Jones v. O'HIGGINSJones v. O'HIGGINS
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- McCurn
MEMORANDUM-DECISION AND ORDER
McCURN, Chief Judge.I. BACKGROUND
This is a motion by the defendant, Michael O’Higgins, to recover legal fees and costs which he incurred in the course of successfully defending against . claims brought by the plaintiff under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (“ERISA”). Defendant’s motion is based on
In the underlying action the plaintiff asserted that the defendant breached fiduciary obligations while managing the assets of plaintiff’s pension plan. The suit was precipitated by a large drop in the value of the assets contained in the pension plan over a nine-month period in 1986. As it was originally styled, the complaint assert
At the end of a two-day non-jury trial, plaintiff withdrew from consideration all but two of the ERISA claims. Plaintiff also withdrew his claim for punitive damages. The two claims remaining for consideration after trial were: (1) whether the defendant failed to diversify the pension plan’s investment portfolio so as to minimize the risk of large losses under
With respect to the diversification claim pursuant to
The court rejected plaintiff’s other “prudent man” cause of action on the grounds that: (1) the defendant put forward credible evidence that his “contrarian” investment strategy was “both independently prudent and within the standards and practice of the investment industry;” (2) it appeared to the court that plaintiff, rather than the defendant, decided to sell the stocks at a low price; and (3) plaintiff had failed to provide significant proof, through expert testimony or otherwise, that the defendant had not performed within industry standards. Decision at 18-19. It should be noted that the court’s determination, as to who made the decision to sell the stock at a low price, was a credibility determination which was made after a consideration of the conflicting testimony of the plaintiff and witnesses for the defendant. Decision at 8.
II. DISCUSSION
A. Legal Standard
The defendant has moved for attorney’s fees pursuant to
In any action under this subchapter ... by a participant, beneficiary, or fiduciary, the court in its discretion may allow a reasonable attorney’s fee and costs of action to either party.
The decision on whether to award legal costs is generally based on five factors:
(1) the degree of the offending party’s culpability or bad faith, (2) the ability of the offending party to satisfy an award of attorney’s fees, (3) whether an award of fees would deter other persons from acting similarly under like circumstances, (4) the relative merits of the parties’ positions, and (5) whether the action conferred a common benefit on a group of pension plan participants.
Miles v. New York State Teamsters Conference, Pension and Retirement Fund Employee Pension Benefit Plan,
698 F.2d 593, 602 n. 9 (2nd Cir.)
cert. denied,
464 U.S. 829, 104 S.Ct. 105, 78 L.Ed.2d 108 (1983);
see Chambless v. Masters, Mates & Pilots Pension Plan,
815 F.2d 869, 871 (2nd Cir.1987);
Ford v. New York Central
Determinations as to whether an award of attorney’s fees under
The favorable slant toward ERISA plaintiffs is necessary to prevent the chilling of suits brought in good faith — the purpose of ERISA being to promote the interests of plan beneficiaries and allow them to enforce their statutory rights. See e.g., Firestone Tire and Rubber Co. v. Bruch, 489 U.S. 101, 109 S.Ct. 948, 956, 103 L.Ed.2d 80 (1989) (“ERISA was enacted ‘to promote the interests of employees and their beneficiaries in employee benefit plans’ ... and ‘to protect contractually defined benefits.’ ”) (and cases cited therein); Chambless v. Masters, Mates & Pilots Pension Plan, 815 F.2d at 872 (“ERISA’s attorney fee provisions must be liberally construed to protect the statutory purpose of vindicating retirement rights.”).
