Kelly v. SheehanKelly v. Sheehan
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Alcorn
In the trial of an action brought on behalf of the named plaintiff, a minor, seeking to recover damages for personal injuries, in which the minor’s father joined seeking recovery for attendant medical expenses, the jury returned a verdict for the defendant. The court denied the plaintiffs’ motion to set aside the verdict, and the plaintiffs have appealed from the judgment rendered on the verdict. Error is assigned in the finding, in numerous rulings on evidence, in the charge to the jury, and in the denial of the plaintiffs’ motion to set aside the verdict. We consider a ruling on evidence decisive of the case.
There is no dispute that, at some time between 1 a.m. and 1:20 a.m. on the morning of May 12,1963, the motor vehicle in which the minor plaintiff was riding collided with a guidepost at the edge of an entrance ramp to route 9, a public highway, in Middletown. The only occupants of the car were the minor plaintiff, sixteen years old, and the defendant, a minor fifteen years old. There were no witnesses to the collision. When persons later arrived at the scene, the minor plaintiff was found lying between the two front bucket seats of the car unconscious, paralyzed below the neck, and unable to move his body. He was removed by ambulance to the Middlesex Memorial Hospital.
The plaintiffs claimed that the defendant was the driver of the car. The defendant claimed that the minor plaintiff was the driver. The identity of the driver was the vital and bitterly contested issue between the parties at the trial.
During the course of the trial, the plaintiffs’ counsel offered in evidence the record of the Middlesex Memorial Hospital relating to the minor plaintiff on his admission there following the accident. The
Counsel for the defendant opposed the offer as made, claiming that the entire record was admissible, on the premise that no one but the minor plaintiff could have given the information as to the identity of the driver and that, consequently, the entire record was admissible not only by virtue of Gfeneral Statutes § 52-180, the business entry statute, but also as a recordation of an admission by the minor plaintiff.
It had been the plaintiffs’ claim that the minor plaintiff suffered from retrograde amnesia as a result of the accident and remembered nothing of
As the result of the ruling, the hospital record containing the statement that the minor plaintiff “was driving car when his car hit an iron grid” was laid before the jury and became a potent piece of evidence on the most vital issue in the case.
Since the enactment, in 1931 (see Cum. Sup. 1935 § 1675c.), of the predecessor of
The mere fact that a record is generally admissible under
Since the statement which was admitted as part of the report had direct and vital bearing on a decisive issue in the case, its admission in evidence was clearly harmful error. In view of this conclusion, it is unnecessary to discuss any of the other assignments of error.
There is error, the judgment is set aside and a new trial is ordered.
In this opinion the other judges concurred.