Vera Young petitions this court for a writ of mandamus directing the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York (Carter, J.) to grant her a jury trial in her wrongful discharge action against the United States Postal Service. Her petition presents an important question of first impression before this court. Petitioner claims that the clause in the Postal Reorganization Act that allows ■ the postal service to “sue and be sued”, 39 U.S.C. § 401(1), is not only a broad waiver of sovereign immunity but also subjects the postal service to trial by jury. We disagree and, for substantially the reasons stated in Judge Carter’s comprehensive opinion,
Petitioner relies on the Supreme Court’s recent decision in
Loeffler v. Frank,
— U.S. -,
Petitioner now argues that the waiver of sovereign immunity granted by the “sue and be sued” clause encompasses all normal incidents of suit, including the right to a jury trial. While “sue and be sued” clauses in federal statutes are indeed broad waivers of immunity and have subjected the federal government and its agencies to many types of liability and process, including prejudgment interest, liability for costs, and garnishment and attachment proceedings,
see Loeffler v. Frank; Reconstruction Finance Corp. v. J.G. Menihan Corp.,
The constitutional basis for a jury trial, the seventh amendment, simply does not apply in actions against the federal government.
See Lehman v. Nakshian,
Through the “sue and be sued” clause in the Postal Reorganization Act congress effectively waived sovereign immunity for the postal service, but the waiver does not change the fact that the party being sued is still the federal government. The postal service is an “independent establishment of the executive branch of the Government of the United States”. 39 U.S.C. § 201. Since the statute contains no language “affirmatively and unambiguously” granting a jury trial in suits against the postal service, the district court properly denied petitioner’s application.
The petition for mandamus is denied.
