In re the Judicial Settlement of the Account of Proceedings of Title Guarantee & Trust Co., 264 A.D. 704

In re the Judicial Settlement of the Account of Proceedings of Title Guarantee & Trust Co.

264 A.D. 704 | N.Y. App. Div. | 1942

Dissenting Opinion

Martin, P. J.

(dissenting). The major portion of the surcharge against the corporate trustee herein is based on the practice of that trustee dealing with itself when investing in whole mortgages. The resort to devious efforts to have it *705appear that these whole mortgages were purchased from the affiliate leaves no doubt that the officials of the corporate trustee realized they were doing something unauthorized by law. Deliberate improper investments of estate funds and purchase of securities by a fiduciary from himself are reasons for denial of commissions to which a trustee is ordinarily entitled. (See discussion of subject in Matter of Taft, 145 Misc. 435.) Also, we are of the opinion that the dereliction of duty herein has been willful and characterized by bad faith, and, therefore, interest at the rate of six per cent should be imposed on the surcharge. (King v. Talbot, 40 N. Y. 76.)

The decree so far as appealed from should be modified so as to eliminate the provision for payment of any commissions to the corporate trustee, and so as to provide for the payment of interest at the rate of six per cent on the amount of the surcharge, and as so modified affirmed. The intermediate orders brought up for review should be affirmed.

O’Malley, J., talcing no part.

Lead Opinion

William F. Brown, one of the appellants, having died March 21, 1942, subsequent to the argument of the appeals, the following determination of said appeals is ordered to be entered nunc pro tunc as of January 6, 1942. Decree, so far as appealed from, affirmed, with costs to the respondent Ralph S. Daniels, as guardian and ancillary committee, etc., payable by the corporate trustee. No opinion.

Present' — Martin, P. J., O’Malley, Townley, Glennon and Untermyer, JJ.; Martin, P. J., dissents and votes to modify; dissenting opinion by Martin, P. J. Intermediate orders brought up for review unanimously affirmed. O’Malley, J., talcing no part.