Jenkins v. LarpenterJenkins v. Larpenter
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Gaidry, Guidry, McClendon
GAIDRY, J.
Appellant appeals the dismissal of his suit for failure to timely request service on the defendants. Having reviewed the record and the applicable law, we affirm.
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
On January 14, 2002, Tommie T. Jenkins, Jr. filed a personal injury suit against Jerry J. Larpenter, as Sheriff of Terrebonne Parish; the Terrebonne Parish Sheriff‘s Office; and four other defendants,1 based on injuries he sustained on January 18, 2001, while confined in the Terrebonne Parish Criminal Justice Complex. In his petition, Jenkins alleged that he was “without funds and ... unable to prepay court costs or as they accrue or provide funds for bonds for costs.” He requested that Sheriff Larpenter and the Terrebonne Parish Sheriff‘s Office be served with a copy of the petition, but that service be withheld on all other defendants. Attached to the petition was a signed pauper application. Jenkins‘s request to proceed in forma pauperis was denied by order of the trial court on January 17, 2002, and notice of the order was sent on January 23, 2002. As a result of the court‘s denial of his request to prosecute the suit in forma pauperis, service was not made.
On January 22, 2003, Sheriff Larpenter filed a motion for involuntary dismissal pursuant to
A joint hearing on the motion and exception was held, and by judgment dated July 11, 2003, the trial court dismissed Jenkins‘s suit without prejudice. Following the denial of his motion for new trial, Jenkins moved for an order of devolutive appeal, which was granted by the trial court.
ASSIGNMENTS OF ERROR
By this appeal Jenkins raises the following assignments of error:
1. The trial court erred in finding that plaintiff‘s request for service in the original petition did not constitute a “request” that satisfied the requirements of
La. C.C.P. art. 1201(C) andLa. R.S. 13:5107(D) .2. The trial court erred in redefining the word “request” to mean more
than the ordinary meaning of the word. 3. The trial court erred in granting defendant‘s Exception of Insufficiency of Service of Process and Motion for Involuntary Dismissal.
4. The trial court erred in denying plaintiff‘s motion for new trial.
DISCUSSION
Article 1672(C) of the Louisiana Code of Civil Procedure mandates that an action be dismissed if good cause is not shown why service of the citation is not requested within the ninety-day time period provided in
(1) In all suits in which the state, a state agency, or political subdivision, or any officer or employee thereof is named as a party, service of citation shall be requested within ninety days of the commencement of the action or the filing of a supplemental or amended petition which initially names the state, a state agency, or political subdivision or any officer or employee thereof as a party. This requirement may be expressly waived by the defendant in such action by any written waiver.
(2) If service is not requested by the party filing the action within that period, the action shall be dismissed without prejudice, after contradictory motion as provided in
Code of Civil Procedure Article 1672(C) , as to the state, state agency, or political subdivision, or any officer or employee thereof, who has not been served.(3) When the state, a state agency, or a political subdivision, or any officer or employee thereof, is dismissed as a party pursuant to this Section, the filing of the action, even as against other defendants, shall not interrupt or suspend the running of prescription as to the state, state agency, or political subdivision, or any officer or employee thereof; however, the effect of interruption of prescription as to other persons shall continue.
In Ayers, 03-1576 at p. 2, 870 So.2d at 349, the Fourth Circuit found that requesting service and providing service instructions without payment is not a request for service under
In Tenney v. Burlington Northern & Santa Fe Railway, 03-1260, p. 4 (La.1/21/04), 863 So.2d 526, 528, the Supreme Court held that the timely filing of a “proper application” to proceed in forma pauperis satisfies
A proper pauper status request is but part of the requirements under
We find that a request for service without payment of required fees, or without leave of court excusing such payment because of pauper status, simply is no proper request at all. The articles requiring that service be requested within ninety days would be rendered meaningless if a non-pauper plaintiff could include a paragraph in his petition “requesting” service, but not actually pay the fee required for service to be effected. Even if the 90-day deadline was tolled until the denial of his request for pauper status, Jenkins failed to pay the required fee for well over ten months after being notified of that denial, and no good cause was shown for such failure. See Ayers, 03-1576 at p. 2, 870 So.2d at 349. Thus, he did not request service within the ninety-day period, and the trial court was therefore correct in dismissing his petition.
CONCLUSION
For the above reasons, we affirm the judgment of the trial court and assess all costs of this appeal to plaintiff, Tommie T. Jenkins, Jr.
AFFIRMED.
GUIDRY, J., dissents and assigns reasons.
GUIDRY, J., dissenting.
The statutes at issue,
Interpreting
I believe that the majority errs in failing to apply the law as written and in essentially rewriting the law to effect a purpose that is not otherwise expressed in the statutes at issue. See Naquin v. Titan Indemnity Co., 00-1585, p. 9 (La.2/21/01), 779 So.2d 704, 710. Had the legislature wanted to require a plaintiff to pay any applicable filing fees or be granted pauper status within the stipulated time period in order for the service request to be valid, it could have so provided. See e.g.,