer, using vulgar language and other charges. After a disciplinary hearing, 2 he was given fifteen days in solitary provided that he would forget about the incident. Cay then spent only seven days in solitary.
Two witnesses testified on behalf of Cay. The first, inmate James Morse, testified that he observed Captain Hagan, Lieutenant Allen and two inmates beat Cay. He also testified, however, that he only saw one of the inmates use a weapon (a blackjack) and that he did not see Cay unconscious. A second inmate, Horace Dewberry, confirmed Cay’s testimony that he and the other inmates in solitary had no clothes, mattresses or blankets. According to Dewberry, he could see into the cell once a day when he was taken to the showers. A third inmate was supposed to present testimony as to Cay’s physical impairment from the beating, but, through an apparent mixup, the wrong inmate was brought to the hearing.
b. Testimony for Defendants
Warden Durbin testified briefly as to the procedures used during hearings before the prison’s Disciplinary Committee. He stated that he did not know Cay and that he had never had a reason to harm Cay or to do anything to cause him harm. Durbin also testified that he was not present during the incident.
Captain Hagan’s testimony, after his memory was refreshed by a disciplinary report written after the incident, differed in almost every respect from Cay’s testimony. Hagan testified that Cay was on the trailer when he jumped off and announced to Hagan (not the Warden) that he (Cay) was not going to work. Cay refused two orders to return to the building and began to yell and curse. After refusing to obey a
c. The Magistrate’s Recommendation
Following the hearing, the magistrate filed a Memorandum and Recommendation. He stated that the hearing was held pursuant to
The magistrate’s Memorandum and Recommendation was sent to the parties. It notified both parties that a failure to file written objections to the proposed findings and recommendations contained in the report within ten days would bar them from attacking the factual findings on appeal. Cay received the report on December 24, 1983. On December 28, 1983, inmate John Pussey mailed a motion for extension of time to file objections on Cay’s behalf to the district court and the Attorney General’s office. (Pussey claimed to be providing Cay with “legal assistance.”) The motion was returned because it had not been signed by Cay. On December 30, 1983, Cay mailed a Motion for Amended and/or Additional Findings of Fact. Because of insufficient postage, the district court did not receive the motion until February 10, 1984. The motion was, however, received by the Attorney General’s office on January 3, 1984. The district court subsequently dismissed the action. Cay now appeals.
DISCUSSION
Cay contends primarily that it is improper to dismiss a civil rights action before trial when material, conflicting testimony is presented at an evidentiary hearing, requiring the magistrate to make an assessment of the credibility of the witnesses. If the dismissal was made under
I.
We must first consider the defendants’ argument that Cay’s appeal is foreclosed by Nettles v. Wainwright, 677 F.2d 404 (5th Cir.1982) (en banc). In Nettles, this court held that:
the failure of a party to file written objections to proposed findings and recommendations in a magistrate’s report [within ten days] . . . shall bar the party from attacking on appeal factual findings accepted or adopted by the district court except upon grounds of plain error or manifest injustice.
Id.
at 410.
See also Thomas v. Am,
— U.S. —, 106 S.Ct. 466, 88 L.Ed.2d 435 (1985). The defendants argue that the motion for extension of time submitted by inmate John Pussey on behalf of Cay, filed
Ordinarily, we would agree with the defendants. Cay is challenging the factual findings of the magistrate, not his legal conclusions,
cf. Nash v. Black,
781 F.2d 665, 667 (8th Cir.1986) (whether a complaint is legally frivolous is question of law, not fact), and
Nettles
made it clear that the ten-day rule would apply to pro se parties as well as parties represented by attorneys.
Nettles,
677 F.2d at 410. A district court, however, has the discretionary authority to allow a party to file objections after the ten-day period.
See
II.
In his brief, Cay asserts that his original complaint alleged that the defendants deprived him of his constitutional rights by beating him, failing to provide him with adequate medical care both immediately after the beating and later while he was in solitary confinement, placing him in solitary under inhumane conditions and denying him access to mail. On appeal, the defendants argue that the claims regarding solitary confinement and access to mail were never properly raised in the complaint because they were not specific enough and because they were made against unnamed “TDC officials” and “the officers that work in solitary.” (The evidentiary hearing also failed to identify the appropriate defendants.) We agree. While pro se complaints must be construed liberally, and the complainant given the opportunity to add specifics, allegations of misconduct must at least name a defendant or so specify the official’s position that his identification is easily ascertainable. Thus, the only claims properly before the district court were those relating to the alleged beating and the alleged denial of medical care immediately following the beating.
III.
Turning to the merits of Cay’s appeal, we must determine initially whether the dismissal of his action was made under
A.
