Jemison v. CrichlowJemison v. Crichlow
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Bracken
OPINION OF THE COURT
Bracken, J. This court having recently decided that
I
The plaintiffs allege, in their complaint, that Crichlow, a City Marshal and licensed process server, forcibly evicted them from their apartment on West 31st Street, Brooklyn, New York, on April 11, 1983, pursuant to a judgment of the Civil Court, Kings County, which had been entered upon their default. It is further alleged that prior to the execution of the judgment of the Civil Court, Crichlow had filed with that court an affidavit which falsely stated that he had previously served a dispossess notice upon the plaintiffs. It is also alleged that ”[a]ll acts and omissions complained of defendant Crichlow herein were undertaken and conducted intentionally, deliberately, willfully, knowingly and voluntarily”. The complaint also contains the allegation that the “[defendant Crichlow performed his duties in a negligent manner”.
Based upon these allegations, among others, the plaintiffs sought a money judgment against Crichlow, for both compensatory and punitive damages, upon the following theories: (1) wrongful eviction, (2) conversion, (3) trespass to property, (4) trespass to chattels, (5) prima facie tort, (6) intentional infliction of emotional distress, (7) intentional interference with contractual and economic relations, (8) negligence, and (9) violation of the plaintiffs’ constitutional rights (
In opposition to the motion, the plaintiffs’ attorney stated that on April 10, 1986, one day before the expiration of the three-year Statute of Limitations (
Special Term agreed with Crichlow that the” plaintiffs’ several causes of action were all barred by the Statute of Limitations set forth in
II
By filing a copy of a summons with notice with the Clerk of the Supreme Court, Kings County, within three years of their eviction, and by subsequently serving a copy of a summons with notice on Crichlow within 60 days of when the three-year Statute of Limitations would otherwise have run, the plaintiffs are deemed to have interposed their claims within three years of the accrual of their causes of action (
The plaintiffs’ first cause of action for wrongful eviction is governed by a one-year Statute of Limitations and is therefore time barred irrespective of the applicability of
The plaintiffs’ other seven claims, aside from consideration of
Ill
The plaintiffs seek to avoid the effect of our decision in Kolomensky v Wiener (supra) by arguing that
CCA 701 (a) provides that all processes and mandates of that court “shall be served or executed by the sheriff of the city of New York or by a city marshal”. Pursuant to section 401 (c) of that act, notices of petition in summary proceedings to recover possession of real property are issued by the Civil Court, and hence, are served by a City Marshal or Sheriff. There can be no doubt, then, that Crichlow was acting by virtue of his authority as a City Marshal when he executed the warrant of eviction at the plaintiffs’ apartment, or that he failed in the performance of his official duty when he (allegedly) neglected, or intentionally omitted, to make service of the prior eviction documents. The complaint, in fact, alleges that Crichlow’s actions were “under pretense and color of law and [in] his official capacity”.
It has been held that “[t]he liability to which this short limitation period [
It is therefore apparent that a holding that the short limitations period provided for in
“A surety, by the more liberal rule, is liable to all persons unlawfully injured by nonfeasance, misfeasance, or malfeasance by a sheriff or constable, by virtue of his office or under color of his office” (9A Appleman, Insurance Law and Practice § 5541, at 155). Since Crichlow was given by his office the authority to serve the process of the Civil Court, it follows that if he exercised that authority in an improper manner (or failed to exercise it in a proper manner), his surety would be liable for the resulting injuries, since those acts or omissions would have been done by virtue of his office. “Acts done by virtue of office are those within the authority of the officer by the duties imposed upon him, but in the doing of which he negligently or wilfully causejs] harm to others.” (Simpson, Suretyship, at 434 [emphasis added].) This rule is reflected in New York’s case law on the subject.
In Dennison v Plumb (18 Barb 89, 90), while explaining the
In Politano v Jacoby (264 NY 686, affg 241 App Div 820), an action against a Sheriff for unlawful imprisonment was held to be barred by the one-year Statute of Limitations. The plaintiff in Politano v Jacoby (supra) had been illegally incarcerated by the defendant Sheriff for several months.
In Wiener v Ellrodt (268 NY 646, affg 243 App Div 820), the act of a Sheriff in falsely attesting that he had made personal service of process was held to be an act within the Sheriff’s official capacity, so that the shorter limitation period provided in Civil Practice Act § 51 (1) (the predecessor of
In Eckstein v Massachusetts Bonding & Ins. Co. (281 NY 435, 438-439, rearg denied 282 NY 590 [emphasis supplied]), the court stated that the bond of a Marshal of the City of New York protects against the officer’s malfeasance “while performing judicial functions where he has maliciously deprived a person of his property or rights (57 C.J. p. 793)”, as well as while acting within the scope of his official duties and performing ministerial functions. This statement would certainly be inconsistent with a holding that Sheriffs (or Marshals) who act maliciously in the exercise of their duties are not covered by their official bonds.
