In re the Rule upon the Western Marine & Fire Insurance
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Lawrence
delivered the opinion of the Court:
In July, 1862, the Circuit Court of Cook county, made an order appointing the Western Marine and Fire Insurance
In October, 1864, the bank made an assignment by deed of all its property to Dickinson, in trust for its creditors. At the date of the failure of the bank and its assignment, there was a balance to the credit of Church’s account, the exact amount of which is one of the matters in dispute, but as to which, in the view we take of the case, it is not necessary for us to express an opinion. Shortly after this assignment, Church obtained from the Circuit Court a rule nisi, which was afterwards made absolute, requiring Dickinson to pay into court, out of any money which had come into his hands as assignee, the sum of $3,798 65, the balance claimed by Church to be due. From this order Dickinson has prosecuted an appeal.
When a court makes an order appointing a particular person a depositary of the court funds, and such person, knowing of such order, accepts the deposit, he unquestionably becomes fro hoc vice, an officer of the court. The court may order him to refund the money, and if he fails to do so, without showing some valid reason, may proceed against him as for a contempt. The same rule would apply to a corporation, and if its officers, having control of its funds, and having the means of payment, belonging to the corporation, in their hands, should refuse to pay, they too might be proceeded against as for a contempt. It is not, however, because the debt due from the depositary to the court, is a debt of any more sacred or binding character
But let us go a step further. Suppose this depositary becomes insolvent^ with the court moneys in his hands, which he has received as a general deposit, and makes an assignment for the benefit of his common creditors, can his assignee be considered as a quasi officer of the court, and be proceeded against in a summary manner, and punished for contempt because he disobeys a summary order ? If the court deposit is made as a specific bailment for safe keeping, the same money deposited to be returned, and there is no change of ownership, then, doubtless, the court might follow its specific property wherever it could find it, and reclaim it even from an assignee. But we are speaking of a general deposit, which creates merely the ordinary relation of debtor and creditor, the money deposited having changed ownership, and becoming, until called for, the property of the depositary, and used by him as his own funds, such being the understanding when the deposit is made. Can an assignee of such a depositary be proceeded against in this manner? We are unable to see upon what grounds. He sustains no personal relation to the court. He •is, in no sense, an officer of the court. He has no property belonging to the court. He holds in his hands certain property in trust for the payment of certain debts, and among them a debt due to the court, but that debt, so far as he is concerned, stands upon the same footing with all other debts. The
It is not clear that even the officers of the bank knew that they were receiving the money under an order of the court. But admitting that they did, it is clear that it was simply received as a general deposit, and not as a bailment. The money deposited went into the general funds of the bank. The court was a general creditor of the bank, the character of its debt not being different from that of other creditors, but with a summary remedy against the officers of the bank in case of a contumacious refusal to pay upon the order of the court. But when the bank assigned to Dickinson, he took the property of the bank merely upon such trusts as were declared in the deed of assignment. He can administer the property only in conformity with those trusts. But the court, in the assignment, is placed upon a common level with all other creditors, Dickinson has no means in his hands with which to pay the debt due the court, except so far as the court is entitled to a dividend in common with other creditors. He is not, himself, the debtor of the court, he has no property in his hands belonging specifically to the court, and occupies no relation to
Mule discharged.