A grant of leave to proceed
in forma pauperis
is made by considering only a petitioner’s economic status.
See
In the Fifth Circuit a district court may dismiss sua sponte an IFP proceeding as frivolous after filing but before service based on an examination of the complaint. While pro se pleadings must be construed liberally, Haines v. Kerner, 404 U.S. 519, 92 S.Ct. 594, 30 L.Ed.2d 652 (1972), close scrutiny of the complaint may be properly made at this stage to determine whether any defendants and claims should be dismissed as frivolous. 3 See Green v. McKas-kle, 788 F.2d 1116 (5th Cir.1986). It is not always easy, however, to determine whether a claim is frivolous simply by examining the complaint: prisoner complaints are notoriously difficult to decipher. If the frivolousness of a complaint is not facially apparent, it is “incumbent upon the court to develop the case and to sift the claims and known facts thoroughly until completely satisfied either of its merit or lack of same.” Jones v. Bales, 58 F.R.D. 453, 464 (N.D.Ga.1972), affd on basis of the district court’s reasoning, 480 F.2d 805 (5th Cir.1973).
To aid its development of the factual basis of a complaint, a district court may send a questionnaire to a prisoner before service requiring him to specify in greater detail the nature of his claims. Watson v. Ault, 525 F.2d 886, 893 (5th Cir.1976). The questionnaire is then made a part of the pleadings. Use of these questionnaires is standard practice in this circuit, and, even though pro se pleadings must be liberally construed, a significant number of complaints are usually dismissed before service upon examination of the complaint and the questionnaire.
As this court made clear in
Spears v. McCotter,
766 F.2d 179 (5th Cir.1985), the district court’s
sua sponte
authority to dismiss under
B.
While a district court may dismiss an IFP proceeding whenever it determines that the complaint is frivolous, before or after service, Cay argues that the dismissal in this case was made not under
IV.
The magistrate explicitly acknowledged that there was conflicting testimony presented at the hearing and that he made his findings of fact regarding the beating after determining the credibility of the witnesses. Cay argues that this action changed the hearing into a trial on the merits and that he had not agreed to trial before a magistrate. He also argues that making determinations of credibility at this stage are inappropriate to resolve conflicts in oral testimony. Although we have determined that the dismissal in this case was made under
A.
In
Green v. McKaskle,
788 F.2d 1116, 1120 (5th Cir.1986), we emphasized “the uniqueness of a
The court’s explanation in
Jones v. Bales
of the special considerations involved in
There are compelling reasons for allowing courts broader dismissal powers in forma pauperis suits — especially damage suits brought by convicted prisoners — than in other cases. Persons proceeding in forma pauperis are immune from imposition of costs if they are unsuccessful; and because of their poverty, they are practically immune from later tort actions for “malicious prosecution” or abuse of process. Thus indigents, unlike other litigants, approach the courts in a context where they have nothing to lose and everything to gain. The temptation to file complaints that contain facts which cannot be proved is obviously stronger in such a situation. For convicted prisoners with much idle time and free paper, ink, law books, and mailing privileges the temptation is especially strong. As Justice Rehnquist has noted, “Though [an inmate] may be denied legal relief, he will nonetheless have obtained a short sabbatical in the nearest federal courthouse.” Cruz v. Beto, 405 U.S. 319, 327, 92 S.Ct. 1079, 1084, 31 L.Ed.2d 263 (1972) (dissenting).
The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure are inadequate to protect the courts and defendants — who it should be remembered pay for their defense — from frivolous litigation from indigent prisoners. The Rules are liberal; they are designed so that most cases will actually go to trial if the parties so desire. Under current standards,Rule 12 motions to dismiss are rarely properly granted. The liberal approach of the Rules is probably desirable, but the rules contemplate litigants who are limited by the realities of time and expense. They also contemplate litigants with a basic respect for accuracy. As Judge Duniway has written, “[w]e know from sad experience with habeas corpus and 2255 cases that imprisoned felons . . . do not hesitate to allege whatever they think is required in order to get themselves even the temporary relief of a proceeding in court.” Weller v. Dickson, 314 F.2d 598, 602 (9th Cir.1963) (concurring opinion). A reasonably intelligent prisoner with a willingness to misrepresent facts can often avoid both 12b dismissal and summary judgment, although he actually has no chance of eventual success in his suit. Even if summary judgment can be won by a defendant, much expense may already have been suffered by him in retaining counsel to conduct the defense.
Jones, 58 F.R.D. at 463-64 (citations, footnotes omitted). v
Due to such considerations, this circuit has vested district courts with especially broad discretion in making the determination of whether an IFP proceeding is frivolous.
