Johnson v. StateJohnson v. State
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Bruns, Schroeder, Isherwood (per curiam)
MEMORANDUM OPINION
PER CURIAM: Rheuben Clifford Johnson appeals from the district court‘s summary denial of his
FACTS
The parties are familiar with the underlying facts and it is unnecessary to repeat them in detail in this opinion. A jury convicted Johnson of two counts of solicitation to commit the first-degree murder of his ex-wife. A panel of this court affirmed Johnson‘s convictions on direct appeal, and the Kansas Supreme Court denied his petition for review. State v. Johnson, No. 110,837, 2017 WL 4558235, at *1, 13 (Kan. App. 2017) (unpublished opinion), rev. denied 308 Kan. 1598 (2018). Likewise, the United States Supreme Court denied his petition for a writ of certiorari. Johnson v. Kansas, 586 U.S. 1238 (2019).
On December 27, 2019, Johnson filed a pro se
In January 2020, an attorney was appointed to represent Johnson in his
A few weeks after the bench ruling was announced—but before a journal entry had been filed—another district court judge was assigned to this matter. Moreover, it
The reason for the delay in filing the journal entry until July 21, 2021, is not readily apparent from the record. Regardless, it is undisputed that a “Journal Entry Denying K.S.A. 60-1507” was signed by the original judge who had issued the bench ruling and filed with the Clerk of the District Court on that date. It is also undisputed that Johnson failed to file either a motion to reconsider or a notice of appeal in the statutorily allotted time period following the filing of the journal entry summarily denying his
Even though neither a motion to reconsider nor a notice of appeal were filed by Johnson following the filing of the journal entry, the district court held several more hearings and granted another motion for appointment of new counsel. In November 2021, Johnson requested that this matter be stayed while he pursued a related federal habeas action in federal court. By the time the district court held a hearing on November 4, 2022, Johnson had been released from prison and was serving postrelease supervision. At that hearing, the parties—as well as the district court—expressed their confusion regarding the current status of the
The district court continued the hearing to look into the record and to review Johnson‘s affidavit of indigency for the appointment of new counsel. Shortly thereafter, the district court once again appointed new counsel to represent Johnson. Several months later—at a May 2023 scheduling conference—Johnson again asked that this matter be stayed so that he could pursue his federal habeas corpus action. In response, the district
On July 6, 2023, the State filed a motion requesting that the district court find that the journal entry summarily denying Johnson‘s
After Johnson filed a notice of appeal, this court issued an order to show cause as to why this action should not be dismissed for lack of appellate jurisdiction. The order noted the journal entry summarily denying the
ANALYSIS
At the outset, we must determine whether we have appellate jurisdiction over this appeal and, if so, the extent of that jurisdiction. As the parties are aware, the right to appeal is entirely statutory and is not a right protected in either the United States or
“A judgment is the final determination of the parties’ rights in an action.”
Still, this 30-day statutory deadline may be tolled if an appellant files certain postjudgment motions with the district court in a timely manner.
Here, a review of the record reveals that the final judgment summarily denying Johnson‘s
We pause to note that Johnson asserts—for the first time on appeal—that his
In summary, we conclude that we lack appellate jurisdiction to review the district court‘s journal entry filed on July 21, 2021, which summarily denied Johnson‘s
Appeal dismissed.