Kellogg v. PeddicordKellogg v. Peddicord
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Boggs
delivered the opinion of the court:
The circuit court of LaSalle county entered a decree vacating and canceling a deed executed by one Edward S. Peddicord, now deceased, to the appellant, which purported to convey to the latter a farm containing one hundred and sixty acres of land in section 25, township 34, north, range 4, east, in said LaSalle county. The record of that proceeding in said court is before us on appeal. The bill was filed by the appellees, who are the children, grandchildren and legatees of the said deceased grantor, and alleged two grounds’ of attack upon the sufficiency of the deed, viz.: First, “that said Peddicord, the grantor, at the time of the execution of said deed was not of sound mind and memory, but was in his dotage, and his mind and memory were so impaired as to render him wholly incapable of comprehending the nature and consequence of the transaction in which he was engaged;” and second, that at the time of the execution of the deed said grantor was greatly enfeebled in body and impaired in mind, and was an inmate of a sanitarium of which the appellant was superintendent and also the physician and medical adviser of the grantor, and that the appellant-took advantage of the influence so alleged to be possessed over the said grantor, and by undue influence procured the execution of the deed without any consideration therefor.
Upon the hearing appellees produced a number of witnesses in support of the allegation the said grantor was lacking in mental capacity to execute the deed, but did not seek to support the charge that the deed bad beeu procured by the exercise of undue influence on the part of any one over the said grantor. The testimony thus produced by appellees, while it tended to show the grantor was not exempt from the ills and afflictions of a physical character which ordinarily affect men of his age, had little, if any, tendency to establish that his mental faculties were impaired, and, so far as it had such tendency, it was met and clearly overcome by that of witnesses produced in behalf
Excluding from consideration all statements in the deposition of the appellant relating to conversations or circumstances which occurred prior to the death of the grantor, the facts disclosed in this case are, that the appellant was the superintendent of a sanitarium at Battle Creek, Michigan, and had occupied that position for about twenty years; that the sanitarium is one of the largest of the institutions of its kind, capable of furnishing accommodation for one thousand patients, and has constantly and regularly connected with it from seven to ten attending physicians; that the appellant, as superintendent, although a physician, did not attend upon the patients personally, nor did
The only testimony disclosing the conversation which occurred between them is that of the appellant, which, on motion of the appellees, was excluded from consideration. “It appeared, however, that as the result of the interview Mr. Hulbert, a member of the bar of the State of Michigan, a resident of Battle Creek, and who was the legal adviser
The facts and circumstances which attended the execution of the conveyance here involved, thus fully dis‘closed by
The decree appealed from must be and is reversed and the cause remanded, with directions to the chancellor to enter a decree finding the conveyance to be valid and effectual to vest the appellant with the title to the premises
Beversed and remanded.