See, e.g., Holloway v. Gunnell,
685 F.2d 150 (5th Cir.1982);
Watson V. Ault,
525 F.2d at 891-92;
Jones v. Bales,
58 F.R.D. at 464. Most other circuits have done likewise.
See, e.g., Anderson v. Coughlin,
700 F.2d 37 (2d Cir.1983);
Collins v. Cundy,
603 F.2d 825 (10th Cir.1979);
Milton v. Nelson,
527 F.2d 1158 (9th Cir. 1976);
Daye v. Bounds,
509 F.2d 66 (4th Cir.),
cert. denied,
421 U.S. 1002, 95 S.Ct. 2404, 44 L.Ed.2d 671 (1975);
Hendricks v. Havener,
587 F.2d 21 (8th Cir.1978);
cf. Boyce v. Alizaduh,
595 F.2d 948, 951 (4th Cir.1979) (“however broad the discretion may be, it may not be exercised arbitrarily and is limited in a
pro se
case . . . by the rule in
Haines v. Kemer . . .
and in every case by the language of [
Courts have had difficulty in defining frivolous as it is used in
We have addressed the appropriateness of credibility findings under the above standards in two previous cases. In Jones v. Bales, 58 F.R.D. 453, we approved action by a district court dismissing an IFP proceeding because the “plaintiff’s allegations simply strain credulity.” Id. at 465. The district court, relying entirely on the plaintiff’s complaint concluded that it would be “almost impossible” for the plaintiff to prove facts necessary to establish his claim. Id. The court considered as relevant to its credibility assessment the plaintiff’s lack of success in substantiating previous claims. In Taylor v. Gibson, 529 F.2d 709 (5th Cir.1976), we considered a magistrate’s report which recommended dismissal of a prisoner’s complaint because the allegations were “completely beyond belief.” Id. at 716. Unlike Jones, the Taylor court had before it supporting affidavits from all parties which substantially conflicted. We reversed the dismissal because the prisoner “was deprived of a hearing at which to present evidence in support of his allegations” and because “[t]he lower court made credibility choices without hearing witnesses testify, without observing their demeanor or hearing their testimony subjected to cross-examination.” Id.
While Jones and Taylor, read superficially, appear to reach conflicting results, close analysis reveals that they are in fact consistent. In Jones, the court considered the inherent improbability of the general facts alleged by the prisoner, together with his lack of previous success in substantiating other claims, to determine that his allegations were not credible. Other courts have allowed an assessment of the credibility of a prisoner’s allegations in similar circumstances. See Taylor, 529 F.2d at 717 (complaint which misstates facts that a district court may judicially notice may be dismissed); Crisafi v. Holland, 655 F.2d 1305, 1307-08 (D.C.Cir.1981) (complaint which postulates facts of a “wholly fanciful kind” may be dismissed). Determining that it would be almost impossible for a plaintiff to prove certain facts requires a different kind of credibility assessment than the assessments made in Taylor. In Taylor, the prisoner had presented a plausible story. The magistrate, with only affidavits before him, chose to believe the prison officials over the prisoner, apparently on the basis of the prisoner’s prior criminal record. As the Taylor court stated, “[fjactual disputes are not so resolved under our system of jurisprudence,” Taylor, 529 F.2d at 716. Clearly, Taylor does not disallow credibility findings; rather, Taylor simply requires that a hearing be held before a court can make credibility determinations involving more than the inherent plausibility of a prisoner’s allegations. Spears, of course, provides for such a hearing.
We conclude from the preceding discussion that credibility assessments are within the sound discretion of a district court making a determination of frivolousness. That discretion is limited, however, by the purpose of a
B.
In reviewing a magistrate’s full credibility assessments, the district judge must consider the verbatim record of the evidentiary hearing.
Hernandez v. Estelle,
711 F.2d 619 (5th Cir.1983). This “fresh consideration” of the magistrate’s findings may be undertaken by listening to a tape recording or reading a transcript of the hearing.
Nettles v. Wainwright,
677 F.2d 404, 409 n. 5 (5th Cir.1982). When the magistrate recommends that claims or cases be dismissed as frivolous after conducting an evidentiary hearing, however, he may be able to dispense with the necessity of the verbatim review by the district judge if the pertinent evidence is summarized and the conflicts and inconsistencies that demonstrate fabrication and lack of merit are set forth in the magistrate’s report. It would be preferable in that case for the district court to state the reasons for the
C.
