Jefferson County v. FergusonJefferson County v. Ferguson
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Caton
Four amendments were allowed to this bill, two of which were permitted after the case had been argued, and while it was under advisement in the court below. The permitting of these amendments is now assigned for error. We do not think that the decree should be reversed for this cause alone. As a general rule, these amendments are in the discretion of the Circuit Court; and when admitted for furtherance of justice, we ought not to listen to the objection, unless the party can show that his substantial rights have been prejudiced by the amendments which’ have been allowed. A case might exist, and we are not prepared to say that this is not that case, where it would be the exercise of a judicious discretion to permit amendments even to the extent allowed here ; but certainly, except to make new parties, amendments should not be allowed after a cause has been submitted to the court, unless under extraordinary circumstances of necessity. That the court has authority to allow such amendments upon proper conditions, there can be no doubt; for, without looking into the English practice on the subject, we find the authority expressly given in the thirty-fourth section of our Chancery act.
The proofs in the case show, beyond a controversy, that Nelson Ferguson the ancestor of the complainants, purchased the lot in question in 1819, at a public sale of lots by the county, upon a credit, and that the terms of sale were, that he should give a note for the purchase-money payable in six, twelve, eighteen, and twenty-four months, upon the execution of which he should receive a certificate of purchase, and that upon the payment of the notes he should receive a deed. We think the proofs show, with equal clearness, that the lot has ever since been claimed under that purchase by Ferguson, or those claiming under him. That the lot was actually taken possession of under that purchase, and a house built upon it in 1829, which was occupied by tenants under that title until the commencement of this suit. It is true that in 1848, one McArtee attempted to hold the lot in subordination to the title of the defendants; but the facts of the case show that he could not divest himself of the character of a tenant under the complainants’
Since 1839, then, the premises have been actually occupied under the complainants’ title. The proof also shows, that for most, if not all, of the time since the sale of 1819, the county has treated the lot as private and individual property by assessing it for taxes and collecting the same. These are facts not seriously controverted. The controversy is made upon the questions, whether Nicholas Ferguson complied with the terms of sale by the execution and delivery of the note required; and whether a certificate of purchase was made to him.
The evidence upon these points, if not conclusive, is quite satisfactory. Upon the first point, several witnesses speak. Mr. Johnson.says he signed the note for the purchase-money, on the evening of the day of sale, as security for Ferguson; that the note was executed in the presence of the court, but that he does not recollect of having seen it actually delivered. J. Pace was
We have no hesitation in finding, that at a public sale of property belonging to the county held in 1819, in pursuance of an order of the County Commissioners’ Court, the ancestor of the complainants purchased the premises in question; that he complied with the condition of such sale by giving his note for the purchase-money, with approved security, which was accepted by the proper county authorities, and which note was duly paid; that he, or those claiming under him, took possession of said property under the sale, made valuable improvements thereon, and have held and continued such possession until the commencement of this suit; and, the whole of the purchase-money having been paid, this entitles the complainants, who are the only heirs at law of the original purchaser, to a conveyance of the property, whether a certificate of purchase was ever delivered to Ferguson or not. In this we find that the Circuit Court decided correctly. The court, however, erred in awarding costs against the county commissioners personally. The county was the defendant in the suit; and if costs were to follow the decree, they should have been adjudged against the county. That portion of the decree which relates to costs must, therefore, be reversed, which imposes the duty upon this court of disposing of the question of costs, as we think the Circuit Court should have done in the exercise of a sound discretion. The county acts through its officers, and is not, like an individual, bound to remember ancient transactions, unless disclosed by its records. The present commissioners may well have been justified in resisting a claim of which they found no evidence on their records, and which should properly have appeared there. Indeed, they may not have been justified in making a conveyance, under the circumstances of this case, except in obedience to the decree of a competent tribunal. Nor can we say that the appeal was vexatiously prosecuted. Upon consideration of the whole case, we are of opinion that the parties respectively should pay the costs made by them in the Circuit Court;
Decree affirmed.