James Willburn White v. Barbara White and Superior Court of the State of California, County of Merced, Honorable George G. Murry, JudgeJames Willburn White v. Barbara White and Superior Court of the State of California, County of Merced, Honorable George G. Murry, Judge
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Wallace
In 1978, Judge George G. Murry of the Superior Court of California, County of Merced, entered an interlocutory judgment dissolving the marriage of James Willburn White (James) and Barbara White (Barbara). The order distributing their community property provided in pertinent part that “[James’] United States Air Force Retirement is eighty percent (80%) community property and [Barbara] is awarded one-half or forty percent (40%) of said retirement benefits.” James did not appeal the interlocutory judgment or the final judgment entered in March 1979, nor did James challenge the state court’s jurisdiction.
In 1978 it was well established California law that military retirement benefits were community property subject to division in a dissolution proceeding.
In re Marriage of Fithian,
10 Cal.3d 592, 517 P.2d 449, 111 Cal.Rptr. 369 (1974). However, in June 1981, the Supreme Court announced its decision in
McCarty v. McCarty,
453 U.S. 210, 101 S.Ct. 2728, 69 L.Ed.2d 589 (1981), holding that federal law precluded state courts from dividing military retirement pay pursuant to state community property laws.
1
James immediately stopped paying
One week later James obtained a temporary restraining order (TRO) from the federal district court preventing enforcement of the interlocutory judgment and the contempt order. James also filed this action in the federal district court against Barbara, the superior court, and Judge Murry. He alleged causes of action for deprivation of civil and proprietary rights, for damages and declaratory judgment and for an injunction restraining the defendants from further proceedings in state court against James’ military retirement benefits. James alleged federal jurisdiction based on
Armstrong,
however, cannot conclusively dispose of James’ cause of action under
District courts have subject matter jurisdiction over suits brought under
We thus conclude that the district court erred in dismissing the
Nonetheless, the dismissal may be affirmed on the ground that James failed to state a claim upon which relief can be granted.
Keniston,
717 F.2d at 1300. An action may be dismissed for failure to state a claim if it appears certain that the plaintiff can prove no set of facts in support of his claim which would entitle him to relief.
Id.
James’ claim is based on his
[T]he argument that McCarty rendered contrary state court judgments void for lack of subject matter jurisdiction was foreclosed when the United States Supreme Court dismissed the appeal of In re Marriage of Sheldon, 124 Cal.App.3d 371, 177 Cal.Rptr. 380 (1981) for want of a substantial federal question. Sheldon v. Sheldon, 456 U.S. 941, 102 S.Ct. 2002, 72 L.Ed.2d 462 (1982).
696 F.2d at 1238. See also Whittington v. Whittington, 733 F.2d 620-621 (9th Cir.1984). A summary dismissal by the Supreme Court of an appeal from a state court for want of a substantial federal question operates as a decision on the merits on the challenges presented in the statement of jurisdiction. Carpenters Pension Trust, etc. v. Kronschnabel, 632 F.2d 745, 747 (9th Cir.1980), cert. denied, 453 U.S. 922, 101 S.Ct. 3159, 69 L.Ed.2d 1004 (1981). In Sheldon, one of the questions presented on appeal was:
Does federal preemption of state community property laws regarding division of military retirement pay render state judgments void for lack of subject matter jurisdiction where such judgments were entered after Congress had preempted area of law?
James argues nonetheless that his case is distinguishable from
Sheldon.
James contends that in
Sheldon
the state court did not uphold the validity of a state statute in the face of a federal law challenge, and that
Sheldon
should have invoked the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court by writ of certiorari rather than by appeal, thus giving
Sheldon
no precedential effect. These challenges are meritless. In the
Sheldon
appeal, the jurisdictional statement explicitly asserted that
We hold that no claim was stated. The judgment of the district court is AFFIRMED.
Notes
. Congress responded to the
McCarty
decision by enacting the Uniformed Services Former Spouses’ Protection Act,