16 How. Pr. 377 | The Superior Court of New York City | 1858
In so far as this action proceeds on tiie idea of a breach by John La Farge, of his implied covenant of quiet enjoyment by the plaintiff, (3 Kernan, 151,) it sounds in contract and continues. In so far as it is based on the allegation of a wrong done by John La Farge, to the rights of the plaintiff as his lessee, it continues by force of section 1 of 2 Revised Statutes, 447.
The only other question is, whether the representatives of the deceased defendant may move for and obtain an order continuing the action, or whether the option is given to the plaintiff alone to move or to omit to move, for such an order ? The only authority for such a motion, is that furnished by section 121 of the Code. By that, after the lapse of a year from the death of a party, the court cannot allow the action to be continued except upon “ a supplemental complaint,” such a proceeding cannot be taken by a defendant.
Prior to the Code, the death of a sole plaintiff or of a sole defendant, before verdict or interlocutory judgment, abated an action at law, and it could not be continued by or against the representatives of the deceased. (2 R. S. 386 to 389.) The chancellor decided in White agt. Buloid, (2 Paige, 475,) that the personal representatives of a sole complainant who had died might, on their own motion, be substituted as complainants under section 115, 2 Revised Statutes, 184. The language of this section is as general as that part of section 121 of the Code, which applies to motions made within a year after the death of a party, with the exception that section 115 applies only to the case, “ when a complainant shall die.” But I find ho provision in the Revised Statutes, broad enough to enable the representatives of a deceased sole defendant to make such a motion. Section 126, [120,] evidently applies to the case of the death of one of two or more defendants, and not to the death of a sole defendant.
If only the representatives of such a deceased party can make
Motion denied without costs; but an order may be entered that the action be discontinued, unless the plaintiff serve within ten days after written notice of the order to be entered hereon a consent that an order be entered continuing the action.