Jones v. Shore'sJones v. Shore's
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Story
delivered the‘opinion of the court, and, after stating the facts, proceeded as follows :
. As the United States have not asserted any claim, the first question for the decision, of the court is, whether the present collector ancTsurveyor, the actual incumbents in office, or the .representatives oí the late collector and surveyor, in right of their testator and intestate, are entitled to the moiety of the money received in satisfaction of the judgment above stated, and now in the custody of the circuit court.
By the express provisions of law, all penalties and forfeitures accruing, under the embargo acts, with a few exceptions, not applicable to this case, are,to be distributed and accounted for in the manner prescribed by the collection law of the 2d of March, 1799, ch. 122. To this latter act, therefore, the arguments of counsel have been chiefly directed; and ppon the true construction of tlie 89th section of‘tbe act, the decision of this cause must principally rest
It is argued on behalf of the present collector and surveyor, that upon tl^e true construction of these
Whenever a forfeiture
in rein
accrues,.it is by the ;ici.pa‘ade. the duty of the collector to seize the thing, afid to prosecute a suit therefor, to final judgment. The law contemplates that he may seize, upon probable Caiiso of seizure, not simply in cases of person-id. knowledge, hut upon the information of others. JJhr.-seizes, however, at‘his peril, and if the act be not Justifiable, he. is subject to a personal responsibility
Much stress has been laid upon the clauses in the 89th and 91st sections of the collection law of the 2d March, 1799, which authorize the collector to receive from the proper officer of the court -the moneys recovered in suits for penalties and forfeitures, and which require him to. pay and distribute the same, according to law, among the officers of the customs, and other parties entitled” thereto. But these provisions áre merely directory to the collector, and do not vest in him any personal right to the money received, which he did not before possess; much less do they authorize the supposition that, until the receipt, no title vested in any person. It might, with as much force and propriety, be urged, that, until the same epoch, no right to the other moiety vested in the United States; for the statute is equally mandatory and precise in this case as in the other. It would, however, be quite impossible to contend, upon any legal principles, that the title of the United States was not, to all intents and purposes, consummated by the judgment.
The same reasoning which has been used in respect to forfeitures
in
rem, applies to personal penalties ; and it is unnecessary to repeat it. The court are clearly of opinion, that the right of the collector ¡0 forfeitures
in rem
attaches on seizure, and to personal penalties on suits brought, and in each case it is ascertained and consummated by the judgment; and it is wholly immaterial whether the collector die. before or after the judgment. And they are further
The next question is as to the proportions.in which this moiety is to be divided between the representatives of.the collector and surveyor. Whatever may have been the practice in the district of Petersburg, the words of the act admit of no reasonable doubt. The moiety is. to be divided in equal proportions between the collector, naval officer, and surveyor, or between such of the said officers as there may be in the district. There was no naval officer in the district of’ Petersburg, and, consequently, the division must be, in equal proportions, between the collector and surveyor.
It is the unanimous opinion of this court, that it be certified to the circuit court, that it is the opinion of this court,
1st. In the case of the United States against Joseph Jones and others, that the moiety of the money now remaining in the custody of the circuit court, in the proceedings in the case of the United States, appellants, against Joseph Jones and others, mentioned, should be paid to the said Joseph Jones, collector of the district of Petersburg, to be, by him, divided in equal proportions between Thomas Shore, as he is executor of the last will and testament of
2d, in the case of Thomas Shore and another against Joseph Jones and others, that the representativo of the late surveyor, in right of his intestate, was entitled to receive pne moiety of that portion of the panalty in the proceedings mentioned, which is by law to be distributed among the several revenue officers of the district wherein the penalty waff incurred.