More recently, several courts have applied the one-year Statute of Limitations of
“The distinction is sought to be drawn between acts in excess of a sheriff’s authority, which he purports to do as sheriff, and acts which are done both in excess of authority and maliciously, that is to say, for some consciously personal and unlawful end. I can see no justification for distinguishing between the latter class of acts and those dealt with by the New York Court of Appeals in Wiener v. Ellrodt, 268 N.Y. 646, 198 N.E. 537, and Politano v. Jacoby, 264 N.Y. 686, 191 N.E. 627, which are very recent decisions. Moreover, the language of the court in Eckstein v. Massachusetts Bonding & Ins. Co., 281 N.Y. 435, 24 N.E.2d 114, 116, 125 A.L.R. 1143, indicates that the distinction suggested is untenable * * *
“To hold that the sureties on the sheriff’s bond would not be liable for imprisonment of the plaintiff because of the sheriff’s malicious motives would involve a novel doctrine of suretyship not warranted by the New York authorities. The deputy sheriff lawfully took the plaintiff into custody under the bench warrant. While, in taking her to prison instead of before a magistrate, he exceeded his authority, very soon afterwards he placed her in the hospital pursuant to an order of the county judge. All these things were done ‘in his official capacity.’ They did not cease to be ‘official’ because of any malicious motive and the sureties would not be exempt from liability because such a motive existed. This, I think, is the New York law and is the law of nearly all other jurisdictions. Kosowsky v. Fidelity & Deposit Co. of Maryland, 1928, 245 Mich. 266, 222 N.W. 153; Stark Hickey, Inc. v. Standard Acc. Ins. Co., 291 Mich. 350, 289 N.W. 172; Clancy v. Kenworthy, 74 Iowa 740, 35 N.W. 427, 7 Am. St. Rep. 508; Powell v. Fidelity & Deposit Co. of Maryland, 1932, 45 Ga. App. 88, 163 S.E. 239; Indiana ex rel. Tyler v. Gobin, C.C., 94 F. 48; Greenberg v. People to Use of Balaban, 225 Ill. 174, 80 N.E. 100, 8 L.R.A., N.S., 1223, 116 Am. St. Rep. 127; Commonwealth v. De Luca, 131 Pa. Super. 451, 200 A. 712; Branch v. Guinn, Tex. Civ. App., 242 S.W. 482. See also Wieters v. May, 71 S. C. 9, 50 S.E. 547;
The cases cited in Judge Hand’s dissent support the rule that, in general, a Sheriffs performance bond will cover liability which is based upon acts or omissions which constitute an intentional or malicious abuse of power. In Powell v Fidelity & Deposit Co. (45 Ga App 88, 163 SE 239), the Georgia court held that a Sheriff who without provocation shot and killed his prisoner was acting within his official capacity so as to render his surety liable (see also, Smith v Glens Falls Indem. Co., 71 Ga App 697, 32 SE2d 105). In Kosowsky v Fidelity & Deposit Co. (245 Mich 266, 222 NW 153), the Michigan court held that a Sheriffs bond covered the liability of a Sheriff who wrongfully assaulted and beat a prisoner. In Stark Hickey, Inc. v Standard Acc. Ins. Co. (291 Mich 350, 289 NW 172), the bond was held to cover liability imposed upon a Constable for damages caused by his fraudulent execution of a bill of sale.
The list of cases cited by Judge Hand in his Ingo dissent may be supplemented by the following, among others:
In Meeks v Douglas (108 Ga App 424, 425, 133 SE2d 768, 769), a Sheriffs bond was held to extend to liability for the injury to the plaintiff’s property and privacy caused when the Sheriff wrongfully caused a search warrant to be executed “in bad faith”.
In State, Use of Hill v Fidelity & Deposit Co. (200 Md 194, 203, 88 A2d 457, 461), the Court of Appeals of Maryland held that a surety on a Sheriffs bond was liable where, “in the discharge of the duties of his office, [the Sheriff] brutally assaults a person without provocation or necessity”.
In light of the weight of authority from the other jurisdictions mentioned above, which in our view comports with the relevant New York precedent, we reject the holding of the Second Circuit in Ingo v Koch (supra) to the extent that it can be read as espousing a rule that Sheriffs’ or Marshals’ performance bonds need not protect the public against harm resulting from official misconduct of an intentional or malicious nature. Those cases which followed the rationale of Ingo v Koch (supra; see, e.g., Paschall v Mayone, 454 F Supp 1289, 1297; see also, Carrasco v Klein, 381 F Supp 782, 788-789 [addressing but not deciding issue]) are also unpersuasive.
We therefore conclude that Crichlow would be liable in his
IV
However, the same result does not obtain with respect to the plaintiffs’ action under the Federal Civil Rights Act of 1871 (
Finally, we note that Crichlow’s motion was also one to dismiss the complaint for failure to state a cause of action. The only argument advanced on appeal in this regard is the
This was the only argument specifically advanced on appeal with respect to the sufficiency of the plaintiffs’ allegations, and “we express no opinion as to whether the allegations of the complaint are legally insufficient for any reason [not] specifically raised on this appeal” (Savino v Board of Educ., 123 AD2d 314, 315).
For the foregoing reasons, the order under review should be modified so as to provide for the denial of defendant Crichlow’s motion to dismiss the plaintiffs’ ninth cause of action. As so modified, the order should be affirmed.
Mangano, J. P., Lawrence and Spatt, JJ., concur.
Ordered that the order is modified, on the law, by deleting therefrom the provision which dismissed the ninth cause of action as against both of the defendants, and substituting therefor a provision denying that branch of the defendant Chrichlow’s motion which was to dismiss that cause of action; as so modified, the order is affirmed, without costs or disbursements.