Kelley v. KelleyKelley v. Kelley
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Thompson
delivered the opinion of the court:
Appellant, Rosine Holmes Kelley, filed her bill in the superior court of Cook county asking that the marriage between her and Clark Mansur Kelley, appellee, be dissolved and that she be awarded the care and custody of their child, Barbara Anne Kelley, eight months old. Appellee could not be found in the State and service was had by publication. May 16, 1922, a decree of divorce a vinculo matrimonii was granted and the care and custody of the child was awarded to appellant. Thereafter appellee returned to Cook county, and December 4, 1922, appellant filed a petition in the same cause alleging that she filed her bill charging appellee with extreme and repeated cruelty and praying for divorce and for alimony and solicitor’s’ fees,, and that a default decree was subsequently entered. She further alleged that appellee was then within the jurisdiction of the superior court of Cook county, and asked that he be summoned to show cause why he should not pay to appellant money for her maintenance and for the support of their child and for solicitor’s fees. Appellee was duly summoned to appear at the next term of court, and January 3, 1923, he filed an answer, admitting that a final decree of divorce was entered May 16, 1922, and alleging that the court was without jurisdiction, at the time the decree was entered, to enter an order requiring him to pay alimony or solicitor’s fees. The answer denies that the court has jurisdiction to enter a further order in the cause and asks that the petition be dismissed. There was a hearing on the petition and an order entered finding that the court had jurisdiction to consider the petition, and that appellee is an able-bodied man, is regularly employed, is earning $25 a week, is residing with his parents, is able to support appellant and their child, and that appellant has no means, or property of her own. Appellee was ordered to pay to appellant the sum of $12.50 a week as alimony for her and their child
The questions presented by this appeal are novel and a decision of them is bound to be far-reaching. Notwithstanding this, we have been compelled to make an independent search of the authorities and have not been aided by properly prepared briefs of counsel. Appellant has filed a brief citing an early case decided by this court where the only question involved was the modification of a decree in personam entered at a former term of court. The brief has not furnished us with any of the authorities from other jurisdictions which deal with the questions before us. Appellee has filed no brief at all. Rule 15 provides that each party shall file a printed brief in the cause. The brief of appellant should contain the points relied upon for a reversal and these points should be supported by authorities. If the question has been decided by this court it is not necessary to cite authorities from other jurisdictions, but if the question has not been decided by this court it is the duty of counsel for appellant to support his contentions by an authority from each jurisdiction that has decided it. Counsel for appellee took this case to the Appellate Court, and it was his duty to follow the case to this court and present the authorities relied upon to sustain his position. If the questions involved in a case are of sufficient importance to justify asking this court to decide them, they are worthy of the careful consideration of counsel presenting them. If the case is not properly presented and the court is not given the benefit of precedents there is danger of a decision being rendered that will not be in harmony with the weight of authority. It is the duty of attorneys practicing in this court to present to the court the authorities supporting their views and to assist the court in reaching a correct conclusion.
In the case at bar appellant took her decree of divorce without personal service on appellee, and under those circumstances the chancellor was without power to award alimony.- This was a voluntary act on her part, and by causing to be
The judgment of the Appellate Court and the order of the superior court are reversed and the cause is remanded to the superior court for further proceedings in harmony with the views herein expressed.
Reversed and remanded.