Kaiser Aluminum Warrick, LLC v. US Magnesium LLC
1:22-cv-03105
S.D.N.Y.Jun 6, 2025Check TreatmentDocket
sa . mwe.com
% Andrew B. Kratenstein
oF Attorney at Law
OO 8 Akratenstein@mwe.com
O bh. 2. [be Laila ace ba
June 5, 2025 c | bap ee be lof ~ □□
VIA ECF (ba nef WO 3, Vere 2ek □□
bseuf tne f cia rrsrey Vere, Corre □□□□
The Honorable John G. Koeitl tot Vy □□
United States District Court Southern District of New York “L2ciz#4* rst □□
Daniel Patrick Moynihan United States Courthouse fom igo. Fuse □□□ □□□
500 Pearl Street, Room 14A Wkingebor, i ete □
New York, New York 10007-1312 hedouw Be bbtertepun~ wie be
Re: Kaiser Aluminum Warrick, LLC v. US Magnesium’ LIC, Case No. iien □□
'
Dear Judge Koeitl: Ket ie xt
We represent Plaintiff Kaiser Aluminum Warrick, LLC (“Kaiser”) in the abové-réferenced action. □□
We write pursuant to this Court’s standing order 19-mc-00583 and Individual Practice Rule VI to identify Gly
the exhibits that Kaiser requests to be filed under seal in connection with Plaintiff's Motion Jn Limine to
Preclude Evidence Related to its Operations and Force Majeure Declaration (the “Motion”), including
certain exhibits attached to the Declaration of Andrew B. Kratenstein, dated June 5, 2025 (the
“Kratenstein Declaration”). Kaiser has identified each document to be filed under seal on Exhibit A of
this letter motion, along with the bases for such designations.
Kaiser respectfully submits that good cause exists to seal these documents. Each of the exhibits
identified for sealing was designated either “Confidential” or “Attorneys’ Eyes Only” pursuant to the
Protective Order (ECF No. 24), and consist of “commercially sensitive and confidential business
information” and “confidential terms of competitively sensitive contracts”. fuboTV Inc. v. Walt Disney
Co., No. 1:24-CV-01363-MMG, 2025 WL 19322, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 2, 2025). This Court previously
granted the parties’ applications to seal similar information in connection with Kaiser’s earlier summary
judgment filings. (ECF Nos. 158-59 and 177.)
Confidential documents pertaining to sensitive business operations that, if made public, would
commercially or competitively disadvantage the disclosing party, are among those this Court has
consistently recognized as justifying protection from the public view when used in litigation. See Matter
of Upper Brook Companies, No. 22-MC-97 (PKC), 2023 WL 172003, at *6 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 12, 2023) (“A presumption of access may be outweighed by a party’s interest in ‘protecting confidential business information’ from disclosure that would subject it to ‘financial harm’ or a ‘significant competitive advantage.’”) (quoting Standard Inv. Chartered, Inc. v. Fin. Indus. Regul. Auth., Ind.,347 F. App’x 615
, 617 (2d Cir. 2009)); see also Standard v. Fin. Indus. Regulatory Auth., Ind.,347 F. App’x 615
, 617 McDermott One Vanderbilt Avenue New York NY 16017-3852 Tel +4212 547 5400 Fax +1212 547 5444 . US practice conducted through McDermott Will & Emery LLP. Will & Emery June 5, 2025 Page 2 (2d Cir. 2009) (affirming district court’s sealing on grounds that the party’s “interest in protecting confidential business information outweighs the qualified First Amendment presumption of public access”); WJ. Deutsch & Sons Ltd. v. Diego Zamora, S.A., No. 1:21-CV-1 1003-LTS,2022 WL 890184
,
at *3 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 25, 2022) (granting a sealing request where “disclosure of this confidential business
information would subject [movant] to a competitive disadvantage”).
