Janzen v. PeopleJanzen v. People
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Craig
delivered the opinion of the court:
This was an indictment in the circuit court of Stephenson county, against Ebbert Janzen, plaintiff in error, for rape, alleged to have been committed on or about the first day of May, 1894, upon the person of his daughter, Mary Janzen, who at the time the offense was committed was under the age of fourteen years. On a trial before a jury the defendant was found guilty as charged in the indictment, and his term of imprisonment was fixed at six years in the penitentiary. The court overruled a motion for a new trial and entered judgment on the verdict, to reverse which the defendant sued out this writ of error.
/It is first claimed by counsel for plaintiff in error that the court erred in the admission of improper evidence, and under this head it is said the prosecution was permitted to introduce evidence that another offense was committed by the defendant on the person of another daughter, subsequently to the one charged in the indictment. Upon looking into the record it appears that Yetta Janzen, a sister of the prosecuting witness, was called and testified in behalf of the People, and from her evidence it appeared that she had been absent from home about three years, living with a family named Clipping, who resided some five miles from the defendant. Upon cross-examination of the witness the following occurred : Counsel for defense stated that he desired to show that the witness ‘had become displeased with her father because she did not have as good a home with him as she had at Clipping’s.
Q. “You did not want to stay at home, did you, Yetta?
A. “No, sir.
Q. “Did your father want you to stay at home?
A. “Yes, sir.”
After this evidence was called out by the defendant, the court, over the objection of the defendant, permitted the witness, on behalf of the People, to testify as follows: “He tried to use me in a bad way in bed. First he was in another bed and afterwards he came into my bed. The boys and Mary were out doors. This was about five o’clock in the morning. After he got into bed he took hold of my arms and got on top of me. He unbuttoned my drawers and put his private parts between my legs. I hollered, ‘Ouch. ’ I hollered more than once—not very loud. When I got up and went out doors I found half a dozen men there.”/This evidence was admitted, as stated by the court, for the purpose of showing why the witness, . Yetta, left home, and the jury were told by the court that the evidence was not admissible for the purpose of showing that defendant had committed a crime on Yetta, and they would not consider it for that purpose.
The defendant testified as a witness in his own behalf, and on cross-examination admitted that he was in bed with Yetta on the morning of May 15,—the day he was arrested,—but he testified that he did nothing to the girl, and in rebuttal the court, over the objection of the defendant, permitted three witnesses to testify that on the morning of May 15 they were in the defendant’s home and saw him in bed with Yetta Janzen, in the act of having criminal sexual intercourse with her. This evidence was admitted by the court, as stated at the time, on the following ground: “I wish to state that this evidence is admitted because the defendant, in his examination, testified that he had gone into this room and got into the bed with this girl, but had done nothing else. If it was material and competent
If the evidence of the girl, Yetta, and of the three other witnesses, in regard to what occurred on the morning of May 15, proves anything, it proves the defendant guilty of a rape on the person of Yetta Janzen,—an offense for which the defendant was not indicted and for which he was never put upon trial; and the question presented is, whether the admission of evidence which proves the defendant guilty of a crime not charged in the indictment is error for which the judgment should be reversed.
In Russell on Crimes (vol. 2, p. 772,) the author says: “No evidence can be admitted which does not tend to prove or disprove the issue joined. In criminal proceedings the necessity is stronger, if possible, than in civil, of strictly enforcing the rule that the evidence is to be confined to the point in issue. * * * It is therefore a general rule that the facts proved must be strictly relevant to the particular charge, and have no reference to any conduct of the prisoner unconnected with such charge.”
It will be remembered that the crime charged against the defendant in the indictment was a rape on the person of Mary Janzen. Any evidence which tended to prove the defendant guilty of the crime alleged in the indictment was proper for the consideration of the jury, but evidence which tended to prove him guilty of another crime—another rape—on some person not named in the indictment, was not competent., When a defendant is put upon trial on an indictment he is presumed to be ready to meet the charge contained in the indictment, but he is not presumed to be ready to defend against a charge not made against him therein, nor does the law require him to
In criminal cases, when it becomes necessary to prove a guilty knowledge on the part of a defendant, evidence of other offenses committed by him, though not charged in the indictment, may be admissible for that purpose. Thus, upon an indictment for uttering a forged bank note knowing it to be forged, evidence may be given of other forged notes having been uttered by the prisoner in order to show his knowledge of the forgery. (2 Russell on Crimes, 777.) The case under consideration, however, is not a case of that character, and the rule there announced has no application to this case. It is true that the court undertook to confine the application of the testimony of Yetta Janzen to the question why she had left home, and to confine the application of the evidence of the three witnesses to a mere contradiction of the defendant’s testimony that he had done nothing when in bed with Yetta. There are cases where evidence not admissible generally may be admitted for a single purpose, and may be confined to that purpose by the instruction of the court. But this is not a case of that character. Here the defendant was indicted for a rape on his own daughter,—a girl twelve years
Whether the defendant was guilty of the charge contained in the indictment was a,question for the jury, and it was the right of the defendant to have that question fairly submitted to them. That has not been done. The evidence of an independent offense was calculated to prejudice the jury, and we think it was error to admit that evidence.
The judgment will be reversed and the cause remanded.