Jones v. PeopleJones v. People
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Craig
delivered the opinion of the court:
French Jones and Lindsey Jones were indicted in Alexander county for the murder of John Goskie on the 24th day of June, 1895. At the October term, 1895, of the circuit court of Alexander county the two defendants were tried on the indictment and both were found guilty. French Jones was sentenced to the penitentiary for the term of his natural life and Lindsey Jones was sentenced to the penitentiary for the term of fourteen years. French Jones died in the penitentiary, and this writ of error was sued out by the other defendant, Lindsey Jones.
Goskie, the deceased, married Althea Jones, a daughter of French Jones and a sister of plaintiff in error. The deceased and bis wife separated about the 28th day of March,
In view of the threats which the evidence discloses were made by the deceased against French Jones, whether he was justified in killing the deceased in necessary self-defense is a question which it will not be necessary to determine, as he is not before the court. Lindsey Jones, and he alone, is complaining of the judgment of the circuit court, and the question is whether he is guilty in manner and form as charged in the indictment. The crime alleged in each count of the indictment is charged as the joint act of Lindsey Jones and French Jones; that French Jones and Lindsey Jones did unlawfully, feloniously and willfully, with malice aforethought, assault and shoot one John K. Goskie, and gave him several mortal wounds, of which he instantly died, etc.
At the time the shooting took place four persons were at or near where it occurred,—the two defendants, Althea Goskie and William Miller,—but no one except the two
There is no controversy from any quarter in regard to the fact that French Jones shot and killed Goskie, but, while Lindsey Jones was present, there is no evidence in the record that he aided, abetted or assisted French Jones, in any manner, in killing the deceased. In order to justify the jury in convicting plaintiff in error under the indictment, it should appear, from the evidence, beyond a reasonable doubt, not only that he was present when French Jones killed the deceased, but that he aided, abetted or assisted in the homicide. If plaintiff in error was present and assented to the homicide but did no act in aid of the killing, he could not be convicted under the indictment. The rule applicable to a case of this character is clearly laid down in White v. People, 81 Ill. 333. It is there, among other things, said (p. 337): “Bythe second instruction the jury are told that one who stands by when a crime is committed in his presence by another, and consents to the perpetration of the crime, is a principal in the offense, and must be punished as such. The law is, that one who ‘stands by and aids, abets or assists * * * the perpetration
After a careful examination of the entire record we do not think the evidence sufficient to authorize a conviction, and the judgment will be reversed and the cause remanded.
Reversed, and remanded.