Johnson v. StateJohnson v. State
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Carleton Harris
Joe Purcell, Attorney General; Don Langston, Asst. Atty. Gen., for appellee.
CARLETON HARRIS, Chief Justice. Appellants, Alan D. Johnson and Louise M. Loyd were charged and convicted of the crime of Robbery, it being alleged that they did by force rob the Pottsville office of the Peoples Bank and Trust Company of $7,000.00. The jury fixed the punishment of each at confinement in the state penitentiary for a period of 15 years. From the judgment so entered, appellants bring this appeal. For reversal, two points are asserted, first, that the court should have granted appellants’ motion for continuance, and second, that the court should have granted appellants’ motion for severance of the cases. We proceed to a discussion of each point.
“The defendants would move for a continuance due to inadequate time in which to prepare a defense, that Alan D. Johnson‘s first opportunity to speak to his attorney was approximately 4:00 o‘clock Friday afternoon; and at this time we would also move the Court to sever the two actions and give the defendants a separate trial, because their interests are adverse to each other, and the same lawyers do not2 represent each of them.”
In discussing the second point, it is necessary that the evidence be reviewed. Harold Edward Williams testified that he was employed by the Peoples Bank and Trust Company of Russellville, and was working in the Pottsville branch on June 25, arriving at work about 8:30 A.M. He said that shortly after 1:00 P.M. the door opened, and a man, followed by a woman, came
Billy Baker, Corporal with the Arkansas State Police, testified that, on June 25, he was on duty and received a communication about a pickup truck, and was told to watch out for it. He had also been advised that a bank robbery had occurred. Baker testified that he saw the truck at the west edge of Atkins, driving east on U. S. Highway 64; that he was driving west, but turned around and gave pursuit, finally stopping the truck after it had turned off onto Highway 105. The occupants of the vehicle, the appellants, were placed under arrest, and the officer made a search of the truck, and inter alia, found a large amount of money in a blue and white striped pillow case on the front seat. There was $6,694.00 in the sack.
Officer Andy McKay testified that he interviewed the two appellants and advised them of their constitutional rights; that Johnson indicated that he understood his rights and signed a waiver, and upon being asked if he had been involved in the commission of robbing the bank at Pottsville, answered, “You caught us with the goods. There is no sense in messing around, but before I give an answer I wish to talk to an attorney.” Subsequently, however, he gave a voluntary statement as to his participation, but the statement was interrupted for arraignment purposes, and after the arraignment, the attorney who had been appointed for appellants directed McKay not to talk with Johnson any further.
Joe W. Phillips, a special agent with the F. B. I., testified that he investigated the bank robbery, interviewed Johnson, advising the latter of his constitution
As to Mrs. Loyd, McKay stated:
“She denied knowledge of the bank robbery, didn‘t wish to make a statement, made several verbal comments she was nowhere around; and she stated it was true she and this fellow had come up to this area. She had got with a gentleman from Dardanelle, Arkansas; that they had anticipated going fishing; they got to drinking; and I believe her description was ‘he got a little too hairy’ for her in their consumption of alcohol, and she decided to hitchhike home; and it was just shortly before Trooper Baker had stopped them that Mr. Johnson had picked her up hitchhiking; and she knew nothing of the bank situation.”
Neither appellant testified:
The question of whether a severance should or should not be granted in felony trials less than capital
We find no prejudice to either appellant, because of the court‘s refusal to grant a severance.
Affirmed.
Notes
“In the case at bar, appellants in addition to being antagonistic towards each other, and having testimony if offered that would conflict with the others were both represented by the same appointed counsel. The fact that the same counsel represented both appellants prevented any showing of the hostility. The only alternative was for both to decline to take the stand. This presented a situation where the appellants when tried together were effectively deprived of representation by counsel.”
“Shortly after 1:00 P.M., on Wednesday, June 25, 1969, I robbed the bank in Pottsville, Arkansas. While I cased that bank on the morning of June 25, 1969, prior to the robbery, I realized it was a branch bank of the Peoples Bank and Trust Company of Russellville, Arkansas. After I robbed the bank, I tried to lock the teller in the bank vault. I locked the vault door partially, but I did not get it locked all the way. I actually planned the robbery Tuesday night 6/24/69 before I robbed the bank on 6/25/69.
“I arrived in Pottsville, Arkansas, on the morning of 6/25/69 and drove by the bank a couple of times and cased it before robbing it that afternoon.”