In short, Kaiser’s proposed sealing is narrowly tailored to protect Kaiser’s non-public operational
information and contractual terms that, if made public, could cause severe harm to Kaiser. Accordingly,
Kaiser respectfully requests that the Court permit Kaiser to file the exhibits to the Kratenstein Declaration
(listed In Exhibit A hereto) under seal.
We thank the Court for its time and consideration.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Andrew B, Kratenstein
Andrew B. Kratenstein
cc: Counsel of Record (via ECF)
q
6 1s ‘B
a 3 a
S 3 a E
g 2 = □ E So
Baad on Oo 3 oS ec ed
8 3 2 |E 6 = |. =
2 3 E =2 |e
|. a, oS 5 ge Oo &
ld se & 5 @ | 218 |g
Eas oS 3 < |s a4 18 3
real 3 qo □□ a < 3 o's a oe o
peedsct Es Ss wed ci oO 3 36
eal a, |= a 5 6 TS Ba 45 & |8
[2 82 3 5 3 5 |8 e |e |6
go |e 3 a |@ |8& s |5 (8
Eg] © ae |s a B 18 Be | 2 \2
a a5 |S 18 |e 183 2 |2
Fels ae 8. a bo ae a ws M4
Se. 25 8/8 3 5 a a 3 8. □
ass 832/38 is ls |S
al ks 5 HEIs 2
(21 5 a a
gee |BEES
an & > Po
ale >, & oO
pes "eS
Soe wi a
> (|e |
be a
bee Pa oO iD a
5 w "s a a D
QR fel o 2 a Solu □ ¢ ie {2
Se 3 S iz a EB |e
ee S Q = = g oO
= i a a “wa a a 2 # a oO
Bi (2 2 2 £8 (|
jale =| 8 5 _
= a= oS a 3 8 QO |Z
a jal o = Mm jo 4
ae 2 5 Toya fe | |é
aa oO 4 oo . —
SOs ALS | od a Sg 9
Hs ee vd Bie 3 |2 2
2 of ; |g la 5 18
Sf Fee : : =a a o a ¢
A ~ Qa a eg |e
bee! <t ‘ . □□ oO OQ q a 2
ce □□ = Oo QO ct ‘DS 2 a
“39 x ahi a 2 e □□□ ‘Oo B12 12
| |e 3 8 A @ |e {3 gS 18 1s
Sake ff □ ERE Ele
Dy “A
3 rain 2 4 3 □□
Sel a aa c 2 a ww
o aS os a oO od wd
EZ 9 ae] 4) uw a 3 w oo
E 2s | 2 5 3 □□ oo ef
ae i 2
= = Rs dg a > s an
pee n a Sey TS eel mn” wad
S be 4 3 So = 6 |&
& = ke o oO ‘Ss □ o oy ob 8 3
2 § of > = 5 Aas
S 2 |) ge | xo □□□ = else ls > 3
SS YD . ‘os = oa oO — —
“ 2 (33 SEale = Ze op Ag 2 BIS pss 2 □□□
Pace ‘ ee oO wn oO mh ¢
5 Eres 228/2 so ee |e 3 | | =e of B 6 IR
□□□ A 5 eo en = 2 S ~
geo ae a BS HES saz = as Zz |e
Jie egcqj2 Pe oe aA oN 8S FS SG8 S18 > se
1223 Pg sles re by bore s|o2512 Salm 5
ms la wd 3 28 = Ees/s 23s Qo
2) □□ = Ass = P| > a2 S/S 8 = so
ES Oy CS se hae ec a So a
eA Oo <f > fet fa a a a bt 3S PEE SE alg &