B. Contentions of the Parties
Affidavits submitted by the defendant state that he incurred over $33,000.00 in legal fees and costs in the defense of this action — an action which he believes was essentially frivolous. Defendant first notes that the plaintiff voluntarily withdrew from the court’s consideration the claims concerning prohibited transactions and the request for punitive damages. This, defendant maintains, reveals that those claims had no merit. Defendant further contends that he was not only successful in ultimately having all claims dismissed, but that the plaintiff completely failed to offer any credible proof on (1) the prudence of the investment strategy followed by the defendant or (2) the proper measure of damages. The defendant asserts that the court should conclude that the plaintiff made serious accusations, ones that could injure the defendant’s reputation and livelihood, without doing the legal and investigatory work necessary to support
The plaintiff recognizes that he lost the suit but maintains that an award of attorney’s fees is inappropriate. Plaintiff first notes that the court specifically held that he made out a prima facie case for lack of diversification. Decision at 13. Plaintiff asserts that the showing of a prima facie case is evidence that the plaintiff’s suit was “substantially justified.” Plaintiff further asserts that the drop in the value of the highly concentrated investment portfolio from approximately $836,335.00 to $525,-989.00 over a nine-month period would make most reasonable people believe that something imprudent had occurred. Plaintiff correctly points out that the court made a number of important credibility determinations, favorable to the defendant, in the course of deciding this case. Specifically, the court found that it was plaintiff who opted for the higher risk, higher yield, investment strategy and that it was the plaintiff who decided to sell the concentrated investment portfolio when it was at its lowest value. Plaintiff contends that a court should be slow to award attorney’s fees when the basis of its decision was the credibility of conflicting witnesses. With respect to the issue of “prudence” the court recognizes that even the defendant’s own expert stated that he would probably not concentrate an investment portfolio in fewer than six stocks. Decision at 15. Here, the defendant was invested in only three stocks, and then, during a period of sharp decline.
C. Analysis
The first factor of the five-factor test is the degree of the offending party’s culpability or bad faith. It does not appear that the plaintiff acted in bad faith in bringing this suit. The plaintiff did make out a prima facie case of an ERISA violation. The concentration of the investments was unusual even under the standards of the defendant’s own expert. Moreover, if the court had found plaintiff Jones to be the more credible witness, and it was a close question, this court may have held in favor of the plaintiff regardless of the testimony on the prudence of the investments. Though the plaintiff withdrew a number of claims from the court’s consideration at the end of trial for lack of proof, it must be recognized that the defendant never moved for summary judgment on these issues — an action which would have obviated the need for any trial preparation on these issues. Moreover, given that a trial was clearly necessary on at least two of plaintiff’s ERISA claims, it does not appear to the court that these “extra” claims greatly increased defendant’s costs in defending this action.
The second factor is the ability of the offending party to satisfy an award of attorney’s fees. The parties apparently agree that the plaintiff could satisfy an award of attorney’s fees.
The third factor is whether an award of attorney’s fees would deter other persons from acting similarly under like circumstances. As discussed, a central purpose of ERISA is to protect plan beneficiaries by allowing them to enforce their rights in court. In circumstances where the plaintiff has come forward with a prima facie case of an ERISA violation, a decision to award attorney’s fees would likely operate to “chill” other plaintiffs from asserting their rights under ERISA. Thus, an award of attorney’s fees in this instance, even if it might discourage similar suits, would go against the grain of ERISA’s purpose — the protection of beneficiaries.
The fourth factor is the relative merits of the parties’ positions. This factor cuts in favor of the defendant for the obvious reason that he won on all counts. It is also clear that some of the claims asserted by the plaintiff were not supported by any evidence. However, the court’s decision on two of plaintiff’s claims was not premised so much upon the defendant’s affirmative defense, but rather, plaintiff’s failure to provide credible expert testimony to counterbalance the expert evidence provided by the defendant. If plaintiff had placed an appropriate expert on the stand, the court’s decision, as to whether ERISA’s fiduciary standards had been violated, would have
The last factor, whether the action conferred a common benefit, does not cut in favor of either party. While the plaintiff brought this action for his own benefit, it is plain that other persons who invested with the defendant would have stood to benefit from a finding that ERISA’s fiduciary standards had been violated.
III. CONCLUSION
Given the circumstances of this case and an analysis of the five factors generally considered in a motion for an award of attorney’s fees under ERISA,
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Notes
. This view is consistent with the Second Circuit’s recent decision in
Anita Foundations, Inc. v. ILGWU National Retirement Fund,
902 F.2d 185 (2nd Cir.1990). There, the court addressed the propriety of an award of attorney’s fees to employers, under
[T]he five-factor test provides sufficient latitude to review a fee request by allowing courts to consider which party is requesting fees, assess the relative culpability of the parties and address the potential deleterious effect of a fee award. For these reasons, the five factors will often balance against an employer seeking fees under ERISA.
Id. at 189 (emphasis added). The court thus found that the “flexible five factor test will not discourage colorable withdrawal liability suits.” Id. at 189.