Applying these rules, we find that the district court abused its discretion in this case. The magistrate stated that he “assessed the credibility and demeanor of the witnesses and the inherent probabilities of inconsistencies in the testimony received.” The district court adopted the magistrate’s report apparently without a transcript or tape recording of the hearing before him, and the magistrate did not summarize any conflicts or inconsistencies that might demonstrate fabrication. The transcript reveals, however, that Cay’s testimony regarding the alleged beating was consistent with the facts alleged in his complaint. It was substantially corroborated by a fellow prisoner. The testimony of both prisoners was inherently consistent, and, while their testimony differed with regard to details, such as the use of weapons and the extent of Cay’s injuries, they agreed on the essentials — that Cay was severely beaten by two prison guards and two inmates. Cay’s version of the entire incident was not implausible in any way. Any assessment of credibility based on factors other than these, such as demeanor, was inappropriate at this stage of the litigation. The parties clearly differed in their versions of the facts, and it was only for the ultimate trier of fact to determine who was more believable.
V.
The district court adopted the magistrate’s recommendation that Cay’s claim that he was denied adequate medical treatment immediately after the beating be dismissed. Cay does not contest the dismissal of this claim, and we affirm. Prison officials are liable under the Eighth Amendment for failure to provide medical treatment only when they are deliberately indifferent to a prisoner’s serious medical needs.
Estelle v. Gamble,
429 U.S. 97, 106, 97 S.Ct. 285, 292, 50 L.Ed.2d 251, 261
CONCLUSION
Since we affirm the dismissal of Cay’s claim of inadequate medical treatment, we remand only for a determination of the merits of his claim of excessive force.
AFFIRMED IN PART and REVERSED IN PART and REMANDED.
Notes
. Prior to the hearing, Cay filed a first amended complaint in which additional constitutional deprivations were alleged. No action was taken on his request to amend. The parties assumed . at the evidentiary hearing that these additional claims were being treated as a separate action. We assume likewise. Cay also filed a motion seeking to subpoena various witnesses to testify at the evidentiary hearing. The magistrate limited Cay to three witnesses at the hearing.
. Cay complained at the hearing that Captain Hagan, who brought the disciplinary charge, sat on the Disciplinary Committee. This fact was disputed. Apparently, it was not disputed that Lieutenant Allen, who was also involved in the beating, did sit on the committee.
. It is important at this stage that the district courts review each of a prisoner’s allegations to determine whether they adequately state a claim against each defendant. Prisoner complaints often make allegations against numerous defendants which should not survive scrutiny under recent Supreme Court decisions, which require a prisoner making allegations under the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments to allege facts sufficient to establish that prison officials were deliberately indifferent to his rights. See, e.g., Daniels v. Williams, — U.S. —, 106 S.Ct. 662, 88 L.Ed.2d 662 (1986) (Fourteenth Amendment); Davidson v. Cannon, — U.S. —, 106 S.Ct. 668, 88 L.Ed.2d 677 (1986) (same); Whitley v. Albers, — U.S. —, 106 S.Ct. 1078, 89 L.Ed.2d 251 (1986) (Eighth amendment).
. Also useful in this regard is a procedure developed by the Tenth Circuit. In
Martinez v. Aaron,
570 F.2d 317 (10th Cir.1978), the court approved a district court’s order that prison officials investigate the facts surrounding a civil rights suit by inmates to construct “an administrative record . . . to enable the trial court to . . . make a determination [of frivolity] under
. With a judicial officer and witnesses on hand, the parties could, of course, agree to proceed to trial on the merits. The magistrate or judge could then choose to withhold a final
. See Jones v. Morris, 777 F.2d 1277 (7th Cir. 1985) (dismissal appropriate if there is no rational argument in law or fact to support the claim for relief); Martinez v. Aaron, 570 F.2d 317 (10th Cir.1978) (same); Rizzo v. Dawson, 778 F.2d 527 (9th Cir.1985) (dismissal appropriate if the claim has no arguable basis in law or fact); Sills v. Bureau of Prisons, 761 F.2d 792 (D.C.Cir.1985) (same); United States ex rel. Walker v. Fayette Cty, 599 F.2d 573 (3rd Cir. 1979) (same); Brooks v. Seiter, 779 F.2d 1177 (6th Cir.1985) (dismissal appropriate only if it appears beyond doubt that plaintiff can prove no set of facts which would entitle him to relief); Neary v. Dugger, 766 F.2d 456 (11th Cir. 1985) (same); Green v. Black, 755 F.2d 687 (8th Cir.1985) (same); Anderson v. Coughlin, 700 F.2d 37 (2nd Cir.1983) (dismissal appropriate if there is little chance of success on the merits in light of various defenses which may be asserted); Urbano v. Sondem, 370 F.2d 13 (2d Cir. 1966) (dismissal appropriate if it seems highly unlikely that plaintiff could prove his claim or surmount defendant’s defense).