lel oa O a, 5 Cae so | 2 ge 8s ol a □□
0 2/< 87 Ssh 2235 ASS oo. 3 S/H a
e238 a 7S SOE os Eg Sus 2
eee S38 241 zy = 6g ES <= OnE EIS Cow Oo
2) ew TAO EES 26 afeceeeues w
Be es gas seta 2s 5/2 Sig
Ble 5 eS BEES ma — C4 Be o SS
are = > T= O an Q
25 4550 32 aidsacaledeee
anata
gist tida dae:
eS
Bie8h ial
Assseas
&§ |§ |&8 €
. ‘eo
Ss a ls = |S
c o 2 □ a
= a
= a So |e
2 c Qo 3 Ga Ss
== eh 3 SZ |e AR
os 4 3 E E ec ‘a a 3 ‘3
cy 2 o = is
5. § E Og fi EE is
ele □□ 5 a 5 6 8
a =
[8 48 ‘a = 3 & SB 1s e 15
ele Eg = a 2 = B a
|| mo = oO a i Oo fu
2s s 8 ‘3 a |& | is
pore S = □□ oO ou, 5 o
S|: as □ ole 6S ce |e |e |8 2
Eee| Bx ‘3 = a a a a“ ‘x
Eau g 9 o o wv
os 26 i a ° a |s m4
8 Es 18 5 5 (8 je |g
Ee) ga ° ie aA a 4
o| 8 Qo he a ‘a nd
ee oO Ho o =
ee ye 3 a A
2 oS a a
Lae] 2 a 8 a =
as |g a ie [2
mal
& CIS
aoe oO n a
Slee 2 a |e
a pees ‘a
a SS wn >
Lee "x a a
pee 3 3 □□ @
3 le a ‘5 5 a
3 Soe s is 5 □ & & \§
= 3 a =
a 5 3 = 3 2 |< [5
F ala = a i 5 < “
a ee] oo = a Oo O ol
ABS a 3 Oo > is :
2 bee = o O ‘
ao ee . □ i
| S oO “A od mm = 3
Als fe od a 3 a
2 oR iB 5 UIs IS a |A
a rd fu ; 3 A la =e |e
Eos . 2 x a q 2
Lilo od 3 od A ot 3 g a
|| □ 2 a A 5 2 {2 e |g
$28 Lig 3 A 3 IS | |
Ee] o 2 uy D 4 x
Fel3 ‘3 a 5 &
ca 8 a ‘3 B 2 □ wo iad
PEO a 3 =
= a EE a 2 wv
iS a 8 3 30
32 2 a J =e |2 |e
ae 3 = if le □
Bag S| 5 a i¢ a |s
=| J 0 Sy, □□ g mH («aA
3S 2 iw 3 2 |8% 26 |a oS %
= © 6 a9 oso 1A “sy ©
3 2 Ses lyZ <2 Ze |x 3 = iS
4 ee “oo
2 Fle 2 IES 58 a2 |g3 a2 |g FF i
“Oe no ls = a os > bn | a ©
Fees es Qo = go |S S 2 36 6 8 3
A Llgs2 <352 22 [oz ae |3 |g 218
Eee o i □
Eas a ne G 5 ee oO oO o
188s o2E8 2s Ba 8 Sp A» |S iss
a oo as Ad mo | ~ oo
Eo oy ax s = o nO Td 2a
je32 te (2 oa 33 IS oa) 3 8
‘—=l€23 BE Ea < vp “Oo elu 8 26 Balsa a= os
oa 5 af » wi alfale
els 5 oO 5 4 4 On al-5 2 322° a
ees oC 4 . aol a) bd of
Pal As a SE lS 3. 2ese2s 2A 2
□ (86s Ee falSs e ESSECSG SG anes
lfm a Zased eles av pe
ola 28 2 ESA le 2 geese csi S25 218 3
Blo ae a q 3 alg Bia & Fle 2
cs Oo 5 ala Bele as on
aes| Op 3 b old B/S os 5
Ble as aaa?
27 8.6 3/8 □□
ays 2b Seas ie bees
Pa a GS A o 4
ss S82 4/83
ga 35 □
Sle 2 oO
ace ot
Heal oO