In re Turgeon
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Thayer
The petitioner, Ronald ‘Turgeon, seeks a writ of certiorari challenging the sentence review division’s decision upholding a sentence imposed by the Superior Court (O’Neil, J.). He argues that the sentence is illegal under
In 1989, the petitioner was convicted of felonious sexual assault, a class B felony,
“Certiorari is an extraordinary remedy and is not granted as a matter of right but rather at the discretion of the court when the substantial ends of justice require such relief.” Melton v. Personnel Comm’n, 119 N.H. 272, 277, 401 A.2d 1060, 1063 (1979) (quotation omitted). “[T]he court may issue original writs of certiorari to determine whether a tribunal has acted illegally as to matters of jurisdiction, authority, or observance of the law.”, State v. N.H. Retail Grocers Ass’n, 115 N.H. 623, 625, 348 A.2d 360 362 (1975). “[C]ertiorari will not be granted where an adequati femedy is available on appeal.” Exeter & Hampton Electric Co. v. Public Utilities Commission, 108 N.H. 358, 359, 236 A.2d 486, 488 (1967) (quotation omitted).
The petitioner argues that the actions of the division were illegal because he did not qualify for an extended sentence under
*54The division is an administrative tribunal consisting of three members who are either superior court justices, senior justices, or retired superior court justices.
The petitioner argues that the division acted illegally in upholding the trial court’s sentence because the original sentence was unconstitutional and because the trial court erred as a matter of law in finding that the petitioner twice previously had been imprisoned. Even assuming that the petitioner is correct, he is not entitled to a writ of. certiorari.
The jurisdiction of the division is limited. While it can review “the sufficiency and accuracy of the information before the sentencing court,” SUPER. CT. SENTENCE REV. DlV. R. 22(a), it is not empowered to determine the constitutionality of a sentence. See
The legislature created the division to address a perceived inconsistency in sentencing within the State. N.H.S. JOUR. 535 (1975). The legislature intended the division “to make sure that the same crime fits the same sentence.” Id. Appeal to the division has not replaced a criminal defendant’s right to appeal trial court errors to this court; it simply provides an additional arena for defendants to seek redress.
*55Because alternative adequate means of challenging the constitutionality or legality of a sentence exist, granting certiorari in a case such as this would be inappropriate.
Petition denied.
All concurred.