Ingram v. LittleIngram v. Little
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Nisbet
By the Court.
Nisbet, J.delivering the opinion.
*184We think it clear that the early and latest cases in England hold an authority under seal necessary. We cannot err, therefore, in holding with them. We cannot doubt as to what is the settled rule of the C. Law, and that is obligatory upon this Court. This question w‘as brought before Ch. J. Marshall in the U. States vs. Nelson & Myers, and he ruled apparently with some doubt as to the reasonableness of his judgment, upon authority, in favor of the doctrine as I have stated it. He invoked an appeal by expressing the opinion that he would be reversed by the Supreme Court, U. S., but no appeal was taken. (2 Brockenhorough, 64.) That immaterial blanks in :a deed may be filled, upon parol authority, without invalidating fit, we do not doubt. Our judgment extends only to the case •made in this record. The Court therefore erred in admitting this deed as a muniment of title; but ayo do not send the ca le back on that error, because it Avas admissible to shoiv color of title under it] and as the plaintiff belovr must, in our judgment, recover on his Statutory title, the cause ought not to go back. Although inadmissible to support title, Ave hold as the presiding -Judge held, that it is admissible as color of title.
Our organic Law requires the grounds of exception to be specified, that the opposing counsel may be notified, and this Court informed of Avhat is claimed to be error. If the exception had been Avell taken, AYe should hold the testimony admissible.— When the statements of Thomas Little were made, the title of W. G: Little had not accrued. At that time Thomas Little claimed no title, and was in possession therefore as tenant to the true owner. His admissions that he had no title, were admissible to explain the character of his possession, and for the *185same reason his admissions as to his tenancy, under W. J. Little, after he bought the land, were admissable.
The doctrine of registry and notice has no application to this case, and the Court charged correctly as to fraud.
Let the judgment of the Court below